Best Obsessed With Disappeared Podcasts (2025)

1
255: The Girl Who Died Twice (Curious Case Of…) 1:13:41

1h ago1:13:41

1:13:41

In 1981, thirteen-year-old Mary Day vanishes and Investigators suspect her stepfather may have killed her, but they never recover her body; decades later, a woman claiming to be Mary appears, stirring suspicions on what happened. This Week’s Sponsors: Allermi - Head to allermi.com and use code THINK at checkout for 60% off your order Blissy - Go to…

1
Unanswered Questions – The Death of Elisa Lam 1:42:46

12h ago1:42:46

1:42:46

In this episode of Super SUS, we explore one of the most chilling and perplexing mysteries in modern true crime: the case of Elisa Lam. In January 2013, 21-year-old Elisa Lam checked into the infamous Cecil Hotel in downtown Los Angeles during a solo trip from Vancouver. Days later, she vanished without a trace. The last known footage of Elisa—elev…

1
256: True Crime Rundown: The Trials of Diddy and Karen Read Part 2 39:31

1h ago39:31

39:31

Welcome to this special nighttime surprise! In this week's installment of True Crime Rundown, we cover everything that has happened in the trials of Diddy and Karen Read since last last week through Monday evening. Best to enjoy with a gummy.By I Think Not!

1
430: Biggest Heist Ever 1:02:51

35m ago1:02:51

1:02:51

Their crime earned them the nickname "Bitcoin Bonnie & Clyde"...but are they? And they heist is credited as being the most lucrative crime ever...but was it? If you love it when we rage-scream about a bunch of internet losers, then boy oh boy are you gonna love this week's episode. You might want to pre-pull over. WE'RE ON YOUTUBE! Want to view the…

1
Missing in Pictou County: The Vanishing of Lilly and Jack Sullivan 30:55

3d ago30:55

30:55

It all began on Friday morning, May 2nd, 2025. Lilly, who’s just six years old, and her little brother Jack, only four, were last seen around 10 a.m. near their home on Gairloch Road in Lansdowne Station, Pictou County. Their mother, Malehya, and stepfather, Daniel, were asleep with their baby in another room. Meanwhile, Lilly and Jack were suppose…

1
254: True Crime Rundown: The Trials of Diddy and Karen Read 23:07

3d ago23:07

23:07

Welcome to the first ever installment of I Think Not’s new weekly mini-series, True Crime Rundown. You will now be able to catch up on the true crime news that Ellyn and Joey are currently hyper fixated on. This week, they cover the latest in the trials of Diddy and Karen Read. Expect a lot of Diddy and a lot of canton accents. BUT! Who knows what …

1
429: Staten Island Secrets: New York Homicide (S1 E4) 51:31

4d ago51:31

51:31

On August 10, 2005, 18 year old Aliza Parsy was found murdered in her Staten Island home. She was naked, the house had been ransacked, and the killer had managed to leave precious few clues behind. As investigators peel back the layers of Aliza's life--from who her friends were to the pressures she felt growing up in a strict Orthodox Jewish commun…

1
The Case of Layla Santanello: What Happened After She Left the Americourt Hotel? 1:06:53

5d ago1:06:53

1:06:53

On June 27th, 2023, 20-year-old Layla Santanello was last seen walking barefoot and disoriented near the Kingsport Greenbelt in Tennessee. She had just fled the Americourt Hotel in a clear state of distress. What happened after that moment remains a mystery. This video walks through the final known timeline of Layla’s movements, the disturbing Cash…

1
253: What Lies Beneath (Married to Evil) 1:12:56

5d ago1:12:56

1:12:56

When Heidi's alcoholic husband, Chris, goes missing, she searches far and wide to find him, getting help from Chris' wider family; after a missing person's report is filed, police uncover a dark secret hidden in the basement of the marital home. This Week’s Sponsors: Remi - Head to shopremi.com/THINK and use code THINK to save up to 50% off ZBiotic…

1
Getting the Facts Straight – The Murder of Kitty Genovese 1:09:50

8d ago1:09:50

1:09:50

In this episode of Super SUS, we dive into the tragic case of Kitty Genovese, whose murder became widely known for its supposed link to the "bystander effect" — the theory that people are less likely to intervene in emergencies when others are around. We explore the details of the case, recounting the horrific events leading to Kitty’s death and ho…

1
428: The Devil on Trial 1:11:13

8d ago1:11:13

1:11:13

When Debbie Glatzel moves into her new home in the early 1980s, a demonic spirit haunting the home ALLEGEDLY takes over her younger brother David. Right on cue, grifters Ed and Lorraine Warren... er, we mean "paranormal experts Ed and Lorraine..." show up to investigate. But the various accounts of possession lead to murder, making people wonder - …

