Best Pitcher List Podcasts (2026)

1
OTC 591 - Finding SP Super Sleepers 55:23

Play Pause

1h ago55:23

55:23

On The Corner Nick Pollack and Eric Samulski look at the early ADP and highlight some of their favorite late round targets. Nerd out about pitching and fantasy baseball weekly with Pitcher List's Nick Pollack (@PitcherList) and NBC Sports' Eric Samulski (@SamskiNYC). Support us: https://pitcherlist.com/premium/ Our Award Winning Baseball Site: http…

1
Full Show: Whatever the Giants Do, Don't Let John Harbaugh Leave 3:16:51

28m ago3:16:51

3:16:51

John Harbaugh can't leave Metlife; Breaking News: Ranger Suarez signs with the Red Sox and Dante Moore stays in school. With Dante Moore sticking in Oregon, what does that mean for the New York Jets number two draft pick. Does Ty Simpson make a leap? Plus, Carton breaks down the ridiculous award shows, and a caller gives the Carton Show a new name.…

1
Hour 1: Breaking News Hits Left And Right 1:02:40

32m ago1:02:40

1:02:40

John Harbaugh can't leave Metlife; Breaking News: Ranger Suarez signs with the Red Sox and Dante Moore stays in school.

1
Hour 2: Do the Jets Need to Pivot With the Number Two Pick In the Draft? 56:45

38m ago56:45

56:45

With Dante Moore sticking in Oregon, what does that mean for the New York Jets number two draft pick. Does Ty Simpson make a leap? Plus, Carton breaks down the ridiculous award shows, and a caller gives the Carton Show a new name.

1
Hour 3: Connor Hughes Breaks News Regarding John Harbaugh Interview 20:06

41m ago20:06

20:06

SNY's Connor Hughes joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle to give the latest on the John Harbaugh meeting. Plus, Connor breaks the news that Jaxson Dart has met with John Harbaugh.

1
Hour 4: John Harbaugh Has Left the Building 57:19

1h ago57:19

57:19

It's Wednesday... which means it's time for another episode of "What the F*** Wednesday". Also word breaks that the Giants are wrapping up their interview with John Harbaugh and that he is indeed.... leaving the building.

1
Giants Coaching Search Update: Jaxson Dart Meets John Harbaugh 22:36

21m ago22:36

22:36

On today’s Carton Show, Big Mac and Craig Carton break down exclusive details from insider Connor Hughes about the Giants’ head coaching search. Hear why Jaxson Dart’s involvement in meeting John Harbaugh and other candidates is a smart move for the franchise’s future. Plus, get the latest on Harbaugh’s interview timeline, his upcoming visit with t…

1
Carton Show WTF Wednesday: Kyle Tucker Contract Drama, Giants Coaching Rumors & Jets Coach Aaron Glenn Locked In 17:41

22m ago17:41

17:41

On this WTF Wednesday edition of the Carton Show with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle, the hosts dive into hot New York sports topics. They break down the ongoing Kyle Tucker contract saga with the Mets and what his passion (or lack thereof) for baseball means for a potential deal. Plus, insider calls reveal the latest on John Harbaugh and the New…

1
Giants Coaching Search Deep Dive with NFL Insider Connor Hughes 18:54

32m ago18:54

18:54

On this segment of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle sit down with NFL insider Connor Hughes to discuss the New York Giants' intense pursuit of John Harbaugh as their next head coach. Connor shares exclusive updates on Harbaugh’s potential visit to the Falcons, the Giants’ impressive coaching offer, and how the franchise legends lik…

1
Barbecue Sauce Bets, Giants Coaching Buzz & Classic Carton Rants 20:01

15m ago20:01

20:01

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle bring classic Carton Show chaos as Giants coaching buzz heats up and the guys debate how fans should celebrate a potential John Harbaugh hire — including a ridiculous barbecue sauce bath bet. The conversation rolls into what the Giants really need to become relevant again, why simply “normal” winning football would …

