Best Tim & Tay Podcasts (2025)

1
This Teen Rapper in in Prison Now - The Tay-K Story 8:19

Play Pause

4h ago8:19

8:19

The case of Tay-K centers on Taymor McIntyre, a teenage rapper whose rising career was eclipsed by a violent spiral that began with his involvement in a 2016 home-invasion robbery that left 21-year-old Ethan Walker dead. While awaiting trial, McIntyre cut off his ankle monitor and fled, turning his run from the law into a combustible piece of inter…

1
This Shady Politician is in Prison Now - The Sidney Dorsey Story 8:29

11h ago8:29

8:29

Sidney Dorsey, once the elected sheriff of DeKalb County, Georgia, slid from power into infamy after a bitter 2000 election he lost to challenger Derwin Brown. Investigators later uncovered that Dorsey, desperate to keep control of the department and shield himself from internal corruption probes, orchestrated a murder plot targeting Brown before h…

1
The Russian Female Serial Killer - The Irina Gaidamachuk Story 8:05

7h ago8:05

8:05

Irina Gaidamachuk was a Russian serial killer who spent nearly a decade preying on elderly women across the Sverdlovsk region, posing as a social-services worker to slip into their apartments before bludgeoning them to death and stealing small amounts of cash to fuel her alcoholism. Her crimes stretched from 2002 to 2010 and baffled investigators, …

1
The Famous TV Host Who KIlled For Ratings - The Wallace Souza Story 8:36

2h ago8:36

8:36

Wallace Souza was a former police officer turned TV host in Manaus who rose to fame in 1996 with his crime show Canal Livre, a sensational program that often arrived at murder scenes faster than law enforcement. As his popularity grew, he leveraged his tough-on-crime persona into political power, winning a seat as a state legislator. But in 2009, i…

1
This Maniac Killed His CoWorker - The Tom Monfils Story 8:08

16h ago8:08

8:08

Tom Monfils’s death in 1992 at the James River paper mill in Green Bay became one of Wisconsin’s most controversial homicide cases. After Monfils made an anonymous call reporting a coworker for theft, the recorded tip was improperly released to the mill, exposing him and heightening already strained workplace tensions. He vanished during his shift,…

1
SSC 109: Die Hard (McTiernan, 1988) 1:32:06

1d ago1:32:06

1:32:06

In Die Hard, a New York cop must single-handedly battle a group of terrorists who have seized a Los Angeles skyscraper and taken hostages during a Christmas Eve party, including his estranged wife. Die Hard was released on July 15, 1988, and stars Bruce Willis, Alan Rickman, Bonnie Bedelia, and Reginald VelJohnson, and was directed by John McTierna…

1
The Pro Athlete Turned Drug Smuggler - The Missy Giove Story 8:17

1d ago8:17

8:17

Missy Giove rocketed to fame in the 1990s as one of the most aggressive and charismatic downhill mountain bikers in the world, blasting through the NORBA circuit and winning the 1994 UCI Downhill World Championship while turning herself into an extreme-sports icon with her punk-charged energy. After retiring from competition, her life swerved into …

1
He Stole Millions... From Netflix - The Carl Rinsch Story 9:32

3d ago9:32

9:32

Carl Rinsch’s case centers on the collapse of his Netflix project White Horse aka Conquest, in which he was entrusted with a large production budget but allegedly misused significant portions of the funds. Instead of directing the money toward the series, Rinsch reportedly diverted millions into personal luxury purchases and high-risk options tradi…

1
The Biggest Scandal in the NBA - The Tim Donaghy Story 8:33

5d ago8:33

8:33

Between 2005 and 2007, Tim Donaghy bet on games he officiated and supplied inside information to gamblers, exploiting injury reports, referee assignments, and his influence over foul calls. His actions triggered a federal investigation that exposed a network of illicit betting tied to organized crime.…

1
He's Youtube's Biggest Creep - The Elliot Rodger Story 8:46

6d ago8:46

8:46

Elliot Rodger’s case is a documented progression from early social withdrawal and untreated psychological distress to a lethal act of targeted violence in Isla Vista in 2014. Born in 1991, Rodger struggled for years with isolation, rigid self-focused thinking, and growing resentment toward peers, particularly women, whom he believed rejected him. A…

