Best Cold Case Central Podcasts (2026)

1
The Highway That Hunts: Canada’s Most Infamous Cold Cases - Highway of Tears part 3 38:14

Play Pause

6h ago38:14

38:14

Send us a text Part 3 of our Highway of Tears series examines some of the most infamous missing and murdered cases along Highways 16, 5, and 97 in British Columbia, from the 1990s to the present day. We explore the disappearances of Delphine Nikal, Ramona Wilson, Roxanne Thiara, Alisha Germaine, Lana Derrick, Nicole Hoar, and Aielah Saric-Auger, tr…

1
The Unsolved Oslo Murder 33:26

7d ago33:26

33:26

In 1995, a young woman checked into a luxury hotel in Oslo under a false name — and was found dead days later in a locked room with no ID, no luggage, and a story that never made sense. This episode explores the mysterious death of Jennifer Fairgate, found in Room 2805 of the Oslo Plaza Hotel. Ruled a suicide almost immediately, the case is filled …

1
The Christmas Poisoner 29:41

15d ago29:41

29:41

In this chilling holiday episode of Murder With My Husband, Payton dives into the bizarre and twist-filled case of Barbara Hoffman—a biochemistry student turned massage parlor worker turned accused murderer. On Christmas Day 1977, a man walks into the Madison Police Department and confesses to helping bury a body in the snow. What unravels next is …

1
The Stranger, the Job Offer, and the Family That Never Returned: More Mysteries on the Highway of Tears 31:57

22d ago31:57

31:57

Send us a text For more than five decades, a remote stretch of road in British Columbia has been the epicenter of one of Canada’s darkest crises. The Highway of Tears is home to dozens of missing and murdered Indigenous women, girls, and families — many cases mishandled, ignored, or never fully investigated. In this episode, Arlene and Leah uncover…

1
The Murder of Lisa Solomon | Christmas Eve Tragedy 35:11

20d ago35:11

35:11

In this episode of Murder Monday, we dive into the heartbreaking case of Lisa Solomon—a newlywed who vanished on Christmas Eve 1987. What started as a quiet night at home turned into a chilling mystery that shocked her family and community. As the search unfolds, dark secrets come to light… and suspicion turns toward the one person who should have …

1
She Vanished in 15 Minutes: The Unsolved Disappearance of Patrice Endres 18:09

23d ago18:09

18:09

In today’s sit-down video, we’re diving deep into the heartbreaking and still-unsolved case of Patrice Endres — a beloved mother, wife, and hairdresser who vanished from her salon in Cumming, Georgia on April 15, 2004. Her mysterious disappearance shook the small town and left behind a trail of unanswered questions, suspicious behavior, and a devas…

1
John Hinckley Jr. and the Disturbing Obsession That Nearly Killed a President 24:18

29d ago24:18

24:18

On March 30, 1981, chaos erupted outside the Washington Hilton. Six shots rang out in less than two seconds, sending Secret Service agents scrambling and leaving President Ronald Reagan moments from death. The footage is iconic — replayed for decades — but the real question behind the shooting has always remained unsettlingly unclear: Why did John …

1
The Christmas That Ended in Murder: Ronald Gene Simmons' Rampage 35:06

27d ago35:06

35:06

In December 1987, Ronald Gene Simmons murdered 16 people—14 of them his own family—in what remains the deadliest family annihilation in U.S. history. In this episode, Peyton Moreland unpacks the disturbing case that turned a quiet Arkansas Christmas into an unthinkable nightmare. ⚠️ Trigger Warning: This episode contains detailed descriptions of mu…

1
The Park Bench Murders: Was it Racist Motivated 49:36

1M ago49:36

49:36

On June 4, 2019, Kate Brown and Carnell Sledge were brutally murdered in broad daylight at a Cleveland Metropark. Five years later, their killer is still unknown. This episode breaks down the case, theories, and how you can help bring justice. Today's episode is brought to you in part by the following: Patriot Food Supply: ➡️ https://www.rzmaf8trk.…

1
The Shocking Truth Behind 40 Missing Women: What’s Really Happening on Canada’s Highway of Tears? 48:59

1M ago48:59

48:59

Send us a text The Highway of Tears is ground zero in one of Canada’s darkest ongoing tragedies. For more than 50 years, dozens of people – mostly Indigenous women and girls – have been murdered or gone missing along Highway 16 and its connecting routes in northern British Columbia. Despite RCMP task forces and national attention, these cases have …

