Best Gina Nichols and Amber Paul Podcasts (2025)

1
A Family Still Fighting: The Unsolved Murder of Eric Nelams 28:34

6d ago28:34

28:34

On the morning of September 26, 2003, 32-year-old Army veteran and father Eric Nelams stepped outside his Phenix City, Alabama home to head to work—just like he did every other day. Minutes later, he was gunned down in his own carport. Despite witnesses, potential suspects, and a possible motive, Eric’s murder remains unsolved more than two decades…

1
A Family Still Fighting | The Unsolved Murder of Eric Nelams 28:34

6d ago28:34

28:34

On the morning of September 26, 2003, 32-year-old Army veteran and father Eric Nelams stepped outside his Phenix City, Alabama home to head to work—just like he did every other day. Minutes later, he was gunned down in his own carport. Despite witnesses, potential suspects, and a possible motive, Eric’s murder remains unsolved more than two decades…

1
Goats, Kangaroos, and Mowing the Rug: Hilarious 911 Calls You Won’t Believe // WTF #30 31:31

13d ago31:31

31:31

After diving into the world of creative criminal sentencing, Gina and Amber are back—this time turning their attention to the unsung heroes of chaos control: 911 dispatchers. From mistaking a goat for a kidnapped child to a man mowing shag carpet in the living room, this episode dives into some of the weirdest, funniest, and flat-out absurd emergen…

1
The Submarine Murder of Kim Wall: A Journalist’s Final Interview 36:41

20d ago36:41

36:41

In August 2017, award-winning journalist Kim Wall boarded a homemade submarine in Copenhagen to interview eccentric inventor Peter Madsen. She was never seen alive again. What began as a promising story turned into one of the most chilling and bizarre true crime cases in recent memory. In this episode, we take you through Kim’s life, the investigat…

1
Crimes and Consequences: The Weirdest Sentences Ever Handed Down // WTF #29 54:03

27d ago54:03

54:03

In today’s episode, Gina and Amber are diving deep into the wild world of creative criminal sentencing. We’re talking bread-and-water diets, lawnmower justice, court-mandated makeovers, and yes—someone actually had to knit sweaters as punishment. From animal neglect to sidewalk-stomping road rage, these stories feature judges who didn’t just throw …

1
Missing Persons, Advocacy, and Ethics in True Crime with Charlie Shunick 1:36:40

1M ago1:36:40

1:36:40

In this episode, we’re honored to share a powerful conversation with Charlie Shunick — founder of the Resource Association for Missing People, forensic consultant, professor, and passionate advocate for families of the missing. Back in October 2024, G attended the virtual Cold Case Symposium — a meaningful event that brings together families of uns…

1
When Criminals Hit Fast Food: Tales of Theft, Heists, and Unexpected Arrests / WTF # 28 49:03

1M ago49:03

49:03

In this episode, we dive into some of the most bizarre and hilarious fast food crimes, from a meth lab in a Taco Bell to a chaotic art heist at an Arby’s, and a robbery foiled by a trail of hot dogs. Join Amber and Gina as they break down these outlandish criminal acts with humor and sarcasm, uncovering what went wrong, what went way too far, and h…

1
The Murder of Cassie Jo | From The Vault 1:12:39

2M ago1:12:39

1:12:39

We're throwing it back to the very first episode we ever recorded together — and it's a case that still gives us chills. Sixteen-year-old Cassie Jo Stoddart was house-sitting for her aunt and uncle when what should’ve been a quiet night turned into an unthinkable nightmare. In this episode, we cover how two of Cassie’s classmates carried out a cold…

1
Witchcraft, Lies & Stolen Lives—Unbelievable True Crime Headlines | WTF #27 58:03

2M ago58:03

58:03

In this gripping episode of Weird True Crime, Amber and Gina uncover some of the most bizarre, shocking, and jaw-dropping true crime headlines—from hidden backyard bodies to murder-for-hire plots gone wrong. 🔎 What You'll Hear in This Episode: ✔️ The chilling case of Leigh Sabine, who kept her husband’s mummified body in her backyard for 18 years—u…

1
Crook County: Unraveling Family Secrets with Kyle Tekiela 32:09

2M ago32:09

32:09

What would you do if you discovered your father had been leading a double life—one as a respected firefighter, the other as an alleged hitman for the Chicago Outfit? That’s exactly what Kyle Tekiela faced when he learned the shocking truth about his father, Kenny "The Kid" Tekiela. In his gripping podcast, Crook County, Kyle unpacks his father’s al…

