Best Scott Mathie Podcasts (2025)

1
Dante's Inferno Pt. 2 - Violence Begets Violence 1:05:54

Play Pause

1d ago1:05:54

1:05:54

Our tour through the underworld continues as David leads Michael through the remainder of the sixth and seventh circles of Hell. Learn which Pope was heretical, what happens to violent souls, and how to summon your own "monster of fraud!" **Content warning - This episode features heavy religious imagery and self-harm**…

1
The Lord's Animals and the Devil's; The Beam; The Old Beggar Woman; The Three Sluggards; The Twelve Idle Servants; The Shepard Boy 44:00

9d ago44:00

44:00

Story overload! Michael brings David a plethora of Brothers Grimm tales and puts David to the test writing too many lessons. PLUS - see how confidently wrong Michael is when it comes to foreign royalty!

1
Dante's Inferno Pt. 1 - Abandon All Hope 1:25:49

23d ago1:25:49

1:25:49

Hells bells! David surprises Michael this week with a journey through the underworld. Michael learns where some of his favorite video game characters' names come from, what happens to unbaptized babies, and how terrible Florence is, just for starters! Let's get metal!

1
The Donkey; The Turnip; The Old Man Made Young Again 49:26

1M ago49:26

49:26

We return to pre-industrial Europe as we grow ever closer to the end of the Brothers Grimm! Unexpected themes pop up and Michael REFUSES to do a celebrity impression. PLUS! Anti-aging tips for from times past!

1
American Cryptids Pt. 4 - The West 58:53

1M ago58:53

58:53

After a few side-trips, the boys finally finish their journey across the creepy cryptids of the United States. We finally talk about Bigfoot, aliens, and of course, a spooky little dog. Follow along with the images here! https://photos.app.goo.gl/ynXk2YJ61XfsKsfo8

1
Knoist and His Three Sons; The Maid of Brakel; The Lambkin and the Little Fish; Simeli Mountain; Going A Traveling 44:24

2M ago44:24

44:24

We're absolutely overflowing with stories this week! Granted, some are small, but at least David also hates them! Brush your teeth and dive in as we make our way even closer to the end of the Brothers Grimm!

1
Leaks, Lights, and Long Trips ft. Mike Mathis 1:54:15

2M ago1:54:15

1:54:15

Mike Mathis returns with more news of the strange! He's got a lot to talk about since last he was here, and David and Michael are only too happy to let him! From UFO leaks to personal strange sightings to the underpinning consciousness of the universe, it's all here! Check out our friends at the Chilluminati Pod! https://chilluminatipod.fm/…

1
Superman: Up in the Sky Pt. 2 1:15:23

2M ago1:15:23

1:15:23

David fights through some bad news this week to bring us the exciting and touching conclusion to Superman: Up in the Sky! Race against the Flash, confront your jerk side, and have a burger with Batman all in this exciting episode! Superman: Up in the Sky from creative team Tom King and Andy Kubert

1
Iron John, The Three Black Princesses, Domestic Servant 55:08

3M ago55:08

55:08

The boys are back and getting ever closer to finishing the tales from the Brothers Grimm! Learn the value of a child ($600), how not to look at women, and what to say to your man Cham!

1
Superman: Up in the Sky Pt.1 1:03:55

3M ago1:03:55

1:03:55

Up in the sky! It's a bird, it's a plane, it's one of David's favorite Superman stories! In celebration of the upcoming movie we're taking a journey all through the galaxy as only Supes can! From creative team Tom King and Andy Kubert

1
Brat Mitzvah (feat. Sydney Heller) 1:12:28

3M ago1:12:28

1:12:28

We hit the jackpot this week! It's time for a non-fiction Story Time as our friend Sydney Heller come on to tell us all about her Vegas bat mitzvah (note: we did not tell her this was what she would be talking about). Find Sydney on Youtube and Patreon @SydandOlivia! http://www.youtube.com/@SydAndOlivia https://www.patreon.com/syd_and_olivia…

1
The Fox and the Horse; The Shoes That Were Danced to Pieces; The White Bride and the Black Bride 55:14

4M ago55:14

55:14

We're back with a vengeance! It's a triple tale treat today as Michael brings us more Brothers Grimm tales and David once again has FEELINGS about HORSES. *Note - Michael did in fact not send David the picture he said he took, so now no one gets to see it.