1
The Cosplay Murder: Was it Self-Defense? 32:50

1M ago32:50

32:50

When Matthew Trussler was found dead in his backyard, his fiancée Melissa Turner claimed she had no idea what happened. But as police dug deeper, a dark story began to unravel—one involving shifting lies, blood evidence, and surveillance footage that caught more than anyone expected. Was it self-defense—or something much more sinister? Today's epis…

1
Everything you need to know about tips, rewards, and payouts 9:53

2M ago9:53

9:53

"Everything you need to know about tips, rewards, and payouts. CrimeStoppers 215stop Alabama," is a podcast episode from the CrimeStoppers 215stop Alabama channel featuring host Jerome Jones and Executive Director Tony Garrett. The discussion focuses on the CrimeStoppers process, emphasizing anonymity and the reward system for tips that lead to an …

1
The Blagg Family Murders 33:48

2M ago33:48

33:48

On November 13, 2001, Michael Blagg reported his wife Jennifer and 6-year-old daughter Abby missing. Blood in the bedroom, a staged burglary, and no signs of struggle left police with more questions than answers. Seven months later, a shocking discovery in a landfill unraveled a dark family secret—yet one heartbreaking mystery remains: Where is Abb…

1
The Mysterious Death of Jack Wheeler – Washington Insider or Tragic Accident? 23:05

2M ago23:05

23:05

On December 31, 2010, the body of John “Jack” Wheeler III — a decorated West Point graduate, Vietnam veteran, and former White House aide — was found at the Cherry Island Landfill in Delaware. What began as a clear-cut homicide quickly unraveled into one of the most bizarre unsolved mysteries in American history. Wheeler’s final days were a series …

1
The Mayor’s Sons and the Women Who Died: Alaska’s Unanswered Crimes 25:47

2M ago25:47

25:47

Send us a text Two Indigenous women—Jennifer Kirk and Sue Sue Norton—were both found dead at the home of a former Alaska mayor. Both had dated his sons. Both suffered violence. And yet, no one has ever been charged. Join Box in the Basement as Arlene and Leah uncover the disturbing failures, corruption, and silence surrounding two deaths that deman…

1
💌🩸 Bloodline Buzz: Secrets, Lies, and Small-Town Shadows 🩸💌👀 13:08

2M ago13:08

13:08

Welcome to Bloodline Buzz — our brand new segment where you, the listeners, take the mic. Your stories. Your secrets. Your investigations. This week’s inbox is overflowing with mystery, drama, and a little bit of heartbreak. First up, Karissa drops a relationship bomb that has us all asking: should she dump that man, or could he actually be telling…

1
🎃 Halloween Special: “Trick or Treat — Death in Disguise 42:58

2M ago42:58

42:58

Halloween. A night of masks, laughter, and innocent thrills. But behind the flicker of jack-o’-lanterns, true terror once walked among the trick-or-treaters. In this special Halloween episode of Bloodlines and Headlines, we peel back the mask on two of the most chilling real-life crimes ever tied to October 31st. First — the Orange Sock Murders in …

1
👀Decoding the Zodiac: Terror in Plain Sight👀 34:40

2M ago34:40

34:40

He called himself Zodiac — a name that would come to define terror. He wanted fame. He wanted fear. And he got both. He wrote in codes, bragged in letters, and left behind victims and questions that still haunt investigators half a century later. The Zodiac Killer turned murder into a message — taunting police, the press, and the public with riddle…

1
The Fan Who Killed John Lennon: What Drove Mark David Chapman? 28:20

2M ago28:20

28:20

On December 8, 1980, John Lennon was shot and killed outside his home in New York City by Mark David Chapman, a fan whose obsession turned deadly. This episode explores Chapman’s troubled mind, the events leading up to that night, and the lasting impact of Lennon’s death on music and culture. Today's episode is brought to you in part by the followi…

1
A Perfect Marriage — Until the FBI Found Her Name on a Hit List 32:57

2M ago32:57

32:57

When 43-year-old Amy Allwine was found dead in her Minnesota home, it looked like suicide — until investigators uncovered a dark web murder-for-hire plot paid for in Bitcoin. The shocking truth? The person behind it all was closer than anyone imagined. Today's episode is brought to you in part by the following: Patriot Food Supply: ➡️ https://www.r…

