Send us a text

🕯️ TheColdCases.com Podcast | True Crime & Cold Cases

In this gripping episode, Dustin Terry investigates the tragic and chilling murder story of Sunshine “Captain Sunny” Stewart, a beloved paddleboard instructor and former marine biologist found dead on Maine’s Crawford Pond in July 2025. What began as a mysterious disappearance quickly became a cold case turned homicide investigation, and weeks later, a 17-year-old male was arrested and charged.

This episode delves into the timeline of events, the initial police response, and the perspectives of Sunshine’s friends and family, exploring the human side of this true crime story. Through careful investigative journalism, we examine the evidence, the unresolved questions, and the factors that led to the arrest in this once unsolved crime.

If you’re drawn to cold cases, forgotten crimes, and real crime investigations, this episode provides a detailed and compelling look at one case that captivated a community and continues to demand justice.

🎧

Top Ten Cold Cases in Every State PDF
Discover the Top 10 Cold Cases in the U.S. 🕵️‍♂️ Download exclusive PDF & dive into the mysteries!
Become a Citizen Detective!
Unlock mysteries like a pro 🔎 Grab our Citizen Detective PDF & solve cold cases with us.
Get Our Criminal Psychology Crash Course
Learn Criminal Psychology Offered by TheColdCases.com Podcast! Only $5!
Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you.
Support the show

🎙️ At TheColdCases.com, we bring attention to cold cases, unsolved crimes, and forgotten crimes through powerful true crime stories and investigative journalism.

👉 Support our work by checking out our exclusive resources through our affiliate links inside this podcast:
• Citizen Detective PDF – Learn how to investigate cold cases responsibly.
• Criminal Psychology Crash Course – Understand the minds behind the crimes.
• Top Ten Cold Cases Across the USA PDF – Explore some of the most haunting mysteries still unsolved.

👉 Every download helps keep the podcast alive and continues shining a light on victims and families still waiting for justice.