1
The UNBELIEVABLE Life of KATIE FUSCO & The MURDER of Stephen Pladl 28:35

2M ago28:35

28:35

This is the strange but true case of Katie Fusco and Stephen Pladl. Katie Fusco was like a lot of adopted kids- as she got older, her curiosity about her birth parents grew, and she eventually found them: Stephen and Alyssa Paldl. As a relationshup began building and she turned 18, she moved in with them. However, the relationship was anything but …

1
The UNBELIEVABLE Life of KATIE FUSCO & The MURDERER Stephen Pladl 28:29

2M ago28:29

28:29

This is the strange but true case of Katie Fusco and Stephen Pladl. Katie Fusco was like a lot of adopted kids- as she got older, her curiosity about her birth parents grew, and she eventually found them: Stephen and Alyssa Paldl. As a relationshup began building and she turned 18, she moved in with them. However, the relationship was anything but …

1
Florida Man Chronicles: Wild, Wacky, and Absurd Escapades of the Sunshine State’s Most Bizarre Criminals | WTF 26 41:18

3M ago41:18

41:18

In this episode of Florida Man Chronicles, we take you through some of the most bizarre, hilarious, and downright strange criminal antics that only a Florida Man could pull off! From impersonating FBI agents and trying to escape in a hamster wheel, to breaking into homes and hiding drugs in unexpected places, we cover it all. Join us as we explore …

1
UNSOLVED HOMICIDE | Featuring | Missing in Hush Town | Prologue & Chapter 1: March 25, 2004 The Last Contact...Ever 18:56

3M ago18:56

18:56

Weird True Crime welcomes Missing in Hush Town. This is the first episode from the first season of the long-form investigative podcast. Missing in Hush Town: Chapter One Jennifer Wix was just 21. Adrianna, her baby girl, was just 2. On March 25, 2004, the girls were never seen or heard from again. We started this podcast with a sliver of hope that …

1
UNSOLVED MURDER of Missy Bevers: Surveillance Footage, Suspects & Theories | Ep. 94 40:35

3M ago40:35

40:35

On April 18, 2016, Missy Bevers, a dedicated fitness instructor, was brutally murdered inside Creekside Church of Christ in Midlothian, Texas. Surveillance footage captured a mysterious figure in SWAT-style tactical gear roaming the church halls before the attack, but despite thousands of tips, the killer has never been identified. Was this a burgl…

1
TERRIFYING HUMAN EXPERIMENTS GONE TOO FAR & the DARK SIDE OF PSYCHOLOGY...and more | WTF Wednesday # 25 | 38:22

3M ago38:22

38:22

The Dark Side of Psychology: Little Albert, Stanford Prison, and Fear Conditioning Time to dive into the dark side of psychology— from Little Albert’s trauma-inducing experiment to the Stanford Prison Experiment that turned ordinary college students into sadistic guards in just six days. What happens when science goes too far? And how does classica…

1
Missing in Hush Town| Season One Now Available | Jennifer & Adrianna Wix 1:24

3M ago1:24

1:24

Missing in Hush Town // Season One Now Available // Jennifer & Adrianna Wix Binge the entire season, now! www.missinginhushtown.com Small towns talk- and we're listening. Jennifer Wix was just 21. Adrianna, her baby girl, was just 2. On March 25, 2004, the girls were never seen or heard from again. We started this podcast with a sliver of hope that…

1
MURDER and CORRUPTION and THE FIGHT FOR JUSTICE | Ellen Greenberg | Ep. 93 34:11

3M ago34:11

34:11

Originally ruled a homicide due to 20 stab wounds, including multiple to the back of her neck, Ellen Greenberg's case was later shockingly changed to suicide under pressure from law enforcement. Join us as we dive into this unnerving case of mishandled justice and how after 14 years of unanswered questions, major developments could finally lead to …

1
Confess your Sins to the CRIME SKELETON | WTF Wednesday #8 | Revisit 45:55

4M ago45:55

45:55

The late 1920s was an interesting time in the crime world, to say the least, so let us introduce you to Helene Adelaide Shelby and her crazy crime skeleton patent. Who knows whether or not it would have made anyone’s job easier? From user-submitted stories about the boys in blue, between donuts, drugs, and shoes..? there never seems to be a dull mo…

1
lovelustfridays x Weird True Crime | Unbearable Pain, Unbreakable Spirit: Judy Malinowski’s Battle for Justice | Ep. 92 35:52