1
Why True Crime Captivates Still | A Deep Dive into Our Obsession with Real Crime Stories 19:32

2M ago19:32

19:32

Why do millions of people consume true crime stories—about murder, violence, and trauma—with such fascination? In this video, we explore the psychological, cultural, and media-driven reasons why true crime continues to captivate audiences in the digital age. 🔍 From the history of public executions and crime pamphlets to modern podcasts, Netflix doc…

1
The Fan Who Crossed an Ocean: How One Man’s Obsession Nearly Killed Theresa Saldana 19:26

2M ago19:26

19:26

In 1982, Hollywood was shaken by a brutal attack on rising actress Theresa Saldana — stabbed ten times outside her Los Angeles home by an obsessed fan who believed God told him to do it. This documentary-style deep dive unravels the disturbing story of her attacker, Arthur Richard Jackson: his descent into delusion, his cross-Atlantic hunt for Sald…

1
From Ice Cream Girl to Playboy Fame... Then Everything Went Wrong 11:45

2M ago11:45

11:45

She was Playboy’s rising star and Hollywood’s next big thing—until the man who discovered her turned into the man who destroyed her. In this episode, we unravel the tragic story of Dorothy Stratten, from her humble beginnings in Vancouver to her explosive fame in Los Angeles, and the deadly obsession that led to her murder at just 20 years old. A c…

1
She Tried to Leave Him. Then She Disappeared: The Cases of Senovia Medina & Cecilia Huerta Gallego 38:51

2M ago38:51

38:51

Send us a text In this episode, Arlene and Leah uncover the tragic cases of Senovia Medina, a young mother who fled civil war in El Salvador only to vanish in Houston in 2006 — her boyfriend later convicted of her murder, though her body was never found — and Cecilia Huerta Gallegos, a San Antonio nurse and mother of four who told her sister, “If a…

1
The Napa Halloween Murders 16:15

3M ago16:15

16:15

In this in-depth true crime case, we explore the haunting story of Leslie Mazzara and Adriane Insogna, two bright and ambitious young women who were tragically murdered in their Napa home. What began as a festive evening handing out candy ended in horror — and it would take nearly a year, a mysterious cigarette butt, and a shocking confession to re…

1
The Dark Obsession That Ended a Metal Legend: Dimebag & Nathan Gale 16:53

2M ago16:53

16:53

Witness the tragic story of Dimebag Darrell, legendary Pantera guitarist, and the shocking 2004 night he was murdered onstage by Nathan Gale. This video dives deep into Gale’s mental state, the events at Alrosa Villa, and the lasting impact on the metal community. Today's episode is brought to you in part by the following: Patriot Food Supply: ➡️ h…

1
Who Killed Bobbie Miller? The Cold Case New Hampshire Wants You to Forget 42:43

3M ago42:43

42:43

On Halloween night, 2010, 54-year-old Roberta “Bobbie” Miller was found brutally murdered in her home in Guilford, New Hampshire — alongside her beloved dog. 14 years later, her case remains unsolved. Who killed Bobbie Miller? And why has justice never been served? Today's episode is brought to you in part by the following: Patriot Food Supply: ➡️ …

1
Gone Without a Trace: How a Mother’s Disappearance Exposed the Dark Side of Texas Justice 30:33

3M ago30:33

30:33

Send us a text In this episode of Box in the Basement, Arlene and Leah uncover the chilling case of Vicki Lynn Nisbett, a Texas mother who vanished in 1991—without a body ever found. Her husband was convicted, released, and reconvicted in a legal saga that still divides Williamson County. Was justice truly served, or is the real story still buried …

1
The Betrayal No One Saw Coming: Selena & Yolanda’s Fatal Bond 20:29

3M ago20:29

20:29

Discover the shocking true story behind the murder of Tejano music icon Selena Quintanilla-Pérez. Why did her biggest fan and trusted friend, Yolanda Saldívar, pull the trigger? This video breaks down the events leading to her tragic death, the trial, and Selena’s lasting legacy. Today's episode is brought to you in part by the following: Patriot F…

1
The Murder That Haunted the Kennedys: Who Killed Martha Moxley? 18:45

3M ago18:45

18:45

On October 30, 1975, 15-year-old Martha Moxley was brutally murdered in her backyard in Greenwich, Connecticut — one of the wealthiest neighborhoods in America. For decades, her case remained unsolved, entangled in a web of privilege, secrecy, and powerful connections to the Kennedy family. Today's episode is brought to you in part by the following…

