Best Ordinary Freaks Podcasts (2026)

1
Cancelled Cast: Freaks and Geeks 1:04:48

Play Pause

7M ago1:04:48

1:04:48

Welcome back to The Rewind Podcast! This week ⁠Keeks⁠ discusses the ups and many downs that led to the fall of the one-season, NBC, teen series with an all-star cast, Freaks & Geeks, while Jonah sits back to listen to the messy drama. Freaks and Geeks Synopsis Freaks and Geeks is a coming-of-age story set in a suburban Michigan high school during t…

1
Cancelled Cast: No Ordinary Family 48:25

9M ago48:25

48:25

The Overdue Leading Role for Julie Benz This week Jonah⁠ tells ⁠Keeks⁠ the tale of the short lived ABC superhero series No Ordinary Family, starring Michael Chiklis and pod favorite Julie Benz. Jonah discusses the special effects and what makes the story unique to the superhero genre. Something like open communication between family members and clo…

1
If Smirks Could Kill—A Dexter: Original Sin Review 1:12:08

9M ago1:12:08

1:12:08

Welcome back to The Rewind Podcast! Jonah⁠ and ⁠Keeks⁠ brave the Miami heat to find out if Dexter: Original Sin lives up to the legacy of the Dexter franchise. Keeks is a Dexterverse newcomer, and Jonah is a fan of the original series and the 2021 revival Dexter: New Blood. With eight seasons (96 episodes) of Dexter and 10 episodes of the revival, …

1
Stop Colonizing Sh!t: A Hellraiser (2022) Review 1:01:41

9M ago1:01:41

1:01:41

Welcome back to The Rewind Podcast! This week, Jonah⁠ and ⁠Keeks⁠ ask, “Why are we touching unidentified relics” while discussing the 2022 reimaging of the 1987 horror film Hellraiser. Hellraiser (2022) is the first film in an attempt to revive the long-running, cult classic kicked off by Clive Barker. Eight different directors added to the Hellrai…

1
Not Your Mama’s Interview with the Vampire 1:07:48

10M ago1:07:48

1:07:48

Welcome back to The Rewind Podcast! Jonah⁠ and ⁠Keeks⁠ travel to 1920s New Orleans to discuss the 2022 AMC series Interview with the Vampire, starring Jacob Anderson, Sam Reid, and Eric Bogosian. Trigger Warning This episode was recorded before Michelle Trachtenberg's untimely passing. Michelle was mentioned during one of the hosts' rabbit-chase co…

1
What’s Happening in the World of "Sinners": Trailer Reaction 24:14

10M ago24:14

24:14

Welcome back to The Rewind Jonah and Keeks are taking a week to regroup, but don’t worry. We’re leaving you with a trailer reaction to get you through the week. Your hosts settle in to watch the second official trailer for the Ryan Coogler film Sinners, starring Michael B. Jordan and Hailee Steinfeld. And yes, Jordan is playing his twin…sigh. Is th…

1
A Tribute to Trachtenberg 1:19:37

10M ago1:19:37

1:19:37

Welcome back to The Rewind Podcast!⁠⁠ Jonah⁠ and ⁠Keeks⁠ took a break from the regular show format to celebrate the life and career of a millennial queen, Michelle Trachtenberg. With roles like Dawn Summers (Buffy the Vampire Slayer), Harriet M. Welsch (Harriet the Spy), and Georgina Sparks (Gossip Girl) under her belt, Michelle was THAT GIRL. From…

1
Malbec & Mystery Meat: A Review of the Hannibal TV Series 1:25:16

11M ago1:25:16

1:25:16

It plays the podcast like it’s told, or it gets the hose again! That’s right, Jonah⁠ and ⁠Keeks⁠ hopped over to the FICTIONAL world of Hannibal Lecter to discuss the 2013 series Hannibal. Before they dive into Hannibal, Jonah and Keeks fanboy over Charisma Carpenter’s TikTok video where she discussed the possibility of a Buffy/Angel rewatch podcast…

1
Chilling Adventures of Sabrina: Magic is Afoot with Vaseline on the Lens 55:18

11M ago55:18

55:18

Welcome back to The Rewind Podcast!Jonah⁠ and ⁠Keeks⁠ took a trip to the Archieverse to discuss the Netflix Original series “Chilling Adventures of Sabrina.” After reacting to this week’s viral clip and revealing Google AI’s whitewashing of the history of Lake Lanier, Jonah and Keeks took some time to discuss the inconsistent reverse morality of th…