4M ago35:52

35:52

In this episode, Jake and Michele are joined by Gina and Amber from the Weird True Crime podcast to discuss the tragic story of Judy Malinowski, a mother of two who was set on fire by her abuser, Michael Slager, and bravely fought for 696 days to survive—ultimately making legal history by testifying against him. The discussion delves into the devas…

1
MURDER BY ARSON |Judy Malinowski: The Woman Who Testified In Her Own Murder Trial 51:31

4M ago51:31

51:31

She survived the unimaginable to tell her own story. This is the case of Judy Malinowski. In this episode of Weird True Crime, we’re diving deep into one of the most harrowing cases of domestic violence and survival—the story of Judy Malinowski. After enduring an unspeakable attack at the hands of her ex-boyfriend, Michael Slager, Judy survived for…

1
Busted! The Wildest (and Funniest) Police Stories from Reddit | WTF Wednesday #24 29:45

4M ago29:45

29:45

🚔 Busted! Get ready for the wildest and funniest police stories straight from Reddit! From hilarious close calls to unexpected cop encounters, these real-life moments will have you laughing out loud. Hear about outrageous traffic stops, mistaken identities, and creative ways people avoided tickets—all with a comedic twist. Whether you love true cri…

1
EXCLUSIVE: Uncovering the Untold Story of Ryan Waller’s Interrogation - Part 2 45:13

5M ago45:13

45:13

In part two, we pick up with the joint trial of Richie and Larry Carver and take you through the twists, revelations, and frustrations that followed. This episode uncovers the systemic failures and courtroom drama that left the Waller family fighting for answers.What we cover in part two: The joint trial of Richie and Larry Carver and the bombshell…

1
EXCLUSIVE: Uncovering the Untold Story of Ryan Waller’s Interrogation - Part 1 34:08

5M ago34:08

34:08

In part one of this two-part series, we dive into the heartbreaking story of Ryan Waller and Heather Quan—a case that began as a Christmas tragedy in 2006 and exposed shocking failures by law enforcement. This isn’t just true crime; it’s a story of survival, resilience, and systemic injustice.What we cover in part one: Ryan and Heather’s lives lead…

1
The Unbelievable Case of Ryan Waller and Heather Quan Revisit 54:45

5M ago54:45

54:45

Interrogators are responsible for the task of determining what happened and who is at fault when a crime is committed. When the dead body of 21-year-old Heather Quan is discovered, they immediately suspect her 18-year-old injured but alive boyfriend, Ryan Waller. Join us as we go over the unbelievable details of Ryan’s interrogation and uncover the…

1
The Funniest Christmas Stories from Reddit and Beyond | WTF Wednesday #23 32:48

5M ago32:48

32:48

🎄 Welcome to Weird True Crime! 🎄 In this holiday special, Amber and Gina take a break from the creepy to dive into some of the funniest, most chaotic Christmas stories you’ll ever hear. From wholesome moments with wrapped art supplies to drunken Santa mishaps, we’ve got it all—and let’s not forget grandma’s iconic “Merry F**ing* Christmas” gift tos…

1
MURDERED | Deadly Friendship: The Shocking Case of Mahogany Jackson | Ep. 86 23:22

6M ago23:22

23:22

In this week’s episode of Weird True Crime, we dive into the tragic and infuriating case of Mahogany Jaquise Jackson—a young mother working hard to turn her life around when her dreams were violently taken from her. At just 20 years old, Mahogany was betrayed by people she thought she could trust, and her life ended in the most unimaginable way. Jo…

1
People of Walmart GONE WILD! | WTF Wednesday #22 42:43

6M ago42:43

42:43

In this hilarious and chaotic episode, we dive deep into the weird world of Walmart's unforgettable shopping experiences. From Florida Man's failed shoplifting attempts to bizarre Black Friday brawls, we’ve got some truly ridiculous stories to make you laugh (and cringe). We also explore an unforgettable Thanksgiving knife fight over a parking spot…

1
What Happened to Kristin Smart? From Disappearance to Justice 50:03

6M ago50:03

50:03

Kristin Smart’s disappearance in 1996 sparked a decades-long fight for answers. In this episode, we unpack the latest updates, including revelations from the People Magazine Investigates documentary released on November 18, 2024. We explore the groundbreaking role of Your Own Backyard, the failures of the initial investigation, and Paul Flores’s di…