1
Scrolling Away Reality: A Fishing Rod Beats a Phone 38:40

7d ago38:40

38:40

Send us a text Could your family's digital habits be destroying your relationships more than any banned book? While parents storm school board meetings over inappropriate literature, the unbridled use of technology in homes might be the real enemy we should be fighting. The passionate debates about removing certain books from schools have dominated…

1
Deadly Deception: The Cartel, the Affair, and the Romeoville Family Murders 31:06

11d ago31:06

31:06

Tonight, we’re talking about a crime that rocked the small village of Romeoville, Illinois. It was a quiet Sunday evening in September 2023 when police pulled up to a quaint blue home on Concord Avenue. The neighbourhood was calm and peaceful, but what they found inside was anything but. As officers moved through the dark, quiet house, their flashl…

1
Scamanda 50:55

11d ago50:55

50:55

GIRD. YOUR. LOINS. AND. PULL. THE. HELL. OVER. When Amanda Riley, a young wife and mother, is diagnosed with terminal cancer, she decides to share her journey with the world via her blog. Tens of thousands of people send her love, support, AND MONEY. But when an anonymous tip is sent to an investigative reporter, CLAIMING THAT AMANDA IS FAKING CANC…

1
252: Deadly Delivery (Married to Evil) 1:09:50

12d ago1:09:50

1:09:50

A successful Florida family has their American dream shattered when a mysterious figure dressed as a clown shoots a loving mother on her doorstep; the case goes cold for decades until an unexpected break helps bring the killer clown to justice. This Week’s Sponsors: BetterHelp - This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at …

1
Deadly Obsession – The Murder of Alisha Bromfield 1:03:41

13d ago1:03:41

1:03:41

In this episode of Super SUS, we travel to Wisconsin Dells to explore a deeply disturbing case that shocked a community and changed state law. When 21-year-old Alicia Bromfield agreed to attend a wedding with someone she trusted, she had no idea her decision would end in unthinkable violence. As we peel back the layers of Alicia's life—from her bri…

1
God Hook: The Ohio Craigslist Killings is available now! 10:11

13d ago10:11

10:11

Listen to a clip from episode one of the podcast - the full episode is available now! In this new installment of her true crime series, journalist Carol Costello delves into the complex case of the Ohio Craigslist Killings, and in doing so, unearths the untold story of the crimes that preceded the murders – and the victims who’ve never received jus…

1
427: Disappeared in the Darkness 1:16:10

16d ago1:16:10

1:16:10

In December 2013, police in the Myrtle Beach area discover an abandoned car at a pitch-dark boat landing. They quickly surmise its owner - twenty-year-old Heather Elvis - has vanished. Authorities race to find Heather and stumble into a twisted web of lies, betrayal and fury. WE'RE ON YOUTUBE! Want to view the episodes and not just listen? Check ou…

1
Who Killed Amber Tuccaro? The Recording That Haunts Canada 58:02

14d ago58:02

58:02

Amber Tuccaro was just 20 years old when she disappeared near Edmonton, Alberta, in 2010. Two years later, her remains were found in a remote field—and the last known recording of her voice has haunted Canada ever since. In this video, we break down every detail of Amber’s case, the RCMP’s mishandling of the investigation, and the chilling phone ca…

1
Dodger Alibi: The Murder of Martha Puebla and the Man They Got Wrong 30:59

17d ago30:59

30:59

On the night of May 12, 2003, 16-year-old Martha Puebla sat outside her home in Sun Valley, California, sharing a quiet moment with a friend. Within minutes, her life was stolen by a gunman who asked for her by name before firing multiple shots and disappearing into the night. What seemed like a cold, calculated execution quickly unravelled into a …

1
426: Web of Death: Facebook Live 1:00:56

21d ago1:00:56

1:00:56

When Keisha Hawkins is tragically shot dead at a birthday party, Her father, Kalvon, is determined to get justice for his little girl. When the authorities give up looking for the killer, Kalvon takes matters into his own hands, using social media to smoke out the murderer. WE'RE ON YOUTUBE! Want to view the episodes and not just listen? Check our …

1
251: Home is Where the Nightmare is (Married to Evil) 1:15:58

19d ago1:15:58

1:15:58

Jenny and Mike were teen sweethearts but after marrying, Mike begins a campaign of control and violence against his wife and children. Just as Jenny plans to escape her living nightmare, Mike finds out and decides he will do anything to stop her. This Week’s Sponsors: HungryRoot - Head to hungryroot.com/ithinknot and use code ITHINKNOT to get 40% o…

1
Gone Without a Trace – The Disappearance of Brian Shaffer 57:27

21d ago57:27

57:27

In this episode of Super Sus, we delve into the perplexing case of Brian Shaffer, a 27-year-old medical student at Ohio State University who vanished without a trace in the early hours of April 1, 2006. Despite extensive investigations and numerous theories, Brian's disappearance remains unsolved, leaving behind a trail of questions and a grieving …