1
Not For Us 2: A Nosferatu Review 1:01:26

11M ago1:01:26

1:01:26

Jonah and Keeks got together to discuss the wild ride that was “Nosferatu” (2024). The dynamic duo recounts their out-of-control experience in the theater and Keeks’ obsession with Willem Dafoe’s accent. *SPOILER WARNING* Dafoe is the stand-out yet again. In addition to Dafoe’s scene-stealing performance, Keeks and Jonah found appreciation in the c…

1
The Power of Three with Mr. G 1:38:39

11M ago1:38:39

1:38:39

Keeks and Jonah called on the magnificent Mr. G to invoke the Power of Three to discuss Charmed (2018). Each host shares their Charmed origin story before getting into their discussion. After reacting to a viral clip (and judging Keeks), the trio of hosts get into Charmed (2018), and maybe a little compare and contrast with OG Charmed, but absolute…

1
Beetlejuice, Beetlejuice & the Origins of Moira Rose 1:05:27

12M ago1:05:27

1:05:27

Keenon & Jonah are back to discuss "Beetlejuice, Beetlejuice," the long awaited sequel to the 1988 film Beetlejuice. Micheal Keaton (Beetlejuice), Winona Ryder (Lydia Deetz), and Catherine O’Hara (Delia Deetz) return for a zany underworld adventure with Lydia Deetz's daughter Astrid, played by Jenna Ortega. *SPOILER ALERT* We had a good time. Give …

1
Cross: Too Much Fine for One Show 1:46:29

12M ago1:46:29

1:46:29

Jonah and Keeks are back, and for the first episode of the season they may or may not be thirsting over the titular character Alex Cross, played by Aldis Hodge. Listen to find out how they felt about the series. Synopsis: Based on NY Times Bestselling author James Patterson’s #1 hero, Cross is a crime thriller series that follows the investigations…

1
Exclusive Interview: X-Men ‘97 Star JP Karliak 42:39

1+ y ago42:39

42:39

Voice actor, activist, and amazing human, JP Karliak (he/him), won the hearts of many mutant-loving millennials with his portrayal of Morph on X-Men '97. He recently sat with Multiverse of Color to discuss the challenges faced by Queer and Non-binary voice actors, the threat of AI, his nonprofit organizations Queer Vox Academy and Nerds Vote, and t…

1
Scream VI and Ninja Turtle Ghost Face 2:01:46

3y ago2:01:46

2:01:46

Jonah and Keeks wrap their third season with what’s proven to be the biggest box office installment in the franchise, Scream VI. The duo brings ALL the sass and laughs as they slash their way through hella intense kill scenes, plot hole oopsies, and upsettingly small NYC apartments. Find out where this film carves its place in the hosts’ personal r…

1
LIVE: Unaired Buffy Pilot & the Forgettable Willow 58:22

3y ago58:22

58:22

Jonah and Keeks returns to their first love - the show that started it all - Buffy the Vampire Slayer. This time they’re watching the original unaired pilot live with fellow Scoobies and together they pick apart the many interesting scene and casting choices that almost made the cut. You can stream us on Anchor FM, Apple Podcasts, Castbox, Google P…

1
CancelledCast: Swamp Thing & Santa Clarita Diet 1:21:12

3y ago1:21:12

1:21:12

On this Cancelled Cast episode, Keeks dives into the long lost DC series Swamp Thing, which turns out to be hella more intense than his cohost ever realized. Meanwhile, Jonah makes a case for the beloved horror comedy Santa Clarita Diet, starring Drew Barrymore, and reveals the real reason it was tragically slashed by Netflix. You can stream us on …

1
Quantumania and the Kase for Kang 1:23:25

3y ago1:23:25

1:23:25

Jonah and Keenon blast into the Quantum Realm with a breakdown of Marvel’s Ant-Man & The Wasp: Quantumania. The hot-for-Kang hosts explain why it would take very little coaxing to abandon their morals and hop in Kang the Conqueror’s spaceship. They also discuss how Ant-Man is Marvel’s “funny” Avenger film series and why that could be its ultimate d…

