Olivia, Kylie, and Abby have been best friends since kindergarten, until a messy divorce sent Olivia to California to live with her mom. Eighteen months later, Olivia is back in Eugene, Nebraska and struggling to reconnect with her friends. On Christmas Eve, the three girls each receive the same mysterious games console under their tree before Kylie disappears. Can Olivia and Abby find Kylie before it's too late, and uncover the strange origins of the present they each received?