Best Carl Haley Podcasts (2025)

1
Ep. 54: Duncan MacPherson 54:23

Play Pause

1+ y ago54:23

54:23

We are back from our hiatus with the grim story of Duncan MacPherson. Warning: there are parts of this episode that describe injuries that may be upsetting to some people.

1
Ep. 53: The Mothman part 2 41:29

2y ago41:29

41:29

Welcome to part 2 of the Mothman story where we wrap up the sightings and get into some theories!

1
Ep. 52: The Mothman part 1 46:17

2y ago46:17

46:17

We may not be consistent but boy do we have a doozy of a story for you today. Join us for the first part of the Legend of the Mothman!

1
Ep. 51: James, Paul, and Frieda 33:26

2y ago33:26

33:26

Finishing up with the Bennington Triangle, here are three more cases of missing people from the area.

1
Ep. 50: Carl Herrick and Middie Rivers 32:37

2y ago32:37

32:37

Continuing on our exploration of the Bennington triangle here are two more mysterious stories from the area.

1
Ep. 49: Paula Welden 39:22

2y ago39:22

39:22

Did you miss us? We missed you! This time we brought you another story from Vermont about Paula Welden who went missing in 1946. So stick around for this intriguing case and get ready for more episodes soon!

1
Ep. 48: A brief history of the Bennington Triangle 43:27

2+ y ago43:27

43:27

As promised we have more on the Bennington Triangle. This episode covers more of the strange and dark history surrounding the land in addition to a brief peek into some stories we will be covering in the future.

1
Ep. 48: Rowan Griffin 30:58

2+ y ago30:58

30:58

Tune in for the short but good story about the mysterious circumstances of Rowan Griffin's disappearance in 2010.

1
Ep. 47 Rendlesham Forest Incident pt. 2 1:05:34

2+ y ago1:05:34

1:05:34

That's right we are back and with a part 2 to Haley's story. Buckle up for conspiracy, time travel, and really really bad accents.

1
Ep. 46: Rendlesham Forest Incident pt. 1 1:04:09

2+ y ago1:04:09

1:04:09

I hope you're ready for lots of songs, tangents, and terrible accents. Listen to the story of the Rendlesham Forest Incident where several US officers report seeing a UFO in the woods.

1
Ep. 45: Julie and Lollie 1:08:21

2+ y ago1:08:21

1:08:21

This episode is about the sad and disturbing unsolved murders of Julie Williams and Laura Winans. Tips are still being accepted by the FBI if yo have any information about this case.

1
Ep. 44: Asha Degree 48:04

2+ y ago48:04

48:04

While this case may not take place in as isolated of a spot as our other stories, we still feel it is essential to spread awareness. If you have any tips please call the FBI at 704- 672-6100 or the Cleveland County Sheriff’s Office at 704 484-4822. Also, apologies for the background noise.

1
Ep. 43: Portlock Alaska 1:00:14

2+ y ago1:00:14

1:00:14

Live your haunted Stardew valley life in Portlock, Alaska, the charming ghost town plagued by mysterious deaths and unexplainable creatures. Warning there is some mention of death and dismemberment.

1
Ep. 42: Cian McLaughlin 33:07

3y ago33:07

33:07

This is a bit of a shorter story but very important. Cian went missing in June of 2021 and no trace has been found of him. Anyone with information or tips can email [email protected], or if you have an urgent report call/text 888-653-0009 or email [email protected]. Additionally, if you wish to support the family you can do so at https://www.go…

1
Ep. 41: Daylenn Pua 33:17

3y ago33:17

33:17

Currently posting this episode from a dying computer at a scientific conference, but we wanted to get this story out to you. Join us for the confounding case of Daylenn Pua who went missing in 2015 on the Haiku stairs in Hawaii.

1
Ep. 40: Colin Madsen 44:19

3y ago44:19

44:19

We are going back to Lake Baikal in Siberia (which apparently only Sierra remembers) to discuss the death of Colin Madsen. Content warning: this episode does mention violence and homophobia.

1
Ep. 39: Staircases in the woods 46:54

3y ago46:54

46:54

Remember when Haley said she would do a part two? That didn't happen. Instead, check out these stories about staircases in the woods!

1
Ep. 38: Cullen Finnerty 48:38

3y ago48:38

48:38

Sorry about the late update and some weird audio issues. To make up for it we've brought you the intriguing case of Cullen Finnerty, a famous college football star whose mysterious disappearance and death are still causing people to scratch their heads.

1
Ep. 37: Garrett Bardsley 37:01

3y ago37:01

37:01

Sorry, this episode is late, but you will want to tune in to the interesting tale of Garrett Bardsley. Garrett went missing in 2004 and still the case remains a mystery.

1
Ep. 36: Joshua Maddux 52:56

3y ago52:56

52:56

The story of Joshua Maddux story is both extremely bizarre and extremely infuriating, but we highly recommend people learn more about it and get the word out there. Warning that this episode mentions suicide and violence.