1
Ty Simpson Declares, Jets on the Clock & Why New York Sports Isn’t “Toxic” 18:46

40m ago18:46

18:46

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down a jam-packed segment that starts with a major correction and a big college football storyline as Ty Simpson officially declares for the NFL Draft, reshaping the Jets’ options with the No. 2 overall pick. The guys debate whether the Jets must leave the draft with a quarterback at all costs, trade scenarios…

1
Breaking News: Dante Moore Staying In School, Did the Jets Dodge A Bullet? 16:21

5m ago16:21

16:21

Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle are interrupted by breaking news that Oregon QB Dante Moore has decided to stay in school another year. Craig Carton discusses why this may be a great thing for the Jets & their fans.

1
Ranger Suarez Off the Board & The Yankees Get a Starting Pitcher. 10:25

12m ago10:25

10:25

As the fellas discuss the Yankees big trade for Ryan Weathers, news breaks that Ranger Suarez is headed to Boston and why it puts pressure on the Mets & David Stearns.

1
Giants Fans Getting Anxious About John Harbaugh? The Carton Show Breaks It Down 14:23

16m ago14:23

14:23

The Carton Show kicks off with Craig and Big Mac diving deep into the Giants fans psyche and figuring out if they are starting to get anxious as the John Harbaugh saga continues.

1
Bye, Bye Belli? | 'NYYST' 1:05:12

17h ago1:05:12

1:05:12

From 'NYYST' (subscribe here): With reports surfacing that the Yankees and Cody Bellinger at an impasse should the Yankees move on and focus on other options? Join Christian and Sem and they discuss what should be next for the Yankees. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn …

1
Hitter Targets with Owen Hurd 1:20:14

1d ago1:20:14

1:20:14

Paul Williamson is joined by Owen Hurd of Scout the Statlline as they discuss the Nolan Arenado deal, the new look Kauffman Stadium and their favorite hitter targets for 2026 drafts. Presented by FanDuel SUBSCRIBE, Rate and Review on Apple and Spotify! Follow us on Twitter: @EthosFantasyBB Follow us on Bluesky: @ethosfantasymlb Join our Fantasy Spo…

1
Full Show: Mike Tomlin Steps Down As Head Coach of Pittsburgh Steelers, Kyle Tucker Reports 3:14:49

21m ago3:14:49

3:14:49

Breaking News: Mike Tomlin steps down as coach of the Pittsburgh Steelers, Did the Giants start the trend of getting big talent to call up coaches? Does Mike Tomlin set to take a year off hurt or help the Jets? Jordan Schultz stops by to discuss the latest in the head coach market, Brian Daboll is not just a good football guy; He's a great guy peri…

1
Hour 1: Mike Tomlin Out as Steelers Head Coach, Giants Embarrass Themselves While Courting John Harbaugh 50:17

5m ago50:17

50:17

Hour 1: Mike Tomlin Out as Steelers Head Coach, Giants Embarrass Themselves While Courting John Harbaugh

1
Hour 2: Craig’s Wild Mike Tomlin Master Plan, Jordan Schultz & C-Mac’s Eagles Scandal 43:54

10m ago43:54

43:54

Hour 2: Craig’s Wild Mike Tomlin Master Plan, Jordan Schultz & C-Mac’s Eagles Scandal

1
Hour 3: Brian Daboll's Next Stop, Jets Lengthy Rebuild Incoming, Beer & Baths 52:00

15m ago52:00

52:00

This hour of the show Craig & Big Mac dive into Jaxson Dart's Trajectory after hearing Brian Daboll was very complimentary of him to aspiring head coaches, also could Daboll be going to Philly? The guys also debate the Jets future, whether bath's are ok for grown men and "shower beers" being a thing.…

1
Hour 4: Mets’ Kyle Tucker Shock & Carton’s Wild “Pound for Pound” Argument, and More Coaching Carousel 48:36

22m ago48:36

48:36

The Carton Show goes everywhere in this unforgettable segment as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle juggle NFL coaching chaos, baseball money madness, and classic Carton off-the-rails debates. The guys react to Mike Tomlin officially stepping away in Pittsburgh, break down the pros and cons of John Harbaugh for the Giants, and compare frustrated Gian…

1
Is Kyle Tucker a 50 Million Dollar A Year Player? 30:52

17m ago30:52

30:52

Craig and Big Mac debate whether the Mets would be making a mistake if they paid Kyle Tucker 50 million dollars a year. The guys also debate what pound for pound would mean when the show flew off the rails at the end of this segment.