1
She Was Hypnotized Into a Crime? - The Heather Tallchief Story 8:32

7d ago8:32

8:32

Heather Tallchief’s life took a drastic turn in 1993, when she became involved with Roberto Solis, a recently paroled murderer whose influence drew her into one of the most successful armored-truck thefts in U.S. history. At age 21, while working as a Loomis driver in Las Vegas, she quietly drove away from her route with millions of dollars and dis…

1
Murder Over Chicken Wings - The Deveius Weather Story 8:01

8d ago8:01

8:01

In 2022, Deveius Weathers allegedly shot and killed another man at a neighborhood barbecue, after an argument involving chicken wings.

1
This Scammer Got Exposed By a Youtuber 8:13

9d ago8:13

8:13

Youtuber Pierogi aka Scammer Payback along with fellow Youtube channel Trilogy media work together to expose and dismantle a $65 million dollar mutinational fraud ring.

1
Ashton Kutcher's Date Was Murdered - The Michael Gargiulo Story 8:31

11d ago8:31

8:31

Michael Gargiulo, the so-called Hollywood Ripper, was a predator who operated in plain sight, drifting through Los Angeles with the easy confidence of a man no one suspected. His violence began in 1993, when he murdered 18-year-old Tricia Pacaccio in Illinois at just sixteen, then followed him west years later. In Hollywood, he befriended and fixat…

1
The Dirty Cult Killer - The Pazuzu Algarad Story 8:43

13d ago8:43

8:43

Pazuzu Algarad, born John Lawson, was a deeply disturbed man in Clemmons, North Carolina who reinvented himself as a self-styled demon and gathered vulnerable people into a chaotic, drug-soaked, filthy house where violence and decay festered unchecked. In 2009, he murdered Joshua Wetzler, leaving the body in his basement for weeks before burying it…

1
This Reality TV Producer Killed Someone - The Jean-Claude and Hilde Story 8:43

14d ago8:43

8:43

Jean-Claude Lacote and Hilde Van Acker were a Belgian couple who became internationally notorious after the 1996 murder of British businessman Simon Dale, a crime they committed in Knokke-Heist before fleeing the country and vanishing for more than two decades. Skilled con artists, they slipped through Europe, the United States, South Africa, Brazi…

1
She Faked Having Cancer - The Jenny Cataldo Story 8:22

15d ago8:22

8:22

Jenny Cataldo spun a long, emotional hoax by pretending she had terminal cancer, complete with shaved-head photos, fake medical stories, and tearful updates that pulled friends, coworkers, and strangers into her invented struggle. Over several years she accepted money, gifts, and donations from people who genuinely believed they were helping her su…

1
She Took Everything From Her Boyfriend - The Sabrina Taylor Story 8:39

16d ago8:39

8:39

Sabrina Taylor spent years weaving a sympathy-soaked lie, pretending she had multiple sclerosis and a stack of other crises so she could drain more than half a million dollars from friends and online acquaintances who believed they were helping her stay alive, stay in school, or rescue family members who didn’t actually exist. Beginning around 2013…

1
SSC 108: Black Christmas (Clark, 1974) 1:33:21

16d ago1:33:21

1:33:21

During Christmas break, a group of sorority sisters at Pi Kappa Sigma begin receiving disturbing obscene phone calls from an unknown stranger. As the festive season continues, the mysterious caller's threats escalate from harassment to deadly violence. Black Christmas was released on October 11, 1974, and stars Olivia Hussey, Keir Dullea, Margot Ki…

1
This Fake Cop Finally Got Arrested - The Michael Scaletta-Teates Story 8:05

17d ago8:05

8:05

In 2025, Michael Scaletta-Teates of Washington state goes to great lengths to pretend to be a police officer- outfitting his car with red and blue emergency lights, wearing a ballistic-style vest and badge, and appearing at crime scenes.

