Best Evidence Locker Podcasts (2025)

101
The North Pole Slaying Plot - Foiled | Alaska (Revisited) 18:39

Play Pause

1d ago18:39

18:39

Every December, thousands of letters addressed to Santa are sent to North Pole, Alaska. Boxes full of letters are then sent to North Pole Middle School, where they are included in the 6th Grade curriculum: North Pole’s 11 and 12-year-olds are nominated as Santa’s little helpers and reply to all the letters on Santa’s behalf. But in April 2006, the …

1
The Evidence Locker | Natalia Grace 1:20:30

28d ago1:20:30

1:20:30

The three mustaches open up the evidence locker once again to bring you a very special episode featuring the amazingly talented Clayne Crawford. Clayne has starred in films such as A Walk to Remember and currently plays the role of Coach Dobbs alongside Glen Powell in the Hulu series Chad Powers. In this episode, they will be telling the story of N…

1
100 | Episode 100 Extravaganza | 911 Calls 2:15:37

11h ago2:15:37

2:15:37

The three mustaches get in the Christmas spirit and celebrate the 100th episode of Crime Corner! And what better way to kick off the holidays than listening to 911 calls from horrific murders? Jessie curated some of her favorite 911 calls and it's up to Coop and Ryan to figure out whether the person on the other end of the line is an innocent victi…

1
99 | OJ Simpson Part One | OJ Played Football? 2:08:31

7d ago2:08:31

2:08:31

The three mustaches are joined by three-time best-selling author, podcast legend, and father of Jessie's children, ROSS PATTERSON! In order to not overshadow our esteemed guest, we decided to cover an obscure case from the early '90s known as the OJ Simpson Murder Trial. When the bodies of Nicole Brown Simpson and Ronald Goldman are discovered outs…

1
248: The Orderud Murders | Norway 20:10

11d ago20:10

20:10

In May 1999, three members of the Orderud family were found shot to death in their home in rural Norway. The victims — Kristian and Marie Orderud and their daughter Anne — had been killed in the dead of night in what appeared to be a cold and calculated execution. Despite four people being convicted of complicity, no one has ever been held legally …

1
The Wildest Headlines of 2025 (with Ricki-Lee, Tim & Joel) 12/12/25 11:53

15d ago11:53

11:53

We put Nova radio hosts Ricki-Lee, Tim & Joel to the test with a rapid-fire quiz covering the biggest headlines of 2025 — from viral sports moments to showbiz shake-ups and weird global firsts. For more, head to news.com.au See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.By news.com.au

1
98 | Natalie Cochran | War Dogs of West Virginia 1:42:56

14d ago1:42:56

1:42:56

The three mustaches take the country road home to West Virginia to tell the story of Michael and Natalie Cochran. When Natalie traded her career as a pharmacist for the life of a weapons dealer, it made her and Michael rich overnight. But, they soon learned that running a business is no easy task, especially when you’re handling high-dollar governm…

1
Royal Secrets Revealed: Missing Jewels, Closed-Door Meetings and MI5 Deals 05/12/25 19:19

22d ago19:19

19:19

news.com.au’s Bronte Coy chats to royal author Robert Jobson about the scandals rocking the monarchy. From Andrew and Epstein to the theft of royal jewels, the bitter Charles-William-Harry split, and the secrets behind palace walls that could threaten the future of the Crown. For more, head to news.com.au See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy inf…

1
97 | Linda Hazzard | Health Hazard 1:49:51

21d ago1:49:51

1:49:51

The three mustaches check into a health and wellness retreat to start working off the pounds they gained during Thanksgiving. Luckily, under the watchful eye of Linda Hazzard, they're guaranteed to lose a few inches off of their waistline. In fact, Linda may be a little too good at helping people lose weight... Support this podcast at — https://red…

1
247: The Vampire of Bucharest | Romania 21:08

25d ago21:08

21:08

Between 1970 and 1971, a series of brutal murders terrified the streets of Bucharest. The victims were mostly women — attacked at night, bitten, and mutilated. Their killer became known as The Vampire of Bucharest. His crimes were frenzied and disturbing, leaving investigators to wonder whether they were dealing with a deranged killer or a man driv…

1
Jonesy & Amanda: Why We Drank Each Other's Blood 28/11/25 21:31

29d ago21:31

21:31

After two decades on air, Jonesy & Amanda reveal the moments that shaped them, including the risky bets, the deep regrets, the chaos, the laughs, and yes… the day they drank each other’s blood. For more, head to news.com.au See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.By news.com.au

1
Ashes Chaos: The Three Moments That Shocked Cricket 21/11/25 15:42

1M ago15:42

15:42

Cricket tragic and Half-Arsed History host Riley Knight joins us to revisit the three most controversial moments in Ashes history — from Dennis Lillee’s infamous metal bat stunt to Jonny Bairstow’s explosive stumping. For more, head to news.com.au See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.By news.com.au