1
From Comedy to Crime: The Dark History of Clowns | WTF Wednesday #21 51:55

6M ago51:55

51:55

In this episode of Weird True Crime, Gina and Amber dive into the chilling, bizarre, and fascinating world of clowns. From their ancient origins as comedic entertainers to their dark turns in real-life crimes and pop culture, clowns have both delighted and terrified audiences for centuries.Join us as we explore: The history of clowns, from ancient …

1
UNSOLVED: The Murder of Leon Laureles and the System that Failed Him 35:56

7M ago35:56

35:56

In this episode, we uncover the tragic and deeply unsettling case of Leon Laureles, a kind-hearted man from Brownwood, Texas, whose life was brutally cut short in May 1996. Leon, a Hispanic, gay man in a conservative small town, was shot execution-style and left by his burning car on a remote road. His murder shocked the community—but not enough to…

1
AITA - Funeral Edition PLUS Hilarious Obituaries | WTF Wednesday #20 1:02:19

7M ago1:02:19

1:02:19

In this special edition of WTF Wednesday, Gina and Amber dive into the world of funeral-related Am I the Asshole (AITA) Reddit threads, exploring complex family dynamics, questionable etiquette, and some truly outrageous funeral moments. From handling grief and supporting loved ones to hilarious funeral mishaps and unconventional obituaries, this e…

1
VANISHED: The Unsolved Disappearance of Bryan ”Vladek” Hasel 1:00:56

7M ago1:00:56

1:00:56

In this episode of Weird True Crime, we dive deep into the mysterious disappearance of Vladek Hasel, a young man who vanished without a trace from Orlando, Florida, in November 2021. With exclusive insights from his sister Bethany and detailed recounts of events leading up to and following his disappearance, we piece together what we know and explo…

1
The Real Story Behind The STRANGERS: Dark Facts and Sharon Tate Murder Inspiration | Wicked Wednesday #8 31:21

7M ago31:21

31:21

October might be winding down, but the spooky vibes are still alive for the final Wicked Wednesday of 2024! In this episode, Gina and Amber dive deep into the chilling plot of the 2008 horror movie The Strangers and uncover the disturbing real-life events and murders that inspired it. From eerie encounters to terrifying home invasions, we’ll break …

1
Plot Breakdown of the STRANGERS: Inside the Horror Thriller That Could Actually Happen! | Wicked Wednesday # 8 1:05:51

7M ago1:05:51

1:05:51

October might be winding down, but the spooky vibes are still alive for the final Wicked Wednesday of 2024! In this episode, Gina and Amber dive deep into the chilling plot of the 2008 horror movie The Strangers and uncover the disturbing real-life events and murders that inspired it. From eerie encounters to terrifying home invasions, we’ll break …

1
Part 2: The CONJURING! Behind the Scenes + CONJURING HISTORY! | Wicked Wednesday #7 29:04

7M ago29:04

29:04

Today we're continuing WICKED WEDNESDAY with the movie THE CONJURING! Was this one of the scariest movies of all time or what??? Website: www.weirdtruecrime.com Patreon: www.patreon.com/weirdtruecrime Instagram: www.instagram.com/weirdtruecrime TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@weirdtruecrime YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCcAPlqQ1t9nzA9B6kAKifmA …

1
Part 1: The CONJURING! Ghosts, Demons, and Real-Life TERRORS! | Wicked Wednesday #7 1:13:20

7M ago1:13:20

1:13:20

Today we're continuing WICKED WEDNESDAY with the movie THE CONJURING! Was this one of the scariest movies of all time or what??? Website: www.weirdtruecrime.com Patreon: www.patreon.com/weirdtruecrime Instagram: www.instagram.com/weirdtruecrime TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@weirdtruecrime YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCcAPlqQ1t9nzA9B6kAKifmA …

1
Part 2: The True Crime Behind the Movie SCREAM! | Danny Rolling “The Gainesville Ripper” | Wicked Wednesday #6 50:07

8M ago50:07

50:07

Today Amber and Gina are diving into the inspiration behind the movie, Scream! Kevin Williamson, the screenwriter behind the 90s cult classic, was inspired to write the script after watching a documentary about Henry David Rolling, the “Gainsville Ripper.” Henry Rolling went on a kiling spree in 1990, taking the lives of five college students over …

1
Part 1: What’s Your Favorite Scary Movie?? Let’s Talk SCREAM! | Wicked Wednesday #6 1:17:35

8M ago1:17:35

1:17:35

Sources: https://www.slashfilm.com/637496/the-origin-of-the-ghostface-mask-in-scream-is-delightfully-mundane/ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mQS-dZqERIg Part 1 Show Notes Hey little skeletons! On today’s Wicked Wednesday, we’re talking about our favorite 90s slasher flick - Scream. This scary movie is full of all of the BEST aspects of a slasher f…

