Send us a text

The quiet of a library can be louder than any scream. We open a door marked “preternatural” and step into reading rooms where stories don’t end at the last page: a coal-scented childhood library with a balcony watcher, a deserted building that typed without a working typewriter, and modern stacks where webcams tried to catch a Grey Lady in motion. What starts as one listener’s prompt becomes a map of haunted libraries—and what they teach us about place, memory, and the strange ways buildings hold on to people.
We compare two kinds of hauntings you’ll hear about again and again: legend-backed sites that turn every creak into a ghost, and sober reports from staff who log footsteps on upper floors, lights that refuse orders, and cold spots that sit in the same corner for years. From Peoria’s supposed curse that faded after renovation, to Pendleton’s intercom buzzes tied to a tragic loss, to Cairo’s “Toby” who favors special collections, we trace how architecture, history, and expectation shape experience. Bernardsville’s Phyllis Parker—honored with a library card—shows how communities adopt their ghosts, while Willard Library’s Grey Lady invites the internet in, turning surveillance into a shared investigation and sparking record traffic.
Along the way, we swap skeptic tools and believer instincts: check the pipes, log the temperatures, respect the archives, and still leave room for wonder when a chair slides back after you’ve pushed it in three times. The most compelling moments arrive in the seams—between renovation and ritual, between a locked vault and the click of phantom keys, between a beat cop’s shifting memory and a night that refuses to explain itself. If your town has a closed branch, a Carnegie relic, or a children’s room with a draft that smells like perfume, we want to hear it.
Enjoy the journey, then help us grow it—subscribe, share the show with a friend who loves a good library, and send your haunted branch or personal stack story through our website. Where should we open the next locked door?

Support the show