1
96 | The Evidence Locker | Ellen Rae Greenberg 1:42:40

1M ago1:42:40

1:42:40

You asked for it, and the three mustaches listened. This week, we're cracking open the Evidence Locker and bringing you an previously unreleased episode! On a cold, winter night in 2011, 28-year-old Ellen Rae Greenberg was found dead in her Pennsylvania apartment. She had received a total of 20 stab wounds, 10 of which were to her back and neck. Th…

1
246: Fugitive Mom, Dorothy Lee Barnett | USA/Australia 21:04

1M ago21:04

21:04

In 1994, a custody dispute in South Carolina ended with a mother vanishing with her infant daughter. Dorothy Lee Barnett, accused of violating a court order, disappeared without a trace — along with 11-month-old Savannah. For nearly two decades, the pair lived under new identities across the world — first in Europe, then South Africa, then Australi…

1
Mushroom Murders: The Evidence That Sealed Erin Patterson’s Fate 14/11/25 14:57

1M ago14:57

14:57

When Erin Patterson was found guilty over the mushroom murders, jurors said the evidence spoke for itself. But what exactly did they see? In this episode, we speak with writer Greg Haddrick, who followed the case closely to unpack the most shocking moments from the trial and the evidence that sealed Erin’s fate. For more, head to news.com.au See om…

1
95 | Emily Noble | Suicide Surrounds Them 2:15:36

1M ago2:15:36

2:15:36

The three mustaches take a journey to the greatest state in America to cover the tragic case of Emily Noble. In May of 2020 in Westerville, Ohio, police received a report of a woman that was possibly missing. When they begin investigating, they notice that her laid-back husband, Matt, is acting a little too laid-back. Did he have something to do wi…

1
AFL Star Isaac Heeney on Sydney Sweeney, Filthy DMs and Locker Room Antics 07/11/25 18:04

2M ago18:04

18:04

Sydney Swans champ and Telstra ambassador Isaac Heeney told us he would answer any question we had for him, no matter how unhinged. Trust us, we really pushed the limits. For more, head to news.com.au See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.By news.com.au

1
94 | Kristil Krug | Stalk a Mile in My Shoes 2:09:54

2M ago2:09:54

2:09:54

The three mustaches travel to Colorado to cover the case of Kristil Krug and her noodly-armed husband, Daniel. When Kristil rejects the advances of a former boyfriend, she soon learns that her old flame has deadly intentions. Unfortunately, her husband is about as masculine as a West Hollywood hairdresser, so it’s up to her to protect her family. M…

1
245: The Butcher of Mons: Belgium’s Unsolved Suitcase Murders | Belgium 20:44

2M ago20:44

20:44

Between 1996 and 1997, the dismembered remains of at least five women were found stuffed in garbage bags and dumped inside suitcases around the Belgian city of Mons. The killer, who came to be known as Le Dépeceur de Mons — The Butcher of Mons — has never been identified. The murders shocked the quiet provincial city and left investigators chasing …

1
Trinity the Tuck Spills on Taylor Swift, Kylie Minogue & Dodgy Stunt Doubles 31/10/25 14:45

2M ago14:45

14:45

Drag superstar Trinity the Tuck spills all, from working with Taylor Swift to making her wild new Tubi movie Slay. She also dishes on what she really thinks of Australia’s biggest personalities. There's no filter, but it's all fun. For more, head to news.com.au See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.…

1
The Craving Loop: Beat Cravings When Stressed, Bored & Tired 13:24

2M ago13:24

13:24

The Craving Loop: Beat Cravings When Stressed, Bored & Tired Ep.04 - 13 min Get in touch: Instagram: instagram.com/prolificfitness.co Website: prolificfitness.co Why do cravings hit hardest when you’re tired, stressed, or bored? Whether it’s the 3 p.m. slump at work, the drive-home “screw it” moment, or the 9 p.m. pantry raid, those urges aren’t ra…

1
93 | Lois Riess | The Gambling Granny 2:16:17

2M ago2:16:17

2:16:17

The three mustaches grab their lucky four-leaf clovers to cover the case of Losing Streak Lois. This poor woman just couldn’t seem to catch a break. First her husband gets gunned down in their own home, then her new friend Pamela Hutchinson turns up dead. To make matters worse, she keeps losing all of her money at the casinos. If bad luck seems to …

1
The Black Magic Murders (Adolfo Constanzo) | Mexico - Revisited 45:13

2M ago45:13

45:13

In celebration of Halloween, this week’s episode is a re-release of one of our first episodes - still chilling... Adolfo Constanzo, also known as El Padrino (or the Godfather), was the leader of a cult that believed that Black Magic would shield their drug cartel from being busted. Adolfo encouraged human sacrifice, and countless people fell victim…

