Best Daniel and Melissa MacArthur Podcasts (2025)

1
Pew Research’s Gregory A. Smith on What Americans Really Believe—and Why the Data Might Surprise You 1:13:36

Play Pause

30m ago1:13:36

1:13:36

Forget what you think you know about religion in America. The latest research from Pew reveals a story that’s more complex—and more hopeful—than the headlines suggest. Corey sits down with Gregory A. Smith, who’s spent over two decades studying how faith and identity shape American public life. In this no-fluff conversation, Greg unpacks the surpri…

1
ICYMI: Bishop Mariann Edgar Budde on Courage, Faith, and Public Witness 1:05:33

25m ago1:05:33

1:05:33

A luminous conversation about leadership, love, and what spiritual courage looks like in a polarized age. In this ICYMI episode, Corey revisits his deeply moving conversation with Bishop Mariann Edgar Budde, Episcopal Bishop of Washington and one of the most trusted—and most tested—faith leaders in American public life. With striking humility and c…

1
ICYMI: Alexander Vindman — The Folly of Realism 1:17:18

2d ago1:17:18

1:17:18

One of the clearest, most necessary voices on Ukraine, democracy, and what the West keeps getting wrong. In this ICYMI episode, Corey revisits his most recent conversation with Dr. Alexander Vindman — retired U.S. Army Lieutenant Colonel, former Director for European Affairs on the National Security Council, and author of The Folly of Realism: How …

1
From the Bronx to the Beltway: Congressman Ritchie Torres on Grit, Grace, and Governing (ICYMI) 31:21

11h ago31:21

31:21

One of the most compelling personal and political stories in Congress today — raw, principled, and deeply human. In this ICYMI episode, Corey revisits his conversation with Congressman Ritchie Torres, who represents New York’s 15th district in the Bronx. With refreshing candor, Torres shares his journey from public housing and poverty to becoming t…

1
Just Melissa- The Disappearance of Ana Walshe: Inside the Trial of Brian Walshe 9:04

6d ago9:04

9:04

When 39-year-old mother and corporate executive Ana Walshe vanished on New Year's Day 2023, her disappearance shook the quiet coastal town of Cohasset. Her husband, Brian Walshe, told investigators she left on a last-minute work flight. But within days, a chilling series of inconsistencies, and a trail of disturbing Google searches turned a missing…

1
ICYMI: David French — Faith, Politics, and the Ethics of Disagreement 1:18:00

5d ago1:18:00

1:18:00

One of the most clarifying conversations we’ve had about conscience, character, and navigating our divisions with integrity. In this ICYMI release, Corey revisits his conversation with David French — New York Times columnist, attorney, veteran, and one of the most thoughtful voices on religious liberty, civic virtue, polarization, and how principle…

1
After the Show: Episode 157 - Leon Jr. and Tiesh Rhue Harrison 16:19

8d ago16:19

16:19

Join Daniel and Melissa for the unfiltered, unedited, and unhinged discussion on this case. These are the conversations we used to have after we hit stop. Only now we keep recording. Listen at your own risk! Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.…

1
Episode 157- The Body in Black River: Leon Jr. and Tiesh Rhue Harrison 1:11:32

8d ago1:11:32

1:11:32

*Skip the foreplay at 14:00 (this is a rough guesstimation due to ad placement done by AI and not human beings) On March 11th, 2017, a homeowner along the Black River in Georgetown County South Carolina, made a chilling discovery: a man's body, tightly bound at the hands and feet with speaker wire, floating in the dark waters. What began as a missi…

1
ICYMI: Anne Applebaum — How Autocrats Rise and Democracies Fall 1:05:54

4d ago1:05:54

1:05:54

One of the most essential conversations we’ve had — on authoritarianism, influence campaigns, and what it takes to defend democracy. In this ICYMI release, Corey revisits his conversation with Anne Applebaum — Pulitzer Prize–winning historian, staff writer at The Atlantic, and one of the world’s leading experts on modern authoritarianism. Anne expl…

1
ICYMI: David Brooks on Moral Repair, Friendship, Faith, and the Inner Work of Democracy 1:06:31

5d ago1:06:31

1:06:31

One of TP&R’s all-time standout conversations—perfect for new listeners discovering the show this week. In this special ICYMI release, Corey revisits his deeply human, deeply honest conversation with David Brooks—New York Times columnist, bestselling author of The Second Mountain and How to Know a Person, and one of the most thoughtful public voice…

