Best Paranormal Chicks Podcasts (2025)

1
EP 392 - Logan Tucker and Robert Johnson 1:14:14

Play Pause

25m ago1:14:14

1:14:14

Kerri takes us through the heartbreaking case of Logan Tucker, a young boy whose disappearance and murder shook his Oklahoma community. Donna lightens things up a bit with the fascinating life (and mysterious death) of Robert Johnson, the legendary Mississippi bluesman whose music shaped rock and roll and whose story gave rise to the famous “deal w…

1
Sinister Sightings - EP335 30:31

2h ago30:31

30:31

Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at [email protected] If you want to introduce one of our Sinister Sightings, you can join The Creepinati @ www.patreon.com/th…

1
EP 391 - Ashland Tragedy and Courtney Coco 1:13:27

1h ago1:13:27

1:13:27

Donna takes us back to the 1800s with the Ashland Tragedy, a brutal crime that shocked Kentucky and left behind a legacy of fear, public outrage, and vigilante justice. Kerri tells the heartbreaking story of Courtney Coco, a young woman from Louisiana whose life was cut short at just 19 years old. Her murder went unsolved for years, leaving her fam…

1
Sinister Sightings - EP334 37:46

11d ago37:46

37:46

Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at [email protected] If you want to introduce one of our Sinister Sightings, you can join The Creepinati @ www.patreon.com/th…

1
EP 390 - Annie Le and Hvaldimir the whale 1:03:01

2d ago1:03:01

1:03:01

Kerri dives into the heartbreaking story of Annie Le, a brilliant Yale graduate student whose bright future was tragically cut short by murder. Meanwhile, Donna TRIES to lighten the mood with the unusual tale of Hvaldimir the whale—a friendly beluga who captured the world’s attention when he appeared in Norway wearing a harness, sparking theories o…

1
Sinister Sightings - EP333 46:32

6d ago46:32

46:32

Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at [email protected] If you want to introduce one of our Sinister Sightings, you can join The Creepinati @ www.patreon.com/th…

1
EP - 389 Cindy Sarro and Shanda Sharer 1:22:01

15d ago1:22:01

1:22:01

Donna takes us inside the chilling story of Cindy Sarro and the haunted house that left her questioning what was real and what wasn’t. Kerri covers the heartbreaking case of Shanda Sharer, a twelve-year-old whose life was tragically cut short in one of the most shocking crimes of the 1990s. This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. Head to www.bette…

1
Sinister Sightings - EP332 28:07

14d ago28:07

28:07

Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at [email protected] If you want to introduce one of our Sinister Sightings, you can join The Creepinati @ www.patreon.com/th…

1
EP 388 - Mitrice Richardson and Char Man 1:14:46

24d ago1:14:46

1:14:46

Kerri takes us through the heartbreaking story of Mitrice Richardson, a young woman whose disappearance in 2009 exposed serious failures by law enforcement and left her family searching for answers. Donna lightens things up with a chilling California urban legend- the Char Man of Ojai Valley. A tale of folklore, fear, and ghostly encounters. The qu…

1
Sinister Sightings - EP331 32:12

27d ago32:12

32:12

Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at [email protected] If you want to introduce one of our Sinister Sightings, you can join The Creepinati @ www.patreon.com/th…

1
EP - 387 Jemima Packington and Jasmine Harlee 1:22:49

24d ago1:22:49

1:22:49

Donna dives into the quirky world of Jemima Packington, the only known "asparamancer," who predicts the future using asparagus. Her unusual method has made headlines and sparked plenty of curiosity. Kerri covers the shocking case of Jasmine Harlee, whose troubled relationship with her mother, Julie, spiraled into a deadly act that shocked their com…

1
Sinister Sightings - EP330 37:05

28d ago37:05

37:05

Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at [email protected] If you want to introduce one of our Sinister Sightings, you can join The Creepinati @ www.patreon.com/th…

1
EP 386 - Michelle Castillo and the Foley House Inn 1:24:59

1M ago1:24:59

1:24:59

Kerri covers the heartbreaking case of Michelle Castillo, a young mother whose life was cut short in a brutal act of violence. While her death appeared to be suicide, the evidence quickly pointed to murder. Donna takes us to Savannah, Georgia, to explore the haunting history of the Foley House Inn, a charming bed-and-breakfast with a chilling past …