1
American Cryptids Pt. 3 - The Midwest 1:13:21

4M ago1:13:21

1:13:21

Our tour of the American Cryptid scene continues as we make our way through the great Midwest! Spooky worms, Dogmen, and crazy sounds abound in this week's episode! Follow along with the images of these Cryptids here: https://photos.app.goo.gl/Wt43kh8w14Z7QUBP6

1
The Crystal Buddha; The Pine Tree Lovers 49:20

4M ago49:20

49:20

It's time for a folk tale detour! We address a glaring oversight from our email past, and in the process get two great Japanese folk tales for today's stories! That's a win win!

1
American Cryptids Pt. 2 - The South 1:17:31

5M ago1:17:31

1:17:31

Our tour of weird and creepy America continues this week as we head down south (and southwest) for more cryptids! The Chupacabra, the Mothman, and many more await! Pictures of the Cryptids found here: https://photos.app.goo.gl/nu7jnAiaNqN5WXrp6

1
The Four Skillful Brothers; One Eye, Two Eyes, and Three Eyes 50:32

5M ago50:32

50:32

It's time for a double dose of fairy tales and for what may be the first time ever, Michael has chosen NOT to tell one! Everybody thank him for not telling us a garbage tale by listening to the ones that made the cut!

1
American Cryptids Pt. 1 - The Northeast 1:16:52

5M ago1:16:52

1:16:52

It's time to explore the creepy and mysterious creatures in our own (American) backyards! David brings the first region in his Cryptid tour, the northeast. Champ, Puckwudgies, The Dover Demon, and more! The pictures David shows Michael during he episode can be found here (they might not be in the right order in the album though so...good luck!): ht…

1
Ferdinand the Faithful; The Iron Stove 1:00:48

5M ago1:00:48

1:00:48

We're back with a "new" season of Story Time! In honor of that we're bringing Grimm's Brothers tales that at times sound...very familiar.

1
Animorphs FINALE: Pt. 54 - The Beginning 1:33:49

6M ago1:33:49

1:33:49

The time has finally arrived, and one way or another the war with the Yeerks will end today! Join the boys for the emotional conclusion to our much longer than expected series, The Animorphs. Who lives? Who dies? Who gets Cinnabons? Are you ready for it to be over? Too bad, it is!

1
The Old Woman in the Wood; The Three Brothers; The Devil and His Grandmother 50:27

6M ago50:27

50:27

It's a veritable checklist of fairy tale tropes! Michael brings in more Brothers Grimm, and they hit basically everything we've come to expect (and sometimes love)! Breaking and entering, inheritance conflicts, and we continue to expand on the devil's family tree!

1
Animorphs: The Ellimist Chronicles 1:41:49

7M ago1:41:49

1:41:49

The countdown to the end continues today with the penultimate book in the entire Animorphs series - The Ellimist Chronicles. We finally get answers to what the heck the seemingly all-powerful Ellimist's deal is, as well as the origins of his adversarial relationship with the terrifying Crayak! Plus - a tiny hint to what will happen in the last Anim…

1
The Three Apprentices; Donkey Cabbages 50:28

7M ago50:28

50:28

It's time for a double serving of silliness! First Michael takes David on a magical road trip with friends, followed by a lesson in the power of...salad? All this episode!

1
Animorphs Pt. 53 - The Answer 1:41:48

7M ago1:41:48

1:41:48

The beginning of the end is here! All out war is upon our alien-fighting kids, and Jake has to make some of the hardest decisions yet. PLUS - We learn some details previously kept secret and David comes clean about perpetuating that deception! You can't miss this one!