1
Teen Wolf and the Little Jeep That Couldn’t 44:10

3y ago44:10

44:10

Jonah and Keeks sink their teeth into the new Teen Wolf movie. As they shred through confusing time jumps, painfully overused slow motion effects, and lingering Jeep shots - one thing is clear: not even the return of a long lost beloved character could save this movie. The clips used in this video are property of Paramount+.…

1
Wolf Pack, CGI Dogs, & the SMG Slow Burn 1:20:06

3y ago1:20:06

1:20:06

Jonah and Keeks enjoy a wild ride through a world of low budget werewolves, literal hot daddies, and Queen Mother Sarah Michelle Gellar’s return to her supernatural roots in the new series “Wolf Pack.”

1
Cancelled Cast: Heroes and The Bastard Son & the Devil Himself 1:17:21

3y ago1:17:21

1:17:21

In this special CancelledCast episode, Jonah covers the sci-fi-fantasy NBC series Heroes, with some surprising behind the scenes facts most fans probably won’t know. And Keenon presents a solid defense for why the new Netflix series “The Bastard Son & the Devil Himself” deserves another season.

1
The Winchesters and Celeb Doppelgängers 1:23:05

3y ago1:23:05

1:23:05

Jonah and Keeks venture into the Supernatural-verse with the CW’s prequel series “The Winchesters.” Together, the duo battles tech demons and the very disturbing possibility that Megan Donnelly (Mary on the show) and AnnaSophia Robb (girl from Bridge to Terabithia) are the same person.

1
Walker Independence & the Seamus Slip 1:28:54

3y ago1:28:54

1:28:54

Jonah and Keeks take a ride through the dusty and dangerous world of the Walker spin-off “Walker: Independence,” starring the duo’s favorite queer rom-com’er-turned cowboy, Philemon Chambers.

1
Wednesday & the Eugene Erasure 1:22:22

3y ago1:22:22

1:22:22

Jonah and Keeks rewind the creepy, kooky, and altogether ooky Addams Family Netflix spin-off series Wednesday, starring Hollywood’s favorite new starlet Jenna Ortega and “friend of the pod” (sort of) Christina Ricci. The hosts share their feelings about the characters - for better or worse - along with the standouts and fun facts about the show.…

1
Top 5 TV Shows of 2022 1:43:23

3y ago1:43:23

1:43:23

Jonah and Keenon continue ringing in 2023 with a list of their favorite shows of 2023.

1
Top 5 Movies of 2022 1:03:48

3y ago1:03:48

1:03:48

Jonah and Keenon are back to kick off season three with a list of their top five movies of 2022!

1
Introducing: You Are What You Love 2:01

3+ y ago2:01

2:01

You Are What You Love, a new podcast hosted by the creator of Super Ordinary, is available wherever you get your podcasts now. Each week, Marissa Tandon is joined by a new guest who answers one question: what piece of media changed who you are forever? Each guest brings a new answer, and over the course of the conversation, tries to do something we…

1
SEASON FINALE: Marvel’s Dr. Strange in the Multiverse of Madness 45:03

3+ y ago45:03

45:03

In the season 2 finale, Jonah and Keenon leap through the twisted topsy turny (and surprisingly graphic) multiverse as they cover Marvel’s Dr. Strange in the Multiverse of Madness, also known as gay queen Scarlet Witch’s big debut. Buckle up, this one’s a wild and wicked ride! Stream us on: Amazon Music, Anchor FM, Apple Podcasts, Castbox, Google P…

1
PREDICTIONS: Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness 34:50

3+ y ago34:50

34:50

Jonah and Keenon meet to discuss hopes and predictions for the newest Marvel Studios release, Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness! Stay tuned for the movie review. Stream us on: Amazon Music, Anchor FM, Apple Podcasts, Castbox, Google Podcasts, Overcast, Pocket Casts, RadioPublic, Spotify, and Stitcher. Follow us on: Facebook - The Rewind P…

1
Announcing: That Vampire Show 3:45

3+ y ago3:45

3:45

We want to introduce you to our newest audio drama, That Vampire Show. It follows Kat Wright, a high school senior who wins a fan fiction contest for her favorite TV show. But when she finally gets a chance to meet the creator of the teen hit Bloodlines, things go terribly wrong, derailing Kat's senior year and changing the future of Bloodlines for…