1
Mets Finally Act, $50M Kyle Tucker Push & Why Steve Cohen Has to Spend 9:43

40m ago9:43

9:43

With Craig Carton off the air, Chris McMonigle takes over solo and delivers a passionate breakdown of the Mets’ most aggressive move of the offseason. C-Mac reacts to reports that the Mets are willing to offer Kyle Tucker up to $50 million per year on a short-term deal, explaining why Tucker is the best free agent bat on the market and exactly what…

1
Mike Tomlin’s Future, Giants’ Harbaugh Push & Why the Jets Need a Full Rebuild 20:52

23m ago20:52

20:52

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive deep into the NFL coaching carousel as Mike Tomlin officially steps away, sparking debate over whether teams like the Jets should suffer one more year to land a proven winner. The guys break down why the Giants appear to be the favorites for John Harbaugh, reveal behind-the-scenes reporting on John Mara, Eli Ma…

1
NFL Coaching Chaos, Daboll to Philly Rumors & the Great Bath Debate 31:07

1h ago31:07

31:07

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down a wild NFL coaching carousel as top jobs open across the league and big names are linked everywhere. The guys debate how real the Giants’ chances are with John Harbaugh, why Tennessee and Atlanta are suddenly attractive destinations, and whether Brian Daboll could shock everyone by landing as the Eagles’ …

1
NFL Insider Jordan Schultz Breaks Down Mike Tomlin, Harbaugh, Rodgers & the Wild Coaching Carousel 27:07

24m ago27:07

27:07

NFL insider Jordan Schultz joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle on The Carton Show to break down one of the craziest NFL coaching cycles in recent memory. Schultz reacts to Mike Tomlin stepping down from the Pittsburgh Steelers, explains why a year away from football and a TV stint are likely, and details how the Steelers would still control Toml…

1
Mike Tomlin Steps Away, Jets Dream Scenario & Proof C-Mac Isn’t a Real Giants Fan 11:57

34m ago11:57

11:57

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle mix NFL chaos with classic Carton Show humor as breaking news hits: Mike Tomlin officially steps away from the Pittsburgh Steelers. The guys react in real time, read Tomlin’s statement, and debate what it really means for the future of the Giants and Jets. Craig lays out a wild but calculated Jets master plan involv…

1
Tomlin Steps Away, Harbaugh Watch Heats Up & Giants Go Full Court Press on WFAN 25:37

2h ago25:37

25:37

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive headfirst into NFL coaching chaos as Mike Tomlin officially steps away from the Pittsburgh Steelers, ending one of the most remarkable coaching runs in league history. The guys break down Tomlin’s Hall of Fame résumé, why he never had a losing season, and how unfairly he’s been treated by parts of the Steelers …

1
SHOCKER: Mike Tomlin Out as Steelers Head Coach, Giants & Jets Put On Alert 23:02

4h ago23:02

23:02

Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle kick off the show debating the Giants strategy to wooing John Harbaugh when news of Mike Tomlin stepping down as Steeler head coach starts to circulate.

