Best Unsolved Canadian Crime Podcasts (2025)

1
KEEP CANADA WEIRD - 187 - 2025/11/07 - tampered with candy, ding dong ditch, huge tires 56:01

Play Pause

18m ago56:01

56:01

In Keep Canada Weird Jordan and Aaron Airport explore the weird and offbeat Canadian news stories from the past week. In this episode your hosts discuss; 2025’s “tampered with” trick or treating candy stories an over zealous cop vs ding dong ditchers Toronto cops run over suspect… by accident… twice the mystery of the huge tires Series Links Keep C…

1
045 The Black Donnellys 39:40

2h ago39:40

39:40

Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy! On this episode of Canadian Creepies, Valerie and Kyle return to one of the most infamous stories in Canadian folklore — the tale of the Black Donnellys. In the small town of Lucan, Ontario, a simmering feud between neighbours exploded into one of the bloodiest nights in Canadian history. Arson, vigilan…

1
"The Securitas Depot Robbery — Britain’s £53 Million Heist That Shocked the World" 23:29

1d ago23:29

23:29

Welcome back, my little crime connoisseurs! In this jaw-dropping episode of Heists, Hustles, and Homicide, we’re diving into one of Britain’s boldest and most cinematic crimes — the Securitas Depot Robbery of 2006. A gang dressed as cops. A kidnapped manager. A £53 million payday. And a trail of betrayal that unravels like a Guy Ritchie movie writt…

1
the Murder of Alfred Belyea (Suffield, Alberta - 2021) 19:35

8h ago19:35

19:35

In the fall of 2021, Cypress County councilor Alfred “Alf” Belyea vanished from his home in the small Alberta hamlet of Suffield. Within a week, a hand drawn map would lead police to his body… hidden in a garbage bin on an abandoned farm a province away. In this episode of The Canadian Gothic, we hear the story of Alfred and Deborah Belyea. Links: …

1
Force & Frailty / Donald Burgess / PC Stephen Smith & PC Rachel Comotto 53:21

2d ago53:21

53:21

In the quiet corridors of a seaside care home, on an ordinary weekday afternoon, a 92-year-old man sat confused in his wheelchair, gripping a butter knife he'd been using to eat his lunch. Within minutes, two police officers would arrive at his door after being alerted that it was vital for them to attend the scene quickly, as someone’s life had be…

1
DTCP 027 - The Prime Minister and the Spirits 33:20

2d ago33:20

33:20

Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy! On this episode of Down the Crooked Path, we uncover the hidden spiritual life of one of Canada’s most powerful figures — Prime Minister William Lyon Mackenzie King. Behind the formal portraits and wartime speeches was a man who believed the dead could offer guidance to the living. Through séances, crys…

1
The Lost Boys Of Wineville / Chapter 27 33:55

4d ago33:55

33:55

The jury hears the closing remarks. Winifred reveals more details regarding the history of the Northcott family… For more information, visit https://www.thelostboysofwineville.com/ Support this show http://supporter.acast.com/theywalkamongus. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.…

1
202: Sinister Samhain Stories 1:37:01

6d ago1:37:01

1:37:01

Samhain/Sauin season is here and a Happy All Hallow's Eve to all of you! Call them creepy campfire stories, or what you want but we wanted the dark and eerie vibes this time! So let's all snuggle in for the first tale of terror- Kelsey's recitation of the Man Who Watched Me Sleep story?! Or should we say the Red Man Story... Either way, we on the e…

1
KEEP CANADA WEIRD - 186 - 2025/10/31 - Hairbrush Heist, Carwash Chaos, the Red Car Ripper, and Duck Lake 58:24

6d ago58:24

58:24

In Keep Canada Weird Jordan and Aaron Airport explore the weird and offbeat Canadian news stories from the past week. In this episode your hosts discuss; a hairbrush heist Carwash chaos in Sarnia, Ontario the Red Car Ripper of Selkirk Duck Lake, SK - FOR SALE Series Links Keep Canada Weird Series: https://www.thecanadiangothic.com/keep-canada-weird…

1
The Last Hangings in Canada 32:05

7d ago32:05

32:05

On a cold December night in 1962, two men were led through the echoing halls of Toronto’s Don Jail. Beneath their feet, a trapdoor waited. Minutes later, Arthur Lucas and Ronald Turpin became the last people ever executed in Canadian history. In this special Halloween episode, we step back into that chilling night — and the crimes that brought both…

1
044 Unsolved Mysteries: Part 02 42:01

7d ago42:01

42:01

Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy! On this episode of Canadian Creepies, Valerie and Amanda return to the strange and the unsolved — where truth slips through the cracks of history. From the mysterious death of painter Tom Thomson, to the daring Montreal Museum of Fine Arts heist, and the eerie story of a village that vanished, these are…

1
“The Wrap Sheet: Inside the Black Dahlia Files — Lies, Legends, and LAPD Secrets” 13:25