1
The Con Man Who "Married" His Daughter - The Albert Walker Story 8:33

18d ago8:33

8:33

Albert Johnson Walker was a Canadian financial adviser who stole over $3 million CAD from clients in the late 1980s, then fled Canada in 1990 with his teenage daughter Sheena to avoid prosecution. While living in England under false names, he manipulated and ultimately stole the identity of a British man named Ronald Platt, even convincing Platt to…

1
This Woman is The Worst Person I've Ever Covered - The Pam Hupp Story 8:24

24d ago8:24

8:24

Pam Hupp is a Missouri woman at the center of one of the most notorious wrongful-conviction cases in the U.S. in 2011, after her close friend Betsy Faria was brutally stabbed to death, Hupp- who had secretly made herself the beneficiary of Betsy’s $150k life-insurance policy just days earlier- helped steer police toward Betsy’s husband Russ Faria, …

1
The Diaper-Wearing Murdering Lawyer - The Andrew and Alecia Schmuhl Story 8:37

21d ago8:37

8:37

Andrew and Alecia Schmuhl’s case is one of the most shocking and bizarre crimes in recent Virginia history: after Alecia was fired from her law firm, she and her husband spiraled into desperation and rage, culminating on November 9, 2014, when Alecia drove Andrew- dressed in an adult diaper, latex gloves, and a fake badge- to the home of her former…

1
He Killed Hundreds of People - The Timothy McVeigh Story 8:12

22d ago8:12

8:12

Timothy McVeigh was a Gulf War veteran whose growing hatred of the federal government- fueled by the Ruby Ridge standoff, the Waco siege, militia-movement ideology, and The Turner Diaries- led him to plan and execute the 1995 Oklahoma City bombing.

1
He Scammed Millions of Dollars With Pigeons - The Arlan Galbraith Story 8:54

23d ago8:54

8:54

Apparently we need to get into the pigeon racing business 😳 - Arlan Galbraith known as The Pigeon King, ran one of Canada’s strangest and most devastating Ponzi schemes, convincing hundreds of farmers across Canada and the U.S. to buy expensive breeding pigeons with promises that he would buy back the offspring at a guaranteed profit. Galbraith cla…

1
SSC 107: Pan's Labyrinth (del Toro, 2006) 1:28:51

24d ago1:28:51

1:28:51

In Pan's Labyrinth, a young girl seeks her mythical royal heritage in a magical labyrinth during the Spanish Civil War. Starring Ivana Baquero, Sergi López and Doug Jones and directed by Guillermo del Toro, Pan's Labyrinth was released December 29, 2006. Links: Listers Recommendations: Tim: The Wizard of Oz (Fleming, 1939) Tay: Fantastic Planet (La…

1
He's The Worst Hitman In History - The Joe Rosebrook Story 8:02

24d ago8:02

8:02

The Joe Rosebrook case centers on a long-simmering grudge, a murder-for-hire plot, and a catastrophic case of mistaken identity that went unsolved for nearly a decade. Rosebrook, a small-time Ohio fraudster and chop-shop operator with a habit of retaliating against people he believed had crossed him, sought revenge against a man named Daniel E. Ott…

1
She's Pretending to be 14 - The Samantha Azzopardi Story 8:29

25d ago8:29

8:29

Samantha Azzopardi is an Australian serial con artist whose crimes span more than a decade and multiple countries, built almost entirely on elaborate false identities.

1
The Man Who Killed Michael Jackson - The Dr. Conrad Murray Story 8:37

27d ago8:37

8:37

In 2009, Michael Jackson died of an overdose at his Los Angeles home. A powerful anesthetic propofol had been administered by his personal physician, Dr. Conrad Murray. In a highly publicized 2011 trial, Murray was convicted of involuntary manslaughter.