1
CANCELLEDCAST: Black Lightning 1:29:31

3+ y ago1:29:31

1:29:31

It’s Keenon’s turn to talk about one of his favorite shows , Black Lightning. This Black-led superhero series really elevated the landscape of comic book tv shows and explored themes of race, police brutality and addiction in a way that was organic to the show. Enjoy! Stream us on: Anchor FM, Apple Podcasts, Castbox, Google Podcasts, Overcast, Pock…

1
CANCELLEDCAST: Joan of Arcadia 51:19

3+ y ago51:19

51:19

Jonah covers the early aughts supernatural family drama series, Joan of Arcadia, (starring Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants’ Amber Tamblyn) about a teenager who has unexpected conversations with God appearing in the form of everyday people, and is given seemingly random assignments that ultimately have a positive impact on people’s lives. Stream u…

1
THROWBACK: Smallville (Pilot) 1:24:42

4y ago1:24:42

1:24:42

Jonah and Keenon revisit the series that paved the way for the CW’s slate of superhero shows, Smallville. Jonah shares trivia and behind-the-scenes facts about the show, and Keenon reveals his secret fantasy about two surprising characters. Stream us on: Anchor FM, Apple Podcasts, Breaker, Castbox, Google Podcasts, Overcast, Pocket Casts, RadioPubl…

1
REWIND: Yellowjackets 1:37:24

4y ago1:37:24

1:37:24

Jonah and Keenon review the WILDLY popular Showtime series Yellowjackets (think Lost meets Lord of the Flies). The two lay out their theories on the varying plot mysteries, favorite characters, and the impressive stats the show has raked in within its first season. Stream us on: Anchor FM, Apple Podcasts, Breaker, Castbox, Google Podcasts, Overcast…

1
REWIND: Abbott Elementary 42:59

4y ago42:59

42:59

Jonah and Keenon laugh their way through a rewind of the most hilarious and critically acclaimed shows on television at the moment, Abbott Elementary. The hosts talk about why ABC’s new mockumentary series following educators at an underfunded public elementary school thrives in its own lane, apart from predecessors like The Office and Parks and Re…

1
REWIND: Naomi (Pilot) 59:38

4y ago59:38

59:38

Jonah and Keenon explore the coming-of-age superhero story of Naomi, the CW’s newest series based on the comic book of the same name. The hosts discuss what makes the blossoming super-powered skateboarder unique, her lovable built-in Scooby gang, and her mysterious superpowers. Stream us on: Anchor FM, Apple Podcasts, Breaker, Castbox, Google Podca…

1
REWIND: Scream (2022) 1:51:51

4y ago1:51:51

1:51:51

Jonah and Keenon slash into the highly anticipated self-coined “requel” Scream (2022). The duo explain why it’s a standout Scream film that breathes new life (and death) into the franchise and reveal some shocking Easter eggs viewers may or may not have spotted. Stream us on: Anchor FM, Apple Podcasts, Breaker, Castbox, Google Podcasts, Overcast, P…

1
REWIND: Spider-Man: No Way Home 1:44:15

4y ago1:44:15

1:44:15

Jonah and Keenon review the latest installment in the Spideyverse, Spider-Man: No Way Home. The hosts break down the film’s opening rankings among viewers and why this movie about everybody’s favorite webslinger is the most emotional and nostalgic of all. Stream us on: Anchor FM, Apple Podcasts, Breaker, Castbox, Google Podcasts, Overcast, Pocket C…

1
BONUS: Listener Feedback 1:04:35

4y ago1:04:35

1:04:35

Jonah and Keenon read feedback and poll results from Single all the Way and Zoey’s Extraordinary Christmas. Tune in for more insight and love for these new, holiday classics. Stream us on: Anchor FM, Apple Podcasts, Breaker, Castbox, Google Podcasts, Overcast, Pocket Casts, RadioPublic, Spotify and Stitcher Follow us on: Facebook - The Rewind Podca…

1
REWIND: Black Widow / Hawkeye Series 1:57:00

4y ago1:57:00

1:57:00

Jonah and Keenon dive into the explosive, yet late-to-the-party Black Widow film, followed by an episode-by-episode breakdown of Marvel’s new Hawkeye series.Stream us on Anchor FM, Apple Podcasts, Breaker, Castbox, Google Podcasts, Overcast, Pocket Casts, RadioPublic, Spotify and Stitcher.Follow us.Facebook: The Rewind PodcastTwitter:@therewind_pod…

