Split Decisions pits veteran family law attorneys Tim Miranda and Carlos Tavares against each other in mock-trial debates that show how powerful legal arguments can shape a case: and change the outcome! Each has 4 minutes or less to make their case. You be the judge.
In this head-to-head mock trial, they argue opposing sides of a high-stakes question: Should a restraining order be granted when one spouse alleges domestic abuse, but the other denies it ever happened?
The Case:
- A couple married for 23 years with two teenage children.
- The wife claims years of intimidation, stalking through technology, and verbal abuse.
- The husband says it’s exaggeration—admitting to drinking, swearing, and joking with the Tesla app, but denying abuse.
The Debate:
Carlos argues the wife’s safety and peace of mind require court protection.
Tim insists the evidence falls short of what the law demands.
You be the judge. Cast your verdict in the comments and poll — whose argument wins?
Follow for more legal battles, sharp insights, and real courtroom strategies from The AM Sidebar.