1
Just Melissa with Special Guest Daniel- Black Friday: A History of Chaos and Capitalism Gone Wild! 18:13

12d ago18:13

18:13

On this episode Melissa tells Daniel the evolution of Black Friday. From its chaotic 1950's origins to the nationwide shopping frenzy, we know today. Decade by decade we unpack the mayhem and the brilliant marketing. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for adver…

1
Something Special for the Holiday: EAST MEETS WEST SPORTS - Cleveland’s QB Gamble & LA’s Power Play 33:23

12d ago33:23

33:23

Call it a holiday palate cleanser: today’s TP&R feed features a special drop from East Meets West Sports. Be sure to find this new show on all the apps, follow, rate, review... You know the drill. Enjoy! Can Shedeur Sanders prove he's “the one” – or is Cleveland just buying time? Meanwhile, LA sports shake things up from the locker room to the fron…

1
Dr. Melissa Deckman on America’s Cracks: Trumpism, Gen Z, and the Faith Factor 1:18:18

10d ago1:18:18

1:18:18

What PRRI’s Latest Data Reveals About Our Deepening Divide In the shadow of rising polarization, this episode dives deep into the latest findings from PRRI's American Values Survey, Trump’s Unprecedented Actions Deepen Asymmetric Divides. Corey is joined by Dr. Melissa Deckman to break down the data—and what it tells us about party loyalty, trust i…

1
The MacArthur's Talk Cryptids and Haunted Locations... Minnesota! 46:56

15d ago46:56

46:56

Minnesota may be known for its quiet lakes and snowy pine forests but after midnight, the state becomes something else entirely. In this chilling double features episode, Melissa and Daniel dive into the 10 most terrifying cryptids and the 10 most haunted locations hiding in the land of 10,000 lakes. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pc…

1
Redemption Projects: From Wreckage to Repair 40:36

17d ago40:36

40:36

Repairing the damage—in our democracy, in our relationships, and in ourselves. ✨ Episode Summary Let’s talk about redemption—what it really means to repair what’s been broken, whether in our democracy or in our personal lives, and how we can tell the difference between a true apology and just going through the motions. Inspired by a powerful Substa…

1
After the Show: Episode 156 - Dr. William "Bill" and Sharon Guthrie 13:14

22d ago13:14

13:14

*Reading of the email begins around 6:00 Join Daniel and Melissa for the unfiltered, unedited, and unhinged discussion on this case. These are the conversations we used to have after we hit stop. Only now we keep recording. Listen at your own risk! Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection an…

1
Polling, Prop Bets, and Political Truths: Carl Allen Returns 1:25:26

17d ago1:25:26

1:25:26

What do you get when a data scientist with a knack for sports betting and political forecasting returns to the pod? A masterclass in what polling can and can't do, how bad assumptions skew our democracy, and why Carl Allen thinks we need to stop blaming the camera for the race result. In this fascinating, far-ranging convo, Corey and Carl Allen (au…

1
Episode 156 - The Body in the Bathtub: William "Bill" and Sharon Guthrie 1:33:55

22d ago1:33:55

1:33:55

*Skip the Foreplay at 13:00 (this is a rough guesstimation due to ad placement by AI and not human beings) On the morning of May 14, 1999, 54-year-old Sharon Guthrie was found unresponsive and face down in the bathtub of her home in Wolsey South Dakota. Her husband, Dr. William "Bill" Guthrie, a Presbyterian minister, dialed 911. But Sharon never r…

1
Just Melissa- The Influencer, The Manager, and the $1.75 Million Dollar Verdict: The Brenay Kennard Case 9:40

25d ago9:40

9:40

When a North Carolina marriage imploded, it didn't just break hearts, it sparked one of the most viral alienations of affection cases in recent memory. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.By Daniel and Melissa MacArthur

1
Against the Noise: Gratitude as a Form of Protest 24:54

24d ago24:54

24:54

"And now for something completely different..." In a world flooded with outrage and anxiety, taking stock of the good isn’t naive—it’s necessary. Corey shifts the lens from polarization and pessimism to the power of thankfulness. Amid a flood of bad news and anxiety about the state of democracy, Corey invites listeners to pause and consider what’s …