1
This Stranger Things Star Has a Dark Past - The Winona Ryder Story 8:40

28d ago8:40

8:40

Actress Winona Ryder was caught stealing more than $5,000 worth of designer clothing and accessories from Saks Fifth Avenue in Beverly Hills. Security detained her after observing her cutting sensor tags and walking out with the merchandise, leading to her high-profile arrest and a media frenzy that dominated early-2000s pop culture.…

1
She's a Real Life Vampire - The Daniel and Manuela Ruda Story 8:09

29d ago8:09

8:09

In July 2001, German couple Daniel and Manuela Ruda- deeply involved in Satanic and vampire-themed beliefs- lured their friend, 33-year-old Frank Hackert, to their apartment in Witten and brutally murdered him in what they described as a ritual killing. Manuela had filed her teeth into fangs and slept in a coffin, and Daniel claimed he’d received a…

1
The Girl Who Was Hit By a Train - The Yareni Rios-Gonzalez Story 7:59

1M ago7:59

7:59

Yareni Rios-Gonzalez was involved in a reported road-rage incident in Weld County, Colorado, on September 16, 2022, after a man called 911 claiming she tailgated him and pointed a firearm. Police pulled her over near Platteville, where officers from two departments handcuffed her and placed her in the back of a patrol SUV that one officer had parke…

1
This Postman Went Insane - The Devan Schreiner Story 8:05

1M ago8:05

8:05

Devan Schreiner, a former USPS worker from Longmont, Colorado, was locked in a turbulent custody battle with her ex-boyfriend, postal carrier Jason Schaefer, the father of their young son. Their relationship had soured after years of conflict, and shortly before the murder she was fired from the post office following an undisclosed “incident.” Pros…

1
The World's Craziest Diamond Heist - The Leonardo Notarbartolo Story 8:06

1M ago8:06

8:06

Leonardo Notarbartolo was the mastermind behind the 2003 Antwerp Diamond Heist, one of the most ingenious burglaries ever pulled off. Working with a crew of elite Italian thieves, he spent over a year posing as a diamond trader to gain access to the Antwerp Diamond Center, a building considered nearly impenetrable thanks to its multilayered securit…

1
He Started Hundreds of Fires - The John Orr Story 8:58

1M ago8:58

8:58

John Orr was a respected Glendale, California fire captain and arson investigator who spent nearly a decade secretly setting the very fires he was supposed to prevent. Between 1984 and 1991, Orr ignited hundreds possibly thousands of fires.

1
He's The Most Corrupt Cop in History - The Rafael Perez Story 8:28

1M ago8:28

8:28

Rafael Pérez was an LAPD officer whose crimes detonated the largest police-corruption scandal in Los Angeles history. A member of the elite Rampart Division CRASH unit, Pérez spent years planting guns, framing suspects, falsifying reports, beating civilians, and even shooting unarmed people- including paralyzing 19-year-old Javier Ovando, then lyin…

1
The Worst Dad In History - The Ronnie O'Neal Story 8:29

1M ago8:29

8:29

Ronnie O’Neal III committed one of Florida’s most shocking family murders on March 18, 2018. His son miraculously survived, crawled out of the burning house, and later testified against his father in court.

1
SSC 106: The Shape of Water 1:31:19

1M ago1:31:19

1:31:19

In The Shape of Water, a mute janitor working in a government laboratory forms a bond with a captive amphibious creature. Starring Sally Hawkins, Doug Jones and Michael Shannon and directed by Guillermo del Toro, The Shape of Water was released December 1, 2017. Recommendations: Tay — The Lure (Smoczynska, 2015) Tim — The Elephant Man (Lynch, 1980)…

1
She Killed Both Her Husbands - The Velma Barfield Story 8:56

1M ago8:56

8:56

Velma Barfield was a North Carolina caretaker who became one of the most notorious female poisoners in U.S. history. Between 1971 and 1978, she quietly murdered multiple people in her orbit- beginning with her husband, Jennings Barfield, who died in a suspicious house fire while he slept, and later her own mother, along with an elderly couple she s…

1
Trapped Underwater For 60 Hours - The Harrison Okene Story 8:06

1M ago8:06

8:06

The Nigerian cook Harrison Okene was using the bathroom on a tugboat when a massive wave capsized the vessel and sent it to the ocean floor about 100 feet down. Trapped in total darkness, surrounded by drowning crew members, Okene found a tiny pocket of trapped air inside a bathroom and laundry area. He survived nearly three days in that pitch-blac…