1
🫢Confessions in the Dark: The Central Park Five – Part 2🫢 53:23

3M ago53:23

53:23

In part two of the The Bloodlines & Headlines Podcast deep dive, we move on from the interrogations and into the courtroom battles that sealed the fate of the Central Park Five.. Wrongful convictions sent five teenagers to prison. Where they faced years of fear, survival and lost youth. But years later, a confession from the real perpetrator would …

1
👀The Central Park Five: Fear, Frenzy, and False Confessions – Part 1👀 31:42

3M ago31:42

31:42

It’s a dark breezy night in 1989, New York City was shaken by a brutal crime in Central Park – in the cities response would ignite one of the most infamous miscarriages of justice in American history. In part, one of our deep dive, we unravel the chaotic aftermath of the assault, the media frenzy that followed and the intense pressure on police to …

1
How The Railway Killer Was Shit Out of Luck 22:09

3M ago22:09

22:09

Ángel Maturino Reséndiz, better known as The Railway Killer, terrorized communities across the United States during the 1980s and 1990s. Traveling by freight trains, he struck without warning, leaving a trail of brutal murders in his path. From Texas to Illinois, his crimes shocked the nation and exposed major flaws in law enforcement coordination.…

1
Charlie Kirk Murder Investigation Focusing on Potential Accomplices 14:48

3M ago14:48

14:48

Tonight I dig deep into the latest developments in the assassination of Charlie Kirk, including new revelations from FBI Director Cash Patel. The investigation is expanding — from text message confessions to the possibility of an accomplice, hand gestures caught on video, and a decades-old untraceable rifle used in the shooting. Today's episode is …

1
Vanished Without a Trace: The Unsolved Mysteries of Margaret Chauncy & Lisa Chandler 33:48

3M ago33:48

33:48

Send us a text In 1987, 24-year-old Margaret Chauncy left her shift at St. Michael’s Hospital in Texarkana and asked a coworker to follow her home, fearing she was being stalked by a man in a black car. She pulled into her apartment complex in her red Pontiac Fiero—and vanished. Nearly 38 years later, Margaret’s case remains unsolved. Two decades l…

1
New Details in Tyler Robinson Case | Full Breakdown & Text Message Revelations 43:27

4M ago43:27

43:27

Tonight we break down the latest developments in the Tyler Robinson investigation—the man accused of assassinating Charlie Kirk at a public event in Utah. Today's episode is brought to you in part by the following: Patriot Food Supply: ➡️ https://www.rzmaf8trk.com/212KN5C/2CTPL/ Skillshare: ➡️ https://skillshare.eqcm.net/XYOaYX NordVPN: ➡️ http://n…

1
Did Charlie Kirk's Killer Tyler Robinson Have Help 16:10

4M ago16:10

16:10

I dive into the shocking assassination of conservative commentator Charlie Kirk, the arrest of the alleged shooter Tyler Robinson, and the growing questions surrounding whether he acted alone. 🚨 New reports reveal that federal and state law enforcement may be investigating far-left extremist groups in Utah—raising critical questions about political…

1
FBI Releases Images of Person of Interest in Charlie Kirk Shooting 9:03

4M ago9:03

9:03

The investigation into the assassination of Charlie Kirk continues to unfold. In this video, we break down everything we know so far — including new surveillance footage released by the FBI, where the suspect's firearm was found, and what law enforcement is doing to track down the shooter. Authorities believe the suspect blended in with the crowd a…

1
TCNS Thoughts on the Anniversary of 9/11 5:47

4M ago5:47

5:47

On September 11, 2001, nearly 3,000 innocent lives were lost in the deadliest terrorist attack on American soil. Twenty-four years later, the memory of that day still shapes who we are as a nation. In this special episode of True Crime Never Sleeps, we pause from our usual cases to reflect on the anniversary of 9/11. From the tragic events in New Y…

1
🤔⚠️The Chicago Ripper Crew⚠️🤔 35:55

4M ago35:55

35:55

Welcome back to Bloodlines & Headlines!! Today we are in Chicago in the 1980s was alive with music, lights, and endless nights—but lurking in the shadows was something far more sinister. A murderous group known as The Chicago Rippers left behind a trail of horror that still haunts the city to this day. In this episode, we dive into their twisted cr…