1
Scripture, Satire, and Silicon Salvation: Lisa Rose Ferrara’s CHRISTBOT 1:02:54

28d ago1:02:54

1:02:54

🤖 What happens when an ex-campus minister turned agnostic writes a novel about AI Jesus? You get this wide-ranging and deeply moving conversation between Corey and Lisa Rose Ferrara—writer of the Substack The Dangling Door and author of the novel CHRISTBOT. Lisa doesn’t just reflect on the absurdities of our sociopolitical moment—she rewrites the r…

1
Just Melissa- The Stalking and Murder of Kristil Krug 12:11

29d ago12:11

12:11

When Kristil Krug told friends she was being stalked online, she did everything right. Filed police reports, installed cameras, and tried to always be aware of her surroundings. But the real danger wasn't a stranger in the dark, it was her husband. And it wasn't until after Kristil's murder that investigators would uncover a truth more horrifying t…

1
From Military Police to Soft Secession: Christopher Armitage on Resisting Authoritarian Drift 1:03:11

1M ago1:03:11

1:03:11

What happens when a former military cop, existentialist philosopher, and Substack firebrand walks into a podcast? You get this riveting conversation between Corey and Christopher Armitage, who pulls no punches when it comes to democracy, resistance, and why “soft secession” might be the only sane response to creeping authoritarianism. Chris is a U.…

1
5 Boundaries That Signal It’s Time to Walk Away From Toxic Dialogue 31:11

1M ago31:11

31:11

Not every relationship can—or should—be salvaged. In this solo episode, Corey shares a personal story and outlines five unmistakable red flags that tell you it’s time to step back to protect your peace. Sometimes, staying in the conversation means knowing when to step away. In this raw and introspective solo episode, host Corey Nathan opens up abou…

1
After the Show: Episode 155- Melvin "Danny" and Donna Fryman 13:02

1M ago13:02

13:02

Join Daniel and Melissa for the unfiltered, unedited, and unhinged discussion on this case. These are the conversations we used to have after we hit stop. Only now we keep recording. Listen at your own risk! Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.…

1
Episode 155- The Demon in the House: Melvin "Danny" and Donna Fryman 1:12:29

1M ago1:12:29

1:12:29

*Skip the foreplay at 12:00 (this is a rough guesstimation due to ad placement by AI and not human beings) Melissa hijacked the Factoid segment so be prepared! In the quiet upscale suburb of Prospect Kentucky, a relationship that began in high school blossomed into a high stakes interior design business, then seemingly collapsed under the weight of…

1
Is Democracy Backsliding? David A. Graham on Power, Press, and What Comes Next 1:04:18

1M ago1:04:18

1:04:18

From Project 2025 to creeping authoritarianism, Atlantic journalist David A. Graham lays out the threats to democracy — and why he still believes it's worth defending. Glad to have this timely conversation with David A. Graham, staff writer at The Atlantic, author of the Atlantic Daily newsletter, and the mind behind two major works: THE PROJECT: H…

1
LB Prevette on Weave, Rural Belonging, and Why “You Won’t Hurt Alone.” 1:00:56

1M ago1:00:56

1:00:56

How one rural weaver is helping neighbors feel seen, supported, and connected in Wilkes County, NC — and what we can learn from her example. We are kicking off something special. This episode is the first in a new ongoing series highlighting Weavers — local leaders around the country who are rebuilding trust and community from the ground up through…

1
The MacArthur's Talk Haunted Locations... Louisiana 35:59

1M ago35:59

35:59

When the sun goes down in the cities of Louisiana, the spirits don't sleep, they drink! So, pull up a barstool and pour something strong, because in Louisiana, last call is never truly the end. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.…

1
Just Melissa- The Case Against Donna Adelson 8:12

2M ago8:12

8:12

A decade long family feud ends in the murder of FSU law professor Dan Markel. Newly unsealed court documents and chilling wire taps reveal how the family's matriarch, Donna Adelson, was behind it all. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.…

