In 1988, 19-year-old Tara Calico vanished during a bike ride near her New Mexico home. The only clue: a horrific Polaroid found nine months later, 1,500 miles away in Florida, showing a bound and gagged young woman who looked exactly like Tara. Investigators were tormented by the photo's ambiguity; was it a genuine clue or a malicious hoax? For years, the case stalled between local cover-up theories and interstate abduction. Now, the central puzzle remains: Was the Polaroid a desperate plea from the victim confirming she was alive, or was it a killer's deliberate taunt?

WARNING: This case discusses a decades-old disappearance, unsettling theories of police misconduct, and disturbing images of potential captivity. Listener discretion is strongly advised.

So, buckle up! And while you're getting settled, please take a quick moment to share, review, and rate our podcast. Your support truly means the world to us! Now, let's go.

Join the Gossip At The Gravestone community on Facebook!

✨ Support the show through our Patreon: patreon.com/GossipAtTheGravestone