1
[BONUS] ROGUE TRANSMISSIONS: Halfway to Halloween Hullabaloo 1:59:02

21d ago1:59:02

1:59:02

Somewhere the sun shines, somewhere the birds sing the glories of a new dawn. Somewhere … it's Spring again! But HERE … every day is Halloween! Rogue Transmissions, an uncanny anthology of exceptional indie podcasts, presents the Halfway to Halloween Hullabaloo! Your horror host Edward October is scanning the dial for lost broadcasts, campfire tale…

1
425: Worst Ex Ever: Killing for Custody 1:05:14

23d ago1:05:14

1:05:14

When Eric met Rosa, he thought he'd met the woman of his dreams--smart, funny, and interesting. But everything changed after they had their daughter. Suddenly Rosa was demanding and abusive, forcing Eric to work long grueling hours and often disappearing with their daughter. And when Eric and Rosa's relationship ended, he had no way of knowing just…

1
Her Diary, Shoes, and Bag Were Left Behind | The Disappearance of Tonee Turner 39:24

21d ago39:24

39:24

Tonee Turner was 22 years old when she disappeared on December 30, 2019. After finishing her shift at work, Tonee's phone, shoes, diary, and purse were later found carefully placed near the Homestead Grays Bridge in Pittsburgh — but she was gone. Tonee was a vibrant artist, a beloved sister, and a light in her community. Her disappearance left behi…

1
Vanished from His Bed: The Unsolved Disappearance of Zachary Bernhardt 29:32

25d ago29:32

29:32

The date was September 11th, 2000, in Clearwater, Florida. Eight-year-old Zachary Bernhardt was asleep in his bedroom when his mother, Leah Hackett, stepped out of their apartment on Drew Street. It was the middle of the night, but Leah said insomnia had gotten the best of her. She went for a walk, maybe a swim in the apartment complex’s pool, hopi…

1
[BONUS] Unsolved & Unbelievable: Phoebe Handsjuk and Jelani Day | Serial Napper x Perplexity Collab 1:08:08

29d ago1:08:08

1:08:08

In this crossover episode, Serial Napper and Perplexity: A Mystery Podcast join forces to dive deep into two of the most haunting and baffling true crime cases in recent memory. 🎙️ Nikki from Serial Napper takes a closer look at the heartbreaking case of Jelani Day, a graduate student whose body was discovered under suspicious circumstances in Illi…

1
250: A Deadly Dose (Married to Evil) 1:19:06

29d ago1:19:06

1:19:06

Maria's world shatters when her husband Joel starts an affair; she fights to save their marriage, but Joel refuses to give up his mistress, and Maria's patience runs out; when she threatens divorce, Joel makes a deadly plan to stop her. This Week’s Sponsors: Blissy - Go to blissy.com/ITHINKNOTPOD and use code ITHINKNOTPOD to get 60 nights risk-free…

1
Attack at Lululemon – The Murder of Jayna Murray 1:01:35

27d ago1:01:35

1:01:35

In this episode of Super SUS, we dive deep into the chilling true crime case of the brutal murder of Jayna Murray at a Lululemon store in Bethesda, Maryland, in 2011. Jayna, a 30-year-old sales team leader, was on the verge of completing dual graduate degrees in Communication and Business Administration at Johns Hopkins University. On the night of …

1
424: Love You to Death: Playbook for Murder 1:05:18

30d ago1:05:18

1:05:18

When Jessica and Patrick met, it was love at first sight. The two were crazy about each other. But when Patrick is murdered in broad daylight just inside his own front door, authorities have to look at everyone in his life as a suspect. And when the killer is revealed, it is one "stay stupid" moment after another that leads to their downfall. WE'RE…

1
11 Years Later—Where Are Chloie & Gage? The Fire That Left No Answers 36:32

28d ago36:32

36:32

On a quiet Sunday night in 2012, a house fire in rural Tennessee claimed the lives of two beloved grandparents—but left behind a haunting mystery. Chloie Leverette, 9, and Gage Daniel, 7, were believed to be inside the home… yet no remains were ever found. Now, over a decade later, Tennessee's longest-running AMBER Alert is still active. Where are …

1
She Just Wanted to Go Home: The Tragic Death of Emily Pike 27:14

1M ago27:14

27:14

She was just 14. A soft-spoken girl who loved her cat, sketched her dreams in notebooks, took guitar lessons, and had just begun to explore who she was—experimenting with makeup, thinking about high school, maybe even college. Her name was Emily Pike. She was a daughter. A sister. A beloved member of the San Carlos Apache Tribe. And on a quiet nigh…

1
423: Dateline's "The Capture" 57:57

1M ago57:57

57:57

On August 23, 2008, Canadian journalist Amanda Lindhout and members of her entourage were kidnapped by Semolina insurgents in southern Somalia. Amanda, in particular, would endure 15 months of torture before being released. And even when that nightmare was over, her captor still tormented her with demands of more money, "or else." This episode tell…

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Obsessed With Disappeared Podcasts

Podcasts Worth a Listen