1
REWIND: Zoey's Extraordinary Christmas 1:28:29

4y ago1:28:29

1:28:29

In this special Christmas Eve episode, Jonah and Keenon are joined by guest, Fangirlish Editor-in-Chief and DC TV Podcasts Host Lizzie Lanuza Sáenz! Jonah, Keenon, and Lizzie break down – song by song – the new Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist Christmas Movie, Zoey's Extraordinary Christmas. Plus, Lizzie shares the scoop on her interview with Zoey’s C…

1
REWIND: Single All The Way 1:53:15

4y ago1:53:15

1:53:15

Jonah and Keenon return for Season 2 with a review of the Netflix holiday rom-com Single All The Way. Does the film make the cut for The Gay Agenda or does it fail to please these critical ho-ho-homosexuals. Hit play and find out.

1
CancelledCast: Zoey’s Extraordinary Playlist 58:51

4+ y ago58:51

58:51

Jonah and Keenon return from hiatus with a mission to save one of their current favorite TV shows — Zoey’s Extraordinary Playlist. With NBC acting foolish and closing the curtain on this beloved award-winning cult hit, the podcasting duo takes matters into their own hands to remind America why it loves this emotional musical rollercoaster of a show…

1
BEST FRIENDS & SLAYER BABIES 3:07:04

5y ago3:07:04

3:07:04

Buckle up for the podcast finale to end all podcast finales! On the first season finale of The Rewind, Jonah and Keenon are joined by their friends Jessica and Nikki, who are also longtime Scoobies. The duo watches the series finale of Buffy, “Chosen,” with Jess and, together, discuss how they feel about the story’s wrap-up, their favorite scenes, …

1
The Hellmouth is Percolating 1:20:09

5y ago1:20:09

1:20:09

Jonah and Keenon near the end of their rewind of Buffy the Vampire Slayer as they cover the penultimate episode of the final season, “End of Days.” The Hellmouth is bubbling and all seems grim as the Potentials get blown to smithereens, but an ancient surprise weapon (that Jonah cannot pronounce to save his life) could be the key to everything. Jon…

1
Life Was The Villain All Along 1:05:46

5y ago1:05:46

1:05:46

In this break from their usual style, Jonah and Keenon explore the ups and downs of what is arguably the most divisive and controversial season of Buffy the Vampire Slayer — Season 6. From the groundbreaking musical episode to Willow’s addiction to the dark arts to Buffy and Spike’s all-too-relatable toxic relationship, this episode covers everythi…

1
Cancelled Cast: The Secret Circle 1:00:33

5y ago1:00:33

1:00:33

Sometimes a show comes along with a pretty rad plot, a super adorable cast, and top rankings on its network — but even still that’s not enough to keep it alive. Enter, the CW’s one-season series The Secret Circle. In this episode, Jonah covers the show that’s based on the book of the same name by The Vampire Diaries author L.J. Smith, and helmed by…

1
Cancelled Cast: Charlie's Angels (2011 Reboot) 56:31

5y ago56:31

56:31

If there’s anything we’ve learned from years of television, it’s that you never send a man to do a woman’s job. Keenon takes us on a full throttle ride through the 2011 reboot series of Charlie’s Angels. Why did this show crash before it ever took off? Was it really as bad as critics say or was it simply the victim of a misplaced network and a bitt…

1
Announcing Life On Pause 4:29

5y ago4:29

4:29

Life On Pause: A Quarantine Anthology is a brand new audio drama from Tandon Productions. Following seven different households, formed at the start of an unexpected global lockdown, Life On Pause asks how we can form human connection in a world where physical touch isn't possible. Life On Pause is available wherever you get your podcasts, and at ta…

1
The Gift, The Blood, The Glory 1:27:22

5y ago1:27:22

1:27:22

The pod duo watches and discusses the once-touted series finale of Buffy The Vampire Slayer, “The Gift,” where Buffy learns the true meaning of her gift. The episode also brings up some vital questions: like what does Buffy’s fashion choices in that final fight scene represent, and is Giles actually Constantine or just a low-key psycho?…