1
Ep. 35: Stacey Arras 35:38

3y ago35:38

35:38

This is a quick story but a good one. Learn about the baffling disappearance of Stacey Arras that helped fuel the creation of David Paulides' Missing 411.

1
Ep. 34: The Lawndale Bird Incident 51:33

3y ago51:33

51:33

We have a lighter episode talking about the Lawndale bird incident. In this episode, you'll learn about the state capitals, facts about Illinois, and bird sounds!

1
Ep. 33: Double Feature - Seneca Guns and Brandon Lawson 1:07:21

3y ago1:07:21

1:07:21

What do these two share? They are extremely interesting and a little shorter than our normal stories, so we decided to combine them. Otherwise, these stories really have nothing in common.

1
Ep. 32: Brandon Swanson 36:55

3y ago36:55

36:55

Join us for the confusing recent case of Brandon Swanson who seemingly disappeared without a trace.

1
Ep. 31: "Mommy is in the trees" 39:19

3+ y ago39:19

39:19

Content warning: some graphic descriptions and mention of domestic violence. Join Haley and Sierra as they try to figure out how a 2-year-old ended up in a parking lot 30 miles away from where her parents were found in the forest.

1
Ep 30: Alfred Beilhartz 48:08

3+ y ago48:08

48:08

We are back! Join us for the 80 year old tale of Alfred Beilhartz

1
Ep 29: Skinwalker Ranch pt2 50:26

3+ y ago50:26

50:26

Hope you weren't holding your breath for this one, but it's finally here! Listen to the second half of the Skinwalker ranch story! Also, after this episode, we will be taking a hiatus until the end of May due to life getting busy. Don't worry though, we will be back soon with tons of other spooky stories, Thanks for listening!…

1
Ep. 28: Skinwalker Ranch pt 1 42:08

3+ y ago42:08

42:08

Content warning: this episode has descriptions of animal mutilation and death. Take a journey with us into the notorious Skinwalker Ranch in northern Utah. This episode is packed full of demons, lore, aliens, and ghost, and it's only part 1!

1
Ep. 27: Russell Hill and Carol Clay 38:35

3+ y ago38:35

38:35

Join us for the very recent story of Russell Hill and Carol Clay as dive into some of the theories around their disappearance.

1
Ep. 26: 1 Year Anniversary! 45:55

3+ y ago45:55

45:55

Can you believe we've been doing this for a full year? We can't either! To celebrate, we have two tales for you this time, so buckle in and get ready for a special episode.

1
Ep. 25: Lake Bodom Incident 46:08

3+ y ago46:08

46:08

Join us Haley shares a great tale with us about Lake Bodom in Finland and we definitely butcher more names and words.

1
Ep. 24: The Hamar Daban Incident 47:15

3+ y ago47:15

47:15

Also known as the Korovina Group Incident, join us for another mysterious tale of a group of hikers in Russia. Apologies ahead of time for terrible pronunciations, but we hope you enjoy the story!

1
Ep. 23: Trenny Gibson 29:42

4y ago29:42

29:42

Join Sierra and Haley for the short but strange story of Trenny Gibson who went missing in the Great Smoky Mountains National park in 1976.

1
Ep. 22: More Mt. Shasta 40:55

4y ago40:55

40:55

Did you want more Mt. Shasta? Well you got more Shasta!

1
Ep 21: David Gonzales 40:26

4y ago40:26

40:26

Sorry for Sierra's poor audio quality and this episode being a little late. In this episode, we discuss the puzzling and sad story of David Gonzales

1
Ep 20: Mount Shasta and the Glock Spiders 57:46

4y ago57:46

57:46

Sorry about the late update, but as you will hear things have been a little crazy. Not as crazy as Mount Shasta, though. Listen in to some of the wild stories about that place.

1
Ep 19: Bigfoot Stole My Baby 41:12

4y ago41:12

41:12

What's better than one mysterious story? Three mysterious stories! Join Haley and Sierra for some spooky stories of kids that went missing in the woods and claimed to encounter an unknown creature.

1
Ep. 18: Bryce Laspisa 47:01

4y ago47:01

47:01

Join us for the confusing case of Bryce Laspisa and Haley's take on the zodiac signs (or at least two of them).

1
Ep. 17: The Savage Lundy Trail Incident 52:02

4y ago52:02

52:02

In this episode, we dive into the recent mysterious death of a California family out on a well-known trail.

1
Ep. 16 Derek Joseph Lueking 42:20

4y ago42:20

42:20

Throwback to the og podcast! Listen to Haley and Sierra discuss the strange case of Derek Lueking.

1
Ep. 15: Jason Knapp 58:37

4y ago58:37

58:37

Was it a serial killer? Or a kid just trying to vanish? You can learn for yourself on this week's episode of Mystery Mountain!

1
Ep. 14: Travis Walton 57:08

4y ago57:08

57:08

Tune in this week to hear the crazy abduction story of Travis Walton near Snowflake, Arizona!

1
Ep. 13: The Palmyra wolves 44:47

4y ago44:47

44:47

We're sorry we are late but we got to record in person! Listen to Sierra tell the interesting tale about the Martin family and the strange happenings around their house.