(#178) Manipulation vs Messaging: Where’s the Line?
Manage episode 524066708 series 2903868
In today’s episode, we’re pulling back the curtain on something we all feel but rarely talk about:
Why does so much of what we see online — protests, trends, “viral” moments, political messages — feel engineered?
And more importantly…
Where’s the line between honest persuasion and outright manipulation?
Kyle breaks down the gray area between influence and orchestration, exploring questions like:
What we cover in this episode:
- Why most public messaging (left, right, corporate, activist) is coordinated
- How “organic” viral moments often aren’t organic at all
- The blurry boundary between influence, strategy, and manipulation
- How social media algorithms amplify emotion — not truth
- Why transparency matters more than ever
- The ethics of engineering a message, even if the message itself is true
- How orchestrated narratives shape our culture without us realizing it
Kyle also shares:
- Research on political communication
- Studies on influencer persuasion
- Data on media trust and social media virality
- Real examples of modern messaging tactics (without naming groups or pointing fingers)
The big question we leave you with:
“If a message is true… but engineered… does it change how you feel about it?”
This episode is all about curiosity, not conclusions — and invites listeners to think deeply about the media ecosystem we live in, and how it shapes what we believe.
Links:
MIT Sloan research on misinformation spreading faster than truth
Study: Shares without clicks on Facebook and social platforms
UNESCO influencer fact checking study
KFF misinformation poll snapshot
Social Media:
Insta/X: kyleTHEhorton
Youtube: Kyletalkss
Tiktok: KyleTalkss
Intro: Head In The Clouds by Matthew Morelock
Outro: Surfaces Type Beat - Jellyfish Beats
179 episodes