1
America’s First Serial Killer? The Austin Servant Girl Murders, 1885 Part 2 30:32

4M ago30:32

30:32

Send us a text Join us for part 2 exploring the perpetrator of the Austin Servant Girl Murders. If you or someone you know is a victim of violence, please go to Domestic Violence Support or call the National Domestic Violence Hotline. 800-799-SAFE. The hotline is asnwered 24 hours a day by trained advocates prepared for crisis intervention support,…

1
The Murder of Christina Grimmie: Obsession Turned Deadly 22:26

4M ago22:26

22:26

On June 10, 2016, singer Christina Grimmie was doing what she loved most—meeting fans after a show in Orlando—when her life was tragically cut short. Kevin James Loibl, a 27-year-old man consumed by obsession, approached her during a meet-and-greet and opened fire. Christina’s brother Marcus tackled the gunman, but the damage was done. Christina wa…

1
The Blade Runner Turned Killer 30:51

4M ago30:51

30:51

Fame can build legends—but it can also destroy lives. Oscar Pistorius, once celebrated as the “Blade Runner” and an Olympic hero, went from global icon to convicted murderer after the shocking death of his girlfriend, Reeva Steenkamp. In this episode, we dive deep into Pistorius’ life story—his early struggles, his rise to stardom, his relationship…

1
Where Did Brittany Go? - The Disappearance of Brittany Shank 20:06

4M ago20:06

20:06

On the night of November 30, 2018, 23-year-old Brittany Nichole (Wallace) Shank vanished after a minor car crash in rural St. Joseph County, Michigan. Barefoot, bleeding, and afraid, she knocked on a stranger’s door for help. A 911 call captured her voice, but before deputies could arrive, Brittany disappeared into the darkness—and has never been s…

1
Fatal Fandom - Robert Dewey Hoskins: The Man Who Stalked Madonna 19:51

4M ago19:51

19:51

In this in-depth true crime documentary, we explore the terrifying case of Robert Dewey Hoskins, the mentally ill stalker who broke into Madonna’s Hollywood Hills estate multiple times, made violent threats, and nearly changed the course of pop culture history. From delusions of divine marriage to threats of execution, Hoskins’ obsession spiraled i…

1
🩸The Ripper Files: Unmasking a Legend🩸 51:40

4M ago51:40

51:40

A city shrouded in fog. A killer cloaked in mystery.👀 “From Hell”—two words that changed everything.⚠️⚠️ In this week’s episode, we pull back the fog on one of the world’s oldest and most puzzling unsolved cases: Jack the Ripper. Who were the victims behind the headlines? What clues were missed, misread, or manipulated? And why has the identity of …

1
America’s First Serial Killer? The Austin Servant Girl Murders, 1885 49:19

4M ago49:19

49:19

Send us a text Between 1884 and 1885, a shadowy figure terrorized the city, breaking into homes, dragging women from their beds, and leaving behind scenes so brutal that even hardened reporters became physically ill. The press dubbed him the Servant Girl Annihilator—some later called him the Midnight Assassin or even speculated he was Jack the Ripp…

1
Zodiac Files: Pop Culture - Myth vs Reality 21:01

4M ago21:01

21:01

The Zodiac Killer remains one of true crime’s greatest mysteries. From cryptic ciphers to Fincher’s Zodiac and modern podcasts, we explore how pop culture has kept the legend alive—blurring fact, fiction, and memory. Today's episode is brought to you in part by the following: Patriot Food Supply: ➡️ https://www.rzmaf8trk.com/212KN5C/2CTPL/ Skillsha…

1
The Idaho Four - A Complete Rundown 53:30

4M ago53:30

53:30

We revisit the 2022 University of Idaho murders of Kaylee Goncalves, Madison Mogen, Xana Kernodle, and Ethan Chapin. Three years later, Bryan Kohberger’s guilty plea still leaves unanswered questions about motive and evidence. We break down the timeline, investigation, and what might have surfaced at trial. Today's episode is brought to you in part…

1
The Unsolved Murder of Blair Adams 25:07

5M ago25:07

25:07

In this episode, we dive into the baffling and unsolved 1996 case of Blair Adams—a Canadian man whose erratic cross-country journey ended in a mysterious death in Tennessee. Was it paranoia, mental illness, or something far more sinister? Today's episode is brought to you in part by the following: Patriot Food Supply: ➡️ https://www.rzmaf8trk.com/2…