1
The Willful Child; The Three Army Surgeons; The Seven Swabians 42:17

7M ago42:17

42:17

We're back after some minor technical difficulties! What better way to celebrate than with some wild fairy tales?

1
Animorphs Pt. 52 - The Sacrifice 1:22:43

8M ago1:22:43

1:22:43

The countdown to the end continues as David brings the last Ax centric book from the Animorphs! With lots going down following the public outing of the Yeerk invasion by the governor, the kids have to make a choice whether or not to cross a line they've long hesitated crossing and Ax himself must decide where is true loyalties lie...…

1
The Cunning Little Tailor; The Bright Sun Brings It To Light; The Blue Light 52:28

8M ago52:28

52:28

It's a triple story day! Michael brings a few fairy tales- some good, some weird, and some possibly with the opposite of good morals.

1
Animorphs Pt. 51 - The Absolute 1:20:56

8M ago1:20:56

1:20:56

It's a new year, same alien invasion! This week the kids notice some suspicious military activity, and it all goes downhill from there! PLUS - David recounts one of his worst internet memories!

1
The Two Kings' Children 46:28

9M ago46:28

46:28

The holidays are upon us! To celebrate, the boys are doing nothing at all out of the ordinary as Michael brings another fairy tale to the show. David...has opinions on it, and Michael reveals the name of David's drag persona.

1
Animorphs Pt. 50 - The Ultimate 1:21:23

10M ago1:21:23

1:21:23

Things continue ramping up as we crest the last 5 books in the Animorphs series! After evacuating most of their families to the Hork-Bajir valley, tensions are running high, and the kids finally decide on a drastic measure to even the odds...

1
The Talking Cranberries; The Queer Little Baker 38:22

10M ago38:22

38:22

Better late than never! Michael brings David a couple Thanksgiving based tales of...dubious origin, and David couldn't be more thankful for them. Grab your favorite Thanksgiving loaf and jump in!

1
Animorphs Pt. 49 - The Diversion 1:19:19

10M ago1:19:19

1:19:19

The boys are back and diving into the next chapter of the Animorphs saga... and it is a doozy! The kids have always dreaded what would happen if the yeerks ever figure out they're human, and it looks like that might be close to happening! Don't miss the huge events taking place in this episode!

1
Pre-Show, The Show! 1:13:59

10M ago1:13:59

1:13:59

When is an episode not an episode? This week! The boys were feeling a little overwhelmed the past couple weeks and so spent what should have been their recording time just checking in with each other and talking for the first time in a couple weeks. In this episode: The Election Getting a CPAP Machine Disneyland Aliens Pokemon TCG Pocket (we had a …

1
The Skillful Hunter 38:05

11M ago38:05

38:05

It's time for a treat-sized fairy tale featuring plenty of tricks! Giants, tiny dogs, and surprisingly down-to-earth princesses await!

1
The Book of Mormon - The Plan of Happiness (feat. Scott Brazee) 1:04:44

11M ago1:04:44

1:04:44

The boys are joined once again by resident fun-uncle Scott! Here to tell us the overall plan of the universe and our very souls...at least according to Joseph Smith. Join us as we find out where we came from and more importantly, where we'll end up! Don't forget to follow Scott on Instagram @Scott.Milton…

1
Animorphs Pt. 48 - The Return 1:08:55

11M ago1:08:55

1:08:55

David is back to tell the next chapter of The Animorphs and wouldn't you know it...David is back! Rachel faces her inner (and outer) demons as everybody's least favorite rat returns to exact revenge...But is there something more sinister waiting just under the surface?

1
The Two Travelers 1:00:49

11M ago1:00:49

1:00:49

Time for some travel tips, courtesy of The Brothers Grimm! How heavy is bread? What should you do with the water under a dying man? How do you pronounce foal? Answers to these questions and more!