1
A Fast Train From Sydney to Melbourne: Will It Actually Happen? 24/10/25 12:58

2M ago12:58

12:58

Australia’s been dreaming of a fast train from Sydney to Melbourne for decades - but will it ever leave the station? We speak to Professor Christopher Pettit from UNSW to find out how likely high-speed rail really is, and when we might finally get on track. For more, head to news.com.au See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.…

1
92 | Donna Adelson | All in the Family 2:29:26

2M ago2:29:26

2:29:26

The three mustaches get together to tackle a convoluted, murder-for-hire case out of Tallahassee, Florida. When 41-year-old law professor, Dan Markel, is brutally gunned down in his driveway by two members of the Latin Kings gang, investigators are baffled. Why would a violent street gang want a middle-aged, white-collar attorney dead? And why the …

1
244: The Halloween Candy Killer, Ronald O'Brien | USA 18:15

2M ago18:15

18:15

On Halloween night in 1974, eight-year-old Timothy O’Brien came home from trick-or-treating in Deer Park, Texas, excited to sample his candy haul. Among the treats was a Pixy Stix — one that would become infamous in American true crime history. Within hours, Timothy was dead, poisoned by cyanide. Investigators soon discovered that the killer wasn’t…

1
What Greta Thunberg Is Really Like Behind the Scenes 17/10/25 17:58

2M ago17:58

17:58

When a flotilla carrying humanitarian aid to Gaza was reportedly attacked by a drone, journalist Yusuf Omar was on board — alongside Greta Thunberg. In this episode, he relives the chaos at sea, the moment their vessel caught fire, and reveals what Greta is really like when the cameras aren’t rolling. For more, head to news.com.au See omnystudio.co…

1
91 | Donna Scrivo | Donna Dearest 1:25:50

2M ago1:25:50

1:25:50

The three mustaches put on some leathers and hop into their war rig to tackle a case from the post-apocalyptic wasteland known as Detroit. When Donna Scrivo’s 32-year-old son, Ramsay, went missing in the winter of 2014, investigators weren’t prepared for the insanity that followed. What began as a manhunt soon turned into murder investigation where…

1
The Politician Who Died Mid-Shag and Other Strange Deaths 10/10/25 15:40

3M ago15:40

15:40

Half-Arsed History host Riley Knight joins us to talk about some of history’s strangest deaths — from a politician who died while doing the deed to a Viking bitten by a severed head. Honestly, you couldn’t make this stuff up. For more, head to news.com.au See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.…

1
90 | Robert Eugene Brashers | Yogurt Shop Justice 2:00:13

3M ago2:00:13

2:00:13

The three mustaches convene to discuss a shocking breakthrough in a number of decades-old cold cases. After nearly 40 years, the monster responsible for the horrific Yogurt Shop Murders has finally been given a serving of justice. Unfortunately, he’s been dead for 25 years so he won’t be getting any prison time. Although a genealogist named CeCe Mo…

1
243: Diary of a Death Factory (Vlakplaas) | South Africa 23:12

3M ago23:12

23:12

For nearly two decades, a nondescript farm outside Pretoria was the epicenter of South Africa’s most covert and brutal campaign of state-sponsored terror. Known as Vlakplaas, it served as headquarters for a police death squad targeting anti-Apartheid activists. Under the leadership of Colonel Dirk Coetzee and later Eugene de Kock – dubbed “Prime Ev…

1
The Most Devastating Death Message a Police Officer Ever Delivered 03/10/25 13:41

3M ago13:41

13:41

Mark Meredith has spent 38 years as a NSW police officer delivering some of the toughest news imaginable - death messages. In this episode, he reveals how officers handle that task before sharing a personal story that changed his life forever. Check out fortemaustralia.org.au For more, head to news.com.au See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy inf…

1
89 | Laurie Shaver | A Close Shaver 1:45:25

3M ago1:45:25

1:45:25

The three mustaches head to the happiest place on Earth to dig up some dirt on the disappearance of Michael Shaver. After spending two years sending rude and cryptic messages to his family, the Lake County Sheriff's Department finally decides to look into what drove a man to suddenly abandon his wife and two children. This case is sure to raise som…

1
Want Porn? You’ll Have to Prove You’re Over 18 - 26/09/25 12:13

3M ago12:13

12:13

A major change is coming to the way Australians access adult content online. From December, anyone wanting to view porn will have to prove they’re over 18 — not on adult sites, but at the search engine level. What does that mean for your Google account, your privacy, and your options for getting around it? We ask Professor Lisa Given from RMIT. For…