Imagine sharing a district with nine times as many people as the voters next door and getting the same single representative. That stark imbalance was common before Baker v. Carr, and it’s the starting point for our deep dive into how the Supreme Court reshaped representation, why one person, one vote became the baseline, and where the law is drifting now.
We sit down with Professor Stephen Wermiel to unpack the two-step process that changed modern apportionment. First came Baker v. Carr in 1962, which opened the courthouse doors by declaring that extreme population disparities in legislative districts can violate the Equal Protection Clause. Then, in Reynolds v. Sims in 1964, the court set the rule: districts must be drawn with roughly equal populations. That pairing forced states to redraw maps nationwide, bringing urban and rural representation closer to parity and making legislative power track people, not old boundaries.
But equal headcounts didn’t end the fight over power. We explore how partisan gerrymandering flourished within the population rule, as mapmakers learned to pack and crack voters to entrench party control. The Court has largely walled off federal challenges to partisan gerrymanders, holding that these disputes don’t present manageable constitutional standards. At the same time, we dig into the line the Court did draw: racial gerrymandering and vote dilution. For decades, voters could challenge maps that dispersed minority communities to weaken their voice under the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments. Now, a pending case from Louisiana could narrow or even close that pathway, signaling a significant shift in how racial vote dilution claims are treated in federal court.
Across the conversation, we connect doctrine to real-world stakes: school funding, roads, taxes, and who gets heard at the Capitol. You’ll come away with a clear map of how Baker v. Carr changed the game, why Reynolds v. Sims matters every redistricting cycle, and what today’s legal battles could mean for fair representation tomorrow. If conversations about maps, power, and democracy matter to you, press play, share this with a friend, and leave a quick review to help others find the show.

Check Out the Civic Literacy Curriculum!

School of Civic and Economic Thought and Leadership

Center for American Civics