1
PPP 749 – All New York Mets Starting Pitchers For 2026 27:44

6h ago27:44

27:44

PPP 749 – All New York Mets Starting Pitchers For 2026 The Plus Pitch Podcast with Nick Pollack from Pitcher List, reviewing all Fantasy Baseball starting pitchers on the Boston Red Sox for 2026. Which SPs are sleepers for this season? Stay on top of everything with Nick's daily Starting Pitcher Roundup article, SP Streamer Rankings article, and we…

1
PPP 749 – All New York Mets Starting Pitchers For 2026 27:44

2h ago27:44

27:44

PPP 749 – All New York Mets Starting Pitchers For 2026 The Plus Pitch Podcast with Nick Pollack from Pitcher List, reviewing all Fantasy Baseball starting pitchers on the Boston Red Sox for 2026. Which SPs are sleepers for this season? Stay on top of everything with Nick's daily Starting Pitcher Roundup article, SP Streamer Rankings article, and we…

1
Homecoming 52:58

18m ago52:58

52:58

Loss is a funny thing. It doesn’t always hit you in the chest, full-force. It can be quiet. Written by Lex Vranick Narrated by Brooke Jennett Additional voices provided by Ian Epperson Music composed by Caleb Ritchie Editing and sound design by Brooke Jennett Video Editing by Brooke Jennett Assistance from Bridgett Freeman Check out our merch store…

1
Full Show: Jets Had the Worst Weekend Of Any NFL Team; And They Didn't Even Play! 3:16:36

2d ago3:16:36

3:16:36

The Jets get screwed in the draft, John Harbaugh is going to narrow down his teams, Tequila is good for Achilles, The dream team; Robert Saleh & Mike McDaniel, Super Bowl runs through LA, Bring in the big guns to recruit Jon Harbaugh, Top Five Things Craig Doesn't Like, Lakers put a hold on shoot arounds because LeBron James is too old, Tony Romo i…

1
HOUR 1: Bummer For Jets Fans, LOL Eagles, and Harbaugh Watch Continues 41:30

18h ago41:30

41:30

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open the show with Craig unloading on what he calls a brutal weekend for Jets fans, despite an incredible slate of playoff football. The Bills advance, the Patriots win again, and Dante Moore’s national stage performance only fuels Craig’s fear of the Jets getting it wrong—again. Plus, Carton celebrates the Eagles’ …

1
Hour 2: Harbaugh Watch Gets Crazy, The Perfect Omlette Station, and a Coaching Duo Made in Heaven! 55:00

2d ago55:00

55:00

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle turn a simple football discussion into a wildly entertaining Carton Show segment that only they can deliver. The guys debate which NFL team looks the most Super Bowl–ready, break down Rams, Texans, 49ers and Steelers takes, and question Ben Johnson’s shaky playoff coaching decisions.Along the way, the conversation v…

1
Hour 3: Harbaugh Anxiety, Texans Super Bowl, Contenders, & Craigs Top 5 List! 40:49

16m ago40:49

40:49

Hour 3: Harbaugh Anxiety, Texans Super Bowl, Contenders, & Craigs Top 5 List!

1
Hour 4: Carton Obliterates LeBron, Sparks Giants–Jets QB War, & Torch NFL Broadcasters 59:16

2d ago59:16

59:16

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle let it rip in this Carton Show segment as a listener sparks an all-out takedown of Tony Romo’s NFL broadcasting style. From awkward noises and talking to himself to abandoning his once-great pre-snap predictions, the guys debate whether Romo has officially worn out his welcome in the booth. The conversation expands …

1
Tony Romo Has Become Unwatchable? Carton & C-Mac Torch NFL Broadcasters, Praise Greg Olsen & Debate Jets QB Dreams 14:16

2d ago14:16

14:16

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle let it rip in this Carton Show segment as a listener sparks an all-out takedown of Tony Romo’s NFL broadcasting style. From awkward noises and talking to himself to abandoning his once-great pre-snap predictions, the guys debate whether Romo has officially worn out his welcome in the booth. The conversation expands …

