Why the “No Kill” Movement Hurts More Than It Helps

The Pet Parent Hotline | Pet Parent Advice & Support for Overwhelmed Pet Parents

Content provided by Amy Castro. All podcast content including episodes, graphics, and podcast descriptions are uploaded and provided directly by Amy Castro or their podcast platform partner. If you believe someone is using your copyrighted work without your permission, you can follow the process outlined here https://podcastplayer.com/legal.

7M ago 53:15

MP3•Episode home

What if the no-kill movement isn’t saving animals but failing them?

It promised to end unnecessary euthanasia and revolutionize sheltering. But behind the glowing stats and feel-good slogans lies a much messier reality, one most people don’t want to talk about.

In this episode, I sit down with animal welfare expert Daniel Ettinger to expose the unintended consequences of chasing a 90 percent live release rate. From shelters closing their doors to avoid euthanasia to animals being warehoused for years, the system is cracking and those of us on the ground are feeling the weight.

As a longtime rescuer, I’ve seen firsthand how “no-kill” often means no space, no support, and no plan. Daniel introduces a better framework: SMART (Saving More Animals Responsibly Together), a humane, community-based approach rooted in transparency, responsible care, and real solutions.

🎧 By the time you finish listening, you’ll discover:

Why the 90 percent benchmark is doing more harm than good
How “saving” animals can sometimes mean compromising their quality of life
What the SMART approach offers that no-kill doesn't, and how you can help

If you’ve ever felt uneasy about what’s happening behind the scenes in animal rescue, this episode will make you feel seen and give you hope for a more honest path forward.

PS: You might hear us call the show Muddy Paws and Hairballs. That was our old name. Now we’re focused on helping you—the pet parent—not just your pets. You’re in the right place.

Support the show

Love the show? Share it with a pet parent living with chaos and don’t forget to leave a 5-star review so more can get the pet parent advice they need.

Please take our quick listener survey: https://survey.zohopublic.com/zs/ZbaTzF
Follow:🌍Official Site |📱Facebook |📺YouTube | 🍏 Apple |🎵Spotify

Pet parenting is tough, but this show delivers expert pet advice and solutions for real pet parenting struggles. Each week, we share pet care on a budget tips and pet saving hacks to help you stretch every dollar, whether it’s pet cost hacks for vet bills and pet food, or simple ways to make training and daily care easier. You’ll get dog training and behavior advice, cat care insights, and practical pet advice for everything from litter box issues to keeping multi-pet homes peaceful. We cover pet budgeting, managing pet behavior, stress-free vet visits, and home cleaning that actually works with pets. Follow for the support you need to stop chasing your tail and start enjoying life with pets.

Contact: [email protected] ©Ⓟ 2025 Amy Castro

Chapters

1. No-Kill Movement's Unintended Consequences (00:00:00)

2. Defining No-Kill: The Industry Confusion (00:03:16)

3. Closed Doors and Warehouse Sheltering (00:10:26)

4. Introducing SMART: A Better Approach (00:17:40)

5. Balancing Public Safety and Animal Welfare (00:22:32)

6. Community Support and Adoption Advocacy (00:35:59)

7. Working Together: Building a United Future (00:49:05)

137 episodes

#Animals and Pets #Amy Castro, MA, CSP #Amy Castro #CSP #Dog Training #Pet Adoption #Cat Behavior #Puppy Training #Cat Enrichment #Pet Advice #Puppy Socialization #Dog Separation Anxiety #Dog Body Language #Affordable Pet Care #Multi-pet Households #Understanding Dog Behavior #Society #Conversations #Podcasting Education