8d ago13:25

13:25

In this Wrap Sheet breakdown, your favorite host Steve pulls the crime scene tape back on one of the most haunting unsolved murders in American history — The Black Dahlia. You’ve heard the story: a young woman found brutally mutilated in a Los Angeles vacant lot in 1947. But you haven’t heard this version. This episode dives deep into the forgotten…

1
2025 Halloween Special - Ghost Stories from Canadian Gothic's Haunted Listeners 1:03:39

8d ago1:03:39

1:03:39

For this Canadian Gothic Halloween special, we gather around a crackling campfire for a night of true ghost stories. Jordan, Madelayne, and Aaron trade the studio for the open air to listen to chilling, unexplained, and sometimes heartfelt ghost stories sent in by listeners across the world. From haunted accommodations in BC and Newfoundland, to a …

1
The Haunting of Lowes Cottage 48:16

8d ago48:16

48:16

The text detailed a remarkable opportunity. A unique one-off property ripe for modernisation, offering adaptable accommodation in a pretty hamlet five minutes from Ashbourne town centre. The home included a sitting room, a second reception room, a kitchen, a bathroom, a half-cellar/workshop, two bedrooms, a large landing suitable for conversion to …

1
DTCP 026 - The Five Fishermen: Haunted by the Tide 24:43

10d ago24:43

24:43

Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy! On this episode of Down the Crooked Path, we head to Halifax, Nova Scotia—where the sea isn’t the only thing that refuses to rest. Once a funeral home, now a fine dining landmark, the Five Fishermen Restaurant has served generations of guests… both living and otherwise. From flickering lights and moving…

1
The Last Fare / David Wilkie & The Miners’ Strike - Part 2 54:36

12d ago54:36

54:36

A taxi driver was simply doing his job during the miners' strike in 1984, when an object was hurled onto the motorway, crushing his car and killing him in the process. Three men had been charged with murder. However, one insisted to the police that he had played no part in the crime. Against the backdrop of the bitter clash between miners and the g…

1
Where are Lilly and Jack Sullivan - Part 13: New Witness Reports, a rogue family member, and a puzzling phone call 50:28

12d ago50:28

50:28

We continue our coverage of the heartbreaking and still-unfolding disappearance of 6-year-old Lilly and 4-year-old Jack Sullivan, who were reported missing from their rural Nova Scotia home on the morning of Friday, May 2. In this episode, we dig into newly unsealed court documents that reveal some truly puzzling details — fresh witness statements,…

1
KEEP CANADA WEIRD - 185 - 2025/10/24 - spooky candy prices, tiktok pissers, firetruck joyride, and a sweater 55:09

14d ago55:09

55:09

In Keep Canada Weird Jordan and Aaron Airport explore the weird and offbeat Canadian news stories from the past week. In this episode your hosts discuss; the spooky prices on Halloween candy the rising trend of ‘pissers’ on social media a firetruck joyride in Halifax a lost and found ugly jacket Series Links Keep Canada Weird Series: ⁠https://www.t…

1
043 Unsolved Mysteries: Part 01 51:05

14d ago51:05

51:05

Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy! This week on Canadian Creepies, Valerie and Amanda dive deep into the strange and the unexplained — stories that have haunted Canada for decades. From mysterious lights in the northern skies to a theatre magnate who disappeared without a trace, these cases blur the line between fact and folklore. Were t…

1
The Last Fare / David Wilkie & The Miners’ Strike - Part 1 50:25

16d ago50:25

50:25

The winter of 1984 forced miners to confront impossible choices. Families faced a dilemma that would tear at the fabric of the country’s tight-knit communities. Miners could continue to strike, pushing them to the brink of poverty, or return to work to put food on the table… (Part 1 of 2). *** LISTENER CAUTION IS ADVISED *** This episode was resear…

1
DTCP 025 - Beneath the Escarpment: The Haunted Tunnels of the Niagara Region 27:31

16d ago27:31

27:31

Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy! On this episode of Down the Crooked Path, we venture deep beneath the Niagara Region—where the earth hides its secrets in stone and shadow. From the eerie depths of the Merritton Tunnel to the forgotten bunkers near Decew Falls, these underground passages have long been home to whispers, footsteps, and …

1
The Lost Boys Of Wineville / Chapter 26 1:10:59

19d ago1:10:59

1:10:59

Gordon Stewart Northcott begins his defence… For more information, visit https://www.thelostboysofwineville.com/ Support this show http://supporter.acast.com/theywalkamongus. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

1
"The Black Dahlia — Blood, Beauty, and the City of Angels" 25:55

21d ago25:55

25:55

Los Angeles, 1947. A housewife takes a morning stroll and stumbles upon what she thinks is a mannequin—until she realizes it’s something far worse. This week, Steve takes you deep into the haunting story of Elizabeth Short, better known as The Black Dahlia—a Hollywood dreamer who became a Hollywood nightmare. From the grisly discovery in an empty l…

1
201: Crimes in Disguise 1:51:11

21d ago1:51:11

1:51:11

Hey cryptic cuties! Hope you are all enjoying the fall and spooky season as much as we are. This week we thought we would take a look at 2 cases involving disguises or costumes (in honour of halloween of course). First up, Kelsey shares the details of the murder of Marlene Warren, who was shot on her doorstep by a creepy clown, and whose identity w…