1
The Craziest Ex Girlfriend - The Jodi Arias Story 8:34

1M ago8:34

8:34

Jodi Arias brutally murdered her ex-boyfriend, Travis Alexander, a charismatic Mormon salesman from Mesa, Arizona. The pair had met two years earlier at a business conference and quickly began a passionate but toxic relationship marked by jealousy, obsession, and sexual tension that clashed with Travis’s religious values. After he tried to end thin…

1
The Con Man Who Faked His Own Death - The Samuel Israel Story 8:58

1M ago8:58

8:58

Samuel Israel III was a New York hedge fund manager who founded the Bayou Hedge Fund Group in 1996 and orchestrated one of the largest financial frauds of the early 2000s. After years of falsifying trading records and using a fake accounting firm to hide losses, Israel’s $300 million Ponzi scheme collapsed in 2005 when investors tried to withdraw t…

1
She Scammed People with Magic Cheese? - The Madame Gi Story 8:21

1M ago8:21

8:21

Gilberte Van Erpe aka Madame Gil is a Belgian con artist who launched a fake health and cosmetics company called Crema in the early 2000s. Posing as the mystical “Madame Gil,” she convinced thousands of people- especially in Chile- to invest in a bogus line of “magic cheese” and other products that supposedly contained miraculous healing or cosmeti…

1
He Killed His Own Parents - The Bart Whitaker Story 8:34

2M ago8:34

8:34

In 2003, Thomas “Bart” Whitaker orchestrated a murder-for-hire plot against his own family in Sugar Land, Texas, in order to claim his inheritance. After luring his parents and brother home from a celebratory dinner, his friend Christopher Brashear ambushed them inside the house, killing Bart’s mother and brother and seriously wounding his father, …

1
He Tried To Kill The President? - The Kevin Curtis Story 8:49

2M ago8:49

8:49

Mississippi Elvis impersonator Paul Kevin Curtis was wrongly accused of sending ricin-laced letters to President Obama, Senator Roger Wicker, and a local judge. Curtis had a history of posting online about an alleged hospital cover-up after he claimed to have discovered human body parts in 2001 while working as a janitor.…

1
This Creep Stalked His Own Wife - The Daniel Krug Story 8:14

2M ago8:14

8:14

In December 2023, 44-year-old Daniel Krug of Broomfield, Colorado murdered his wife, Kristil Krug, in the garage of their home after months of secretly tormenting her with fake messages from a made-up stalker he created using burner phones and multiple online identities. Posing as her ex-boyfriend Jack, Daniel sent harassing emails and photos to bo…

1
She Fell In Love With a Murderer and Helped Him Escape - The Bobbi Parker Story 8:39

2M ago8:39

8:39

In 1994, Bobbi Parker, the wife of an Oklahoma prison deputy warden, vanished from the Oklahoma State Reformatory along with inmate Randolph Dial, a convicted murderer and artist who had been given unusual privileges due to his painting skills. For 11 years, the two lived under assumed identities on a remote chicken farm in Texas until their discov…

1
He Faked Being a Doctor For Years - The Gerald Barnbaum Story 8:55

2M ago8:55

8:55

Gerald Barnbaum was a conman who spent decades posing as a medical doctor despite never being one. Born in 1933 in Chicago, he was originally a licensed pharmacist, but his license was revoked. Rather than reform, Barnbaum found a new and more dangerous way to exploit the medical system: he began impersonating real physicians, using their stolen id…

1
The Founder of Aldi Got Kidnapped - The Theo Albrecht Story 8:21

2M ago8:21

8:21

In November 1971, Theo Albrecht, the reclusive German billionaire co-founder of Aldi supermarkets, was kidnapped at gunpoint outside his company’s headquarters in Essen, Germany, by Heinz-Joachim Ollenburg and Paul Krüzen, a pair of small-time criminals seeking a massive ransom. The kidnappers held him for 17 days.…

1
He Thinks He's Batman - The Matthew Muller Story 8:47

2M ago8:47

8:47

Matthew Muller was a former Marine and Harvard-educated lawyer whose life spiraled into a series of bizarre crimes. In 2015, he broke into the Vallejo, California home of Denise Huskins and Aaron Quinn, abducting Denise and demanding ransom in what police initially dismissed as a hoax inspired by Gone Girl. Muller, who suffered from mental illness …