1
ICYMI: Mike Madrid on Baseball, Family, and the Soul of America 1:22:36

1M ago1:22:36

1:22:36

Where baseball, family, and democracy meet — Mike Madrid reminds us what’s worth fighting for in America. If you didn't catch our most recent conversation with friend of the pod, Mike Madrid, well... where were ya? We recorded this one right around July 4th and it's still on point! What'd ya expect with the brilliant Mike Madrid?!?! So join us in w…

1
Silencing the Press, Politicizing the Military: Col. David Lapan Isn’t Having It 1:25:18

1M ago1:25:18

1:25:18

“The North Star is the truth. Tell it. And if you can’t, explain why.” — Col. David Lapan (Ret.) We had the distinct honor of sitting down with Colonel David Lapan, retired Marine and former spokesperson for the Department of Homeland Security, Secretaries of Defense, and the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. In a wide-ranging, timely conversa…

1
Episode 154: The Body in the Oven: Part 2- Zack Bowen and Addie Hall 1:05:26

2M ago1:05:26

1:05:26

The murder of Addie Hall by Zack Bowen in New Orleans Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See https://pcm.adswizz.comfor information about our collection and use of personal data foradvertising.By Daniel and Melissa MacArthur

1
Just Melissa- The Louvre Jewelry Heist 8:57

2M ago8:57

8:57

*Breaking News- In October 2025, thieves pulled off one of the most daring daylight robberies in modern history. Stealing priceless royal jewels from the Louvre Museum in under 7 minutes. From sapphire crowns to emerald necklaces. Centuries of French heritage vanished before the world's eyes. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswiz…

1
Fighting Division One Conversation at a Time 20:19

2M ago20:19

20:19

Surviving Triangulation in a Polarized World It's time to reckon with one of the toughest questions in our current public discourse: “How can you think that?” Through stories from his personal and professional life, host Corey Nathan unpacks the emotionally draining phenomenon of triangulation—when we’re caught in the middle of opposing viewpoints—…

1
Just Melissa: The Tale of Bluebeard and the Forbidden Chamber 8:32

2M ago8:32

8:32

Step inside the locked chamber of one of the darkest fairytales ever told. The Tale of Bluebeard is more than just a story of a rich nobleman with a strange colored beard; it's a chilling descent into secrecy, curiosity, and the price of disobedience. Stay tuned for the conclusion, where Melissa digs into the men who may have inspired Charles Perra…

1
🎙️ Transforming Systems, Not Just Souls — with Dr. Kurt Ver Beek 1:09:18

2M ago1:09:18

1:09:18

"If we lived in the poorest, most dangerous neighborhoods, we’d understand better how to love and serve." — Dr. Kurt Ver Beek It was great to sit down with Dr. Kurt Ver Beek, co-founder of the Association for a More Just Society (ASJ), who has lived and worked in Honduras for nearly four decades. From battling systemic corruption to reducing the ho…

1
Episode 154- The Body in the Oven: Zack Bowen and Addie Hall: Part 1 1:23:01

2M ago1:23:01

1:23:01

*Skip the Foreplay at 11:00 (this is a rough guesstimation due to ad placement by AI, and not human beings) In the heart of New Orleans French Quarter unfolded one of the city's darkest true crime stories. Addie Hall and Zack Bowen were the picture of a wild, free-spirited couple, dancing their way through post Hurricane Katrina chaos and Bourbon S…

1
🎙️ Back to Basics: When to Engage, When to Walk Away 25:18

2M ago25:18

25:18

A candid reflection on staying grounded while engaging in contentious conversations—and when to take a step back. ✨ Episode Summary In this heartfelt solo talk, host Corey Nathan goes back to the fundamentals of Talkin’ Politics & Religion Without Killin’ Each Other. Reflecting on recent emotionally charged interactions—some painfully personal—Core…

1
The MacArthur's Talk Cryptids... Louisiana 43:46

2M ago43:46

43:46

Deep in the Louisiana swamps something stirs. From the Honey Island Swamp Monster to the Rougarou echoing through the cane fields. The Bayou state just might be the most supernatural stretch of land in the good ole USA. In this episode Melissa and Daniel wade through murky waters, explore strange footprints, chase glowing lights, and unravel Louisi…