1
KEEP CANADA WEIRD - 184 - 2025/10/17 - chainsaw in a graveyard, quick change hustlers, Robin's Donuts shrine 54:00

21d ago54:00

54:00

In Keep Canada Weird Jordan and Aaron Airport explore the weird and offbeat Canadian news stories from the past week. In this episode your hosts discuss; the chainsaw incident in a London graveyard Canada’s quick change hustlers a Robin’s Donuts shrine too many puppies in Calgary Series Links Keep Canada Weird Series: ⁠https://www.thecanadiangothic…

1
The Murder of Wayne Mallette and the Wrongful Conviction of Ron Moffatt 58:40

21d ago58:40

58:40

Seven-year-old Wayne Mallette vanished on the deserted grounds of Toronto’s Canadian National Exhibition on September 15, 1956. Within days, police zeroed in on 14-year-old Ron Moffatt, extracting a confession during a parent- and lawyer-free interrogation and securing a juvenile conviction—while the real predator, Peter Woodcock, remained free to …

1
042 Creep of the Week: John Robinson 47:37

21d ago47:37

47:37

Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy! This week's episode is chaos. From Valerie being sick and struggling her way through the insanely wrong information to Daisy barking this one is one for the books. Canadian Creepies presents it's first ever full length Creep of the Week with returning season 1 co-host Kyle! Please note that the victim a…

1
Where are Lilly and Jack Sullivan - Part 12: Five Months Missing 58:25

23d ago58:25

58:25

We continue our coverage of the heartbreaking and still-unfolding disappearance of 6-year-old Lilly and 4-year-old Jack Sullivan, who were reported missing from their rural Nova Scotia home on the morning of Friday, May 2. In this episode, we discuss the recent cadaver dog search conducted in and around the children’s home, and how it may shape the…

1
Unsolved / Vicky Glass 1:03:19

23d ago1:03:19

1:03:19

The man and his dog rambled through the North York Moors towards a stream just outside Danby. Like many locals, they regularly enjoyed walking through the scenic heather-covered moorland. There were always areas off the beaten path where they had never set foot and never saw a soul. That day was different. As they got close to the stream, the man s…

1
DTCP 024 - Skeleton Park 25:34

23d ago25:34

25:34

Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy! Beneath the quiet grass of a neighbourhood park in Kingston, Ontario, thousands of bodies still lie just below the surface. Once a cemetery for the poor, the unknown, and the forgotten, the land was converted into a public park—without removing most of the dead. Locals nicknamed it Skeleton Park, and fo…

1
Encounters With Creeps - Vol. 29 57:41

26d ago57:41

57:41

In Encounters with CREEPS, Canadian Gothic listeners are invited to share their unsettling experiences with the many CREEPS lurking in everyday life. In this episode, Jordan and Madelayne unpack the 29th volume of your Encounters with CREEPS. This time we’ve got CREEPs driver for Uber, CREEPs who CREEP out pregnant woman, and a CREEP in a pizza sho…

1
The Lost Boys Of Wineville / Chapter 25 47:09

26d ago47:09

47:09

The state rests its case… For more information, visit https://www.thelostboysofwineville.com/ Support this show http://supporter.acast.com/theywalkamongus. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

1
KEEP CANADA WEIRD - 183 - 2025/10/10 - Cameras, girl guide scammers, the gander Airport 50:53

28d ago50:53

50:53

In Keep Canada Weird Jordan and Aaron Airport explore the weird and offbeat Canadian news stories from the past week. In this episode your hosts discuss; Manitoba’s ‘Home Security Camera’ Registry Scammers pretending to be Girl Guides the broken hearts at the Gander Airport The Winnipeg family scammed twice COYOTE ATTACK BC!!!! Series Links Keep Ca…

1
041 Shadows Over the St. Lawrence: Haunted Quebec 01 1:02:58

28d ago1:02:58

1:02:58

Send us a text, tell us your canadian creepy! From the mist rising over the St. Lawrence to the echoing corridors of centuries-old fortresses, Quebec is a province built on history—and haunted by it. In this episode of Canadian Creepies, Valerie and Amanda wander through three of Quebec’s most chilling sites: 🕯️ The Château Frontenac, where the gho…

1
The Most Infamous Cold Case | The Black Dahlia 13:47

29d ago13:47

13:47

Way back in 1947, the most infamous unsolved case in American history happened. A young woman was found in a vacant lot in Los Angeles, that young woman was Elizabeth Short, a young woman with hopes and dreams of becoming a Hollywood starlet. Before the investigation could even get going, the media dubbed her the Black Dahlia, and the rest is histo…

1M ago56:36

56:36

In Keep Canada Weird Jordan and Aaron Airport explore the weird and offbeat Canadian news stories from the past week. In this episode your hosts discuss; the weird neighbor and his creepy tunnel Attacks on idling cars in Toronto Doug Ford’s ice cream Continued bannings Series Links Keep Canada Weird Series: https://www.thecanadiangothic.com/keep-ca…