1
One of the Best Horror Movies of the 80’s? Let’s Talk Poltergeist! | Part 2 | Wicked Wednesday #5 28:10

8M ago28:10

28:10

Wicked Wednesday is back in full swing with October finally gracing us. Join Gina and Amber as they talk about the 1982 film “Poltergeist.” Spooky, scary, skeletons, rotating movie sets, and tragic untimely deaths all wrapped up in the first episode of Wicked Wednesday of 2024. Website: www.weirdtruecrime.com Patreon: www.patreon.com/weirdtruecrime…

1
One of the Best Horror Movies of the 80’s? Let’s Talk Poltergeist! | Part 1 | Wicked Wednesday #5 2:01:43

8M ago2:01:43

2:01:43

Wicked Wednesday is back in full swing with October finally gracing us. Join Gina and Amber as they talk about the 1982 film “Poltergeist.” Spooky, scary, skeletons, rotating movie sets, and tragic untimely deaths all wrapped up in the first episode of Wicked Wednesday of 2024. Website: www.weirdtruecrime.com Patreon: www.patreon.com/weirdtruecrime…

1
The Return of Dumb Criminals!! | WTF Wednesday #19 35:22

8M ago35:22

35:22

MORE DUMB CRIMINALS!!! Rate, review, and subscribe we really appreciate you!! --- Website: www.weirdtruecrime.com Patreon: www.patreon.com/weirdtruecrime Instagram: www.instagram.com/weirdtruecrime TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@weirdtruecrime YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCcAPlqQ1t9nzA9B6kAKifmA Email: [email protected] Podcast Product…

1
The Heartbreaking Story of Elijah Vue - Taken Too Soon 31:00

8M ago31:00

31:00

In this episode of Weird True Crime, we delve into the heart-wrenching case of Elijah Vue, a three-year-old boy whose disappearance shook an entire community. Elijah was reported missing from his mother’s boyfriend’s apartment on February 20, 2024. What began as a frantic search for a missing child soon turned into a haunting mystery. Katrina Baur,…

1
More UNBELIEVABLE Tales From the Morgue PLUS Crazy Harvard Medical School Morgue Story! | WTF Wednesday #18 39:35

9M ago39:35

39:35

Join Gina and Amber as we talk about the Harvard Medical School morgue scandal in our first WTF Wednesday of 2024. Some laughs to be had at even More Tales from the Morgue because at the end of the day, comedy is cheaper than therapy. (We know you’ve missed us saying that.) When Heaven Meets Hell Podcast with Allyn Amerongen: https://linktr.ee/whmh…

1
The Mysterious Murder of Ted Shaughnessy 52:42

9M ago52:42

52:42

In this episode of Weird True Crime, we explore the case of Ted Shaughnessy, a respected jeweler from Austin, Texas, who was tragically murdered in his own home. Ted and his wife, Corey, were well-known in their community for their successful jewelry store, Gallerie Jewelers. Their quiet life was disrupted when Ted was killed, and Corey narrowly es…

1
Hey! Did you miss us?? -- WE’RE BACK! 0:59

9M ago0:59

0:59

We're back!!! Subscribe so you don't miss our Season 2 premier on September 11th!! Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/weird-true-crime--5679751/support.By Gina Nichols and Amber Paul

1
2023 Wrapped - Our Favorite Episodes & Moments! 56:15

1+ y ago56:15

56:15

We're so happy you found our show and our creepy corner of chaos! We had such a big year in 2023 and we're looking forward to all the amazing things we'll do next year! Look forward to a new episode next week. However, if we're not able to produce the most amazing episode for you because of the holidays, we'll see you next year! Happy Holidays! Lis…

1
Dumb Criminals - Bad Santa Edition! | WTF Wednesday #17 34:44

1+ y ago34:44

34:44

It’s everyone’s favorite dopamine hit - dumb criminals! Join us as we go over ten dumbass Santas up to some less-than-holly jolly shenanigans. Just goes to show that dumb really doesn’t discriminate. Website: www.weirdtruecrime.com Patreon: www.patreon.com/weirdtruecrime Instagram: www.instagram.com/weirdtruecrime TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@weirdtruec…

1
Texas Unsolved: The Texarkana Moonlight Murders 37:41

1+