1
Justin Giboney on the Black Church, Civic Courage, and Healing Our Divides 1:04:54

2M ago1:04:54

1:04:54

By Scan Media, LLC

1
Cursing, Criticism, and the Conversations Worth Keeping 24:26

2M ago24:26

24:26

A raw look at which relationships and conversations are worth our time—and when to just say f* it. ✨ Episode Summary In this candid, off-the-cuff talk, Corey wrestles with a series of deeply personal and philosophical questions that lie at the heart of this progam’s mission: 👉 Which conversations are worth pursuing? 👉 Which relationships are worth …

1
Just Melissa with Special Guest Daniel- The Conclusion of the Horrific Murder of Angela Craig 21:25

2M ago21:25

21:25

When Angela Craig fell mysteriously ill, her husband James, a Colorado dentist, seemed worried. In reality, he was secretly poisoning her protein shakes with cyanide and arsenic. It did not take long for James to be arrested and charged with Angela's murder. Listen as Melissa tells Daniel the conclusion of the case they covered over 2 years ago. In…

1
Inside Heterodox Academy: Jonathan Rauch and Liz Joyner on Reclaiming Truth in a Fractured Democracy 1:23:54

2M ago1:23:54

1:23:54

Why defending viewpoint diversity might be the most radical—and necessary—act in higher education today. 🎧 Episode Summary What a treat to welcome two leading voices in the fight for viewpoint diversity and constructive civic dialogue: Jonathan Rauch, senior fellow at Brookings and author of The Constitution of Knowledge, and Liz Joyner, founder of…

1
Episode 153- Where’s Shannon? The Body Under the Concrete: Joshua and Shannon Madill Burgess 1:12:32

2M ago1:12:32

1:12:32

*Skip the foreplay at 13:00 (this is a guesstimation due to ad placement by AI, and not human beings) When actress Shannon Madill vanished in November of 2014, her disappearance puzzled a city and devastated her family and friends. But months later, the truth revealed a chilling betrayal. From the person who promised to love, honor, and cherish Sha…

1
🎙️ THEY Didn't Do It – A Candid Call for Accountability 19:36

2M ago19:36

19:36

In times of national tragedy, can we resist the urge to turn our grief into political ammo? Sadly, our current leaders can't seem to find their better angels. So who's gonna do the right thing? 🧭 Episode Summary Fair warning: Your trusty friend and host is a little hot under the collar on this one. We're addressing the aftermath of Charlie Kirk’s a…

1
After the Show: Episode 152- Glyn and Hazel Dix with Pia Overbury 17:09

3M ago17:09

17:09

Join Daniel and Melissa for the unfiltered, unedited, and unhinged discussion on this case. These are the conversations we used to have after we hit stop. Only now we keep recording. Listen at your own risk! Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.…

1
Dr. Beth Allison Barr on Women, Power, and the Pastor’s Wife Problem in Evangelicalism 1:11:36

2M ago1:11:36

1:11:36

What if the role of “pastor’s wife” wasn’t biblical at all, but a cultural invention that sidelined women from ministry? Dr. Beth Allison Barr pulls back the curtain on how power, patriarchy, and politics shaped Evangelical churches—and why reclaiming women’s voices could change everything. Episode Summary So glad to sit down with Dr. Beth Allison …

1
Episode 152- The Convicted Killer and His Wife: Glyn and Hazel Dix with Pia Overbury 1:00:31

3M ago1:00:31

1:00:31

*Skip the Foreplay- 13:00 (this is a guesstimation due to ad placement) Two women murdered 25 years apart. How did a killer once jailed for life walk free to kill again? In this episode Melissa tells Daniel one of the darkest and most disturbing murder cases in recent British criminal history. From the brutal slaying of a young wife and mother to t…

1
From Trauma to Torah: Rabbi Michael Holzman’s Mission to Rebuild American Democracy 1:14:36

3M ago1:14:36

1:14:36

After October 7, Rabbi Michael Holzman wasn’t just mourning—he was mobilizing. A project he had already spent years developing. Discover how one rabbi is using ancient wisdom, civic rituals, and interfaith grit to heal our fractured democracy. In this episode, we sit down with Rabbi Michael Holzman, spiritual leader of the Northern Virginia Hebrew …

Daniel And Melissa MacArthur Podcasts