1
Carton Obliterates LeBron, Trashes the Bubble Title & Sparks Giants–Jets QB War on WFAN 27:45

44m ago27:45

27:45

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle deliver a classic Carton Show segment that spirals from a savage LeBron James rant into a full-blown New York quarterback debate. Craig unloads on LeBron, ripping the Lakers for canceling shootarounds to accommodate a 41-year-old superstar, mocking the jersey patch publicity stunt, and declaring LeBron a franchise w…

1
The Top 5 Things Craig Didn't Care About From The Wildcard Weekend 14:09

1h ago14:09

14:09

Craig gives you the 5 stories or events from this NFL Wildcard Weekend that he didn't care for. From Fur Coats, to Press conferences you aren't gonna want to miss this list as Craig and C-Mac dive into the weekends action. Also they talk about the passing of Bob Weir and his impact on American Culture…

1
Are the Texans Super Bowl Bound, Brady Pizza Rant, & Jets Draft Reality Check 25:48

39m ago25:48

25:48

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle deliver another classic, all-over-the-map Carton Show segment as Big Mac gets his flowers after glowing early reviews—and the conversation quickly turns into peak WFAN chaos. The guys dive back into Harbaugh Watch, breaking down every potential landing spot and why the Giants still feel like the best job in football…

1
Harbaugh Watch Goes Off the Rails: Giants Coaching Drama, Super Bowl Picks & the Legendary Omelet Station 27:17

2d ago27:17

27:17

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle turn a simple football discussion into a wildly entertaining Carton Show segment that only they can deliver. The guys debate which NFL team looks the most Super Bowl–ready, break down Rams, Texans, 49ers and Steelers takes, and question Ben Johnson’s shaky playoff coaching decisions. Then things escalate quickly int…

1
The Guys UNLOAD on Sirianni, Dreams Up Saleh–McDaniel Duo & Breaks Down the Ohtani Money Mystery 27:45

2d ago27:45

27:45

The guys dive deep into the NFL coaching carousel, float a bold Robert Saleh–Mike McDaniel coaching combo, and debate what Giants ownership should really be looking for as the Harbaugh rumors swirl. The show then takes a sharp turn into gambling honesty, as Craig shares raw stories from his past and offers blunt advice on responsible betting. Plus,…

1
Carton Roasts the Eagles, Loves Philly’s Pain & Goes Full Conspiracy on NFL “Chip in the Ball” 20:34

28m ago20:34

20:34

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle deliver a classic Carton Show segment filled with laughs, rants, and wild theories. Craig revels in the Eagles’ playoff exit, takes shots at Nick Sirianni’s fractured locker room, and explains why Philadelphia’s pain brings him pure joy. The guys debate Robert Saleh’s coaching reputation, revisit the Jets’ disastrou…

1
Awful Weekend for Jets Fans, Dante Moore Panic, & Harbaugh Watch 20:54

9m ago20:54

20:54

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open the show with Craig unloading on what he calls a brutal weekend for Jets fans, despite an incredible slate of playoff football. The Bills advance, the Patriots win again, and Dante Moore’s national stage performance only fuels Craig’s fear of the Jets getting it wrong—again.…

1
Alex Bregman, Bo Bichette, Cody Bellinger, Kyle Tucker, and ADP Risers After Trades 52:09

2d ago52:09

52:09

Nathan Baker discusses the signing of Alex Bregman, developments in the free agency pursuits of Cody Bellinger, Bo Bichette and Kyle Tucker,. He then follows that up with some ADP risers after recent trades, and whether they are worth their new draft value. Presented by FanDuel SUBSCRIBE, Rate and Review on Apple and Spotify! Follow us on Twitter: …

1
PPP 748 – All Chicago Cubs Starting Pitchers For 2026 32:12

1h ago32:12

32:12

PPP 748 – All Chicago Cubs Starting Pitchers For 2026 The Plus Pitch Podcast with Nick Pollack from Pitcher List, reviewing all Fantasy Baseball starting pitchers on the Boston Red Sox for 2026. Which SPs are sleepers for this season? Stay on top of everything with Nick's daily Starting Pitcher Roundup article, SP Streamer Rankings article, and wee…