1
Animorphs Pt. 47 - The Resistance 1:11:55

12M ago1:11:55

1:11:55

The countdown to the end continues as the Animorphs become aware of an immediate problem - The Hork-Bajir Valley has been compromised! PLUS - A Civil War era flashback!

1
The Book of Mormon Pt. 4 - The End? (feat. Scott Brazee) 1:16:13

1y ago1:16:13

1:16:13

It's the war to end all wars (until the next one)! Scott joins us to finish telling the story of the Book of Mormon, and like all good stories the end just leaves us with more questions! Follow Scott on Instagram @Scott.Milton

1
The Poor Miller's Boy and the Cat; The Jew Among Thorns 58:26

1y ago58:26

58:26

Get ready for a duo of...uh... questionable stories. David relates a little too much to the first, and feels VERY uncomfortable for the second. Just remember - STEREOTYPES ARE NO FUN

1
Animorphs Pt. 46 - The Deception 1:12:19

1y ago1:12:19

1:12:19

The final TEN Animorphs countdown has begun! Things really get out of hand this week as the kids and Ax are faced with the biggest scale problem they've yet encountered. When the dust settles, will the team's relationships survive?

1
The Willow Wren and the Bear; Wise Folks 44:50

1y ago44:50

44:50

The drums of war are sounding in this week's duo of fairy tales, and the animals all must pick a side! Plus - proof that you can always find someone stupider!

1
Animorphs Pt. 45 - The Revelation 1:17:03

1y ago1:17:03

1:17:03

Let the countdown begin! Things are getting serious for our favorite band of child-soldiers, in particular for Marco and his family. What happens in this episode will change things from here on out!

1
The Book of Mormon Pt. 3 - The Drums of War (feat. Scott Brazee) 1:20:43

1y ago1:20:43

1:20:43

We're back and it's time for a showdown! Scott returns to continue the saga of the Book of Mormon, and war is brewing. Hang on to your arms, because it's about to get wild! And check out Scott's art on instagram @Scott.Milton

1
Animorphs Pt. 44 - The Unknown 1:06:40

1y ago1:06:40

1:06:40

Time for a trip! Cassie finds herself on a wild adventure down under, and we learn about what the inside of a kangaroo's pouch is like!

1
The Book of Mormon Pt. 2 - Fail, Lose, Die (feat. Scott Brazee) 55:09

1y ago55:09

55:09

We're back to ancient times again as the story of the Church of Latter-Day Saints continues! Families split, cities founded, and the seeds of war are planted! Follow Scott's art on Instagram @Scott.Milton

1
The Spirit in the Bottle; Bearskin 55:53

1y ago55:53

55:53

The boys brave the heat to bring two surprisingly fun Grimm's Brothers stories! Stranglers, bears, and Devils abound! PLUS - David reveals what his first middle school dance experience was like.

1
The Book of Mormon Pt. 1 - We're On a Boat (feat. Scott Brazee) 1:03:22

1+ y ago1:03:22

1:03:22

Boy oh boy do we have a special treat this week! Our friend Scott is here to give us an introduction to the Book of Mormon, and it is so exciting! Swords and storms and energy blasts abound in this newer but ancient tale of family and faith! Follow Scott's art on Instagram @Scott.Milton

1
Animorphs Pt. 43 - The Test 1:14:58

1+ y ago1:14:58

1:14:58

David has recovered from being sick and to celebrate has brought the next chapter in the Animorphs saga featuring everybody's favorite brooding bird, Tobias! A former enemy appears with an offer the group can't refuse, but what will it cost them?

1
The Water of Life; Stories of Snakes; Sweet Porridge 46:03

1+ y ago46:03

46:03

We have a grab bag of fairy tale tropes today! A classic tale of brothers' ambition, a few short tales of snakes, and a warning we can all agree with!

1
The Three Little Birds; Dr. Know All 40:21

1+ y ago40:21

40:21

Michael continues his last episodes theme of a bird-based tale, followed by an abandonment of that theme for a farcical look at becoming a doctor.