1
Sinister Sightings - EP329 33:57

1M ago33:57

33:57

Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at [email protected] If you want to introduce one of our Sinister Sightings, you can join The Creepinati @ www.patreon.com/th…

1
EP 385 - Hilary Porter and Philip Markoff 1:10:22

1M ago1:10:22

1:10:22

Donna dives into the bizarre and unsettling alien abduction story of Hilary Porter, a woman who claims to have been taken by extraterrestrials multiple times over her life. Kerri tells the story of the so-called Craigslist Killer, Philip Markoff, a seemingly normal med student living a double life that ended in tragedy. This episode is sponsored by…

1
Sinister Sightings - EP328 29:43

1M ago29:43

29:43

Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at [email protected] If you want to introduce one of our Sinister Sightings, you can join The Creepinati @ www.patreon.com/th…

1
EP 384 - Relisha Rudd and the Chelsea Hotel 1:24:10

2M ago1:24:10

1:24:10

Kerri covers the heartbreaking story of Relisha Rudd, an 8-year-old girl who vanished from a Washington D.C. homeless shelter in 2014. As the investigation unfolded, disturbing details about the adults in her life and the system that failed her came to light. This case remains unsolved and deeply haunting. Donna dives into the eerie history of the …

1
"Big Brother is watching. Jojo Siwa is on Big Brother. It's all connected." 1:12:00

2M ago1:12:00

1:12:00

Send us a text There's been some updates since recording the topics of this episode, but that's showbiz baby. Actually, it was an actual baby because after recording, Anna went into labor and had a whole ass human, so Anna will be in recovery for a little bit so enjoy the hiatus! In this week's episode we discuss recent updates regarding Emilie Kis…

1
Sinister Sightings - EP327 38:08

2M ago38:08

38:08

Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at [email protected] If you want to introduce one of our Sinister Sightings, you can join The Creepinati @ www.patreon.com/th…

1
EP 383 - Joan Vollmer and Lorenzen Wright 1:19:09

2M ago1:19:09

1:19:09

Donna tells us about the exorcism of Joan Vollmer. Joan had a history of mental illness and the chilling story of her death during a makeshift ritual raised questions about faith, mental health, and the line between belief and brutality. Kerri tells the story of former NBA player Lorenzen Wright, whose mysterious death in 2010 left Memphis reeling.…

1
Sinister Sightings - EP326 36:31

2M ago36:31

36:31

Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at [email protected] If you want to introduce one of our Sinister Sightings, you can join The Creepinati @ www.patreon.com/th…

1
EP 382 = Robin Bledsoe Spielbauer and Museum of Shadows 1:14:36

2M ago1:14:36

1:14:36

Kerri takes us back to Amarillo two weeks in a row to cover the story of Robin Bledsoe Spielbauer. She was found murdered on a lonely stretch of Texas road and suspicion quickly turned toward those closest to her. Police quickly learned of a love triangle that led to murder. Donna takes us to Nebraska for the Museum of Shadows. The museum claims to…

1
Sinister Sightings - EP325 39:28

2M ago39:28

39:28

Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at [email protected] If you want to introduce one of our Sinister Sightings, you can join The Creepinati @ www.patreon.com/th…

1
EP 381 - Wayside Inn and Brian Deneke 1:18:54

3M ago1:18:54

1:18:54

Donna tells us the story of Longfellow's Wayside Inn in Sudbury, Massachusetts. A historic tavern dating back to 1716, was famously immortalized by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow in his Tales of a Wayside Inn. Known as the oldest operating inn in the United States, it’s rich with colonial history, literary legacy, and ghostly legends. Kerri covers the …

1
Sinister Sightings - EP324 36:41

3M ago36:41

36:41

Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at [email protected] If you want to introduce one of our Sinister Sightings, you can join The Creepinati @ www.patreon.com/th…

1
TBD on WW3 53:42

3M ago53:42

53:42

Send us a text Did you hear that we almost went to war (again). TBD on that. We also discuss the tragic conclusion of Adrianna Smith, facelifts in Guadalajara, and the Poop Cruise (which we wouldn't survive). Social media: Instagram: @butwhatdoweknowpodcast Email: [email protected] Intro/outro music by “Scroopy Sounds"…

1
EP 380 - Colleen Stan and Pigman Road 1:16:18

3M ago1:16:18

1:16:18

Kerri covers a really tough story this week. She tells the kidnapping story of Colleen Stan. While hitchhiking to a friend's house, she was picked up by Cameron and Janice Hooker. The two had a child with them so she trusted it enough to get in the car. Little did she know it would lead to her kidnapping and torture for many years. This week, Donna…

1
Sinister Sightings - EP323 38:26

3M ago38:26

38:26

Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at [email protected] If you want to introduce one of our Sinister Sightings, you can join The Creepinati @ www.patreon.com/th…

1
EP 379 - Swamp Gas and Terry Lee King 1:12:54

3M ago1:12:54

1:12:54

Donna takes us to Michigan where bright, pulsating lights were spotted on more than one occasion. This became a national story and eventually the lights were determined to be swamp gas which thoroughly angered people as they felt they were being gas lit...see what we did there? Kerri covers the case of Terry Lee King's murder. Initially police were…

1
Sinister Sightings - EP322 44:02

3M ago44:02

44:02

Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at [email protected] If you want to introduce one of our Sinister Sightings, you can join The Creepinati @ www.patreon.com/th…

1
I don't even wanna be in a room with 5 men 1:12:28

3M ago1:12:28

1:12:28

Send us a text Oh another mid-week drop. How about that? Hello again and what another great week here in America.... ICE raids, protests, a possible election fraud. But hey, we have some influencer, adult content creator, and reality TV drama to talk about too so you're not weighed down by the existential dread of this world. Enjoy! Social media: I…

1
EP 378 - Kaylee Sawyer and Aradale Lunatic Asylum 1:25:16

3M ago1:25:16

1:25:16

Kerri covers a recommendation from the discord about Kaylee Sawyer. After coming home from a bachelorette party, Kaylee went missing leading police on a multi-state chase of her killer. Donna tells us about Aradale Lunatic Asylum. Located in Victoria, Australia, it was one of the country’s largest psychiatric hospitals. Known for its grim history a…

1
Sinister Sightings - EP321 34:51

3M ago34:51

34:51

Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at [email protected] If you want to introduce one of our Sinister Sightings, you can join The Creepinati @ www.patreon.com/th…

1
EP 377 - Cafe Lafitte in Exile AND Latisha King 58:34

3M ago58:34

58:34

Donna and Kerri both highlight Pride Month this episode. Donna tells us the story about Cafe Lafitte in Exile in New Orleans, Louisiana. Patrons of this gay bar report seeing the ghosts of Tennessee Williams and Truman Capote. Kerri covers a tough story that highlights the plight people in the LGBTQ community still experience. The murder of Latisha…

1
Sinister Sightings - EP320 36:17

4M ago36:17

36:17

Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at [email protected] If you want to introduce one of our Sinister Sightings, you can join The Creepinati @ www.patreon.com/th…

1
EP 376 - Cynthia "Cindy" Dunn and Baleroy Mansion 1:19:34

4M ago1:19:34

1:19:34

Kerri tells the story about Cynthia "Cindy" Dunn, a mother of two, who went missing. Per her husband, she went to drop off a donation and never returned. But police were a bit skeptical about his story and uncovered a heartbreaking case of domestic violence. Donna covers Baleroy Mansion, located in Philadelphia's Chestnut Hill neighborhood. It is o…

1
Sinister Sightings - EP319 33:34

4M ago33:34

33:34

Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at [email protected] If you want to introduce one of our Sinister Sightings, you can join The Creepinati @ www.patreon.com/th…

1
It's not a great time to be a woman in the United States. 1:20:50

4M ago1:20:50

1:20:50

Send us a text Apologies for the midweek drop- hope everyone had a great MDW! We weren't planning on having such a sad episode, but here we are. In today's episode, we discuss how the internet already had Joe Biden dead and reincarnated as Trisha Paytas' baby which is the only "fun" part of the episode. Then rest is... sad sad: a brief update on Ha…

1
EP 375 - Shaker's Cigar Bar and Anatoly Moskvin 1:12:12

4M ago1:12:12

1:12:12

Donna tells us about Shaker's Cigar Bar, a haunted cigar bar in Milwaukee, WI (don't ask Kerri that state abbreviation). A bar that has been many things in the past, including a brothel, has now been deemed the most haunted cigar bar in the country. Kerri covers a heartbreaking case that is a bit different that what she usually covers. Anatoly Mosk…

1
Sinister Sightings - EP318 45:24

4M ago45:24

45:24

Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at [email protected] If you want to introduce one of our Sinister Sightings, you can join The Creepinati @ www.patreon.com/th…

1
EP 374 - Amber Hagerman and Sailor's Snug Harbor 1:15:36

4M ago1:15:36

1:15:36

Kerri tells us about the heartbreaking story of Amber Hagerman, a 9 year old who vanished in broad daylight with one eyewitness. From this awful story came about the AMBER Alert system, which has saved over 1200 children. Donna covers Sailor's Snug Harbor located on Staten Island. In the 1800s, Robert Richard Randall willed his property to become a…

1
Sinister Sightings - EP317 50:10

4M ago50:10

50:10

Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at [email protected] If you want to introduce one of our Sinister Sightings, you can join The Creepinati @ www.patreon.com/th…

1
EP 373 - Elizabeth Klarer & Jeremy Bamber 1:28:42

4M ago1:28:42

1:28:42

Donna giving us another UFO story. Elizabeth Klarer claimed she saw a UFO in 1917 that lead to the ultimate "love" story. Not to give too much away but there was love, a birth, and travel to another galaxy. Kerri covers a really heartbreaking familicide of the Bamber family. This case has many twists and turns that lead Jeremy Bamber into prison. N…

1
Not very papal-y 1:03:10

4M ago1:03:10

1:03:10

Send us a text We have an American pope! U-S-A! U-S-A! *eagles screeching* In other news, we have some TikTok drama to discuss, as per usual. This time about Alice (of Alice and Fern), and pepper-and-cream-cheese Jenelle. Also, have you heard of the Fyre Fest of book conventions- A Million Lives Book Festival? On a more serious note, we talk about …

1
Sinister Sightings - EP316 33:14

5M ago33:14

33:14

Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at [email protected] If you want to introduce one of our Sinister Sightings, you can join The Creepinati @ www.patreon.com/th…

1
EP - 372 Elsie Paroubek and Anna Anderson 1:31:16

5M ago1:31:16

1:31:16

Kerri covers the story of Elsie Paroubek. In 1911, Elsie was kidnapped off the street in broad daylight. The investigation focused on the Romani camps nearby based on fears versus actual evidence. Donna tells us about Anna Anderson who, in the early 1920s, claimed to be Anastasia Tschaikovsky. People, to this day, still debate if Anna was actually …

1
Sinister Sightings - EP315 33:36

5M ago33:36

33:36

Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at [email protected] If you want to introduce one of our Sinister Sightings, you can join The Creepinati @ www.patreon.com/th…

1
Introducing: Clues with Morgan Absher & Kaelyn Moore 5:56

5M ago5:56

5:56

Hey, Creepsters! Join hosts Morgan Absher and Kaelyn Moore as they take you deep into the world of the most notorious crimes ever — where a single clue can crack a case wide open. From shocking murders to serial killers, Clues dives into all the forensic details and brilliant sleuthing of the world's most infamous cases. CLUES is a Crime House Orig…

1
EP 370 - P. T. Barnum and Jodi Huisentruit 1:18:36

5M ago1:18:36

1:18:36

Donna covers P. T. Barnum who made the "freakshow" famous while stretching the truth and even outright lying for entertainment purposes. Kerri tells the story of Jodi Huisentruit- a beautiful, smart, and talented news anchor. One day she never showed up for work mere hours after a coworker spoke with her as she was late. Unfortunately, police are s…

1
"Who grants exorcisms now? The Vice-Pope?" 55:00

5M ago55:00

55:00

Send us a text Sorry we were MIA- Anna had the plague. For two nonreligious people, this episode is very pope-heavy. Did JD Vance take out the pope? Just kidding- don't sue us. We discuss the theatrical way the new pope is selected, if Trisha Paytas' baby will now be the pope reincarnated. In non-Pope news, we discuss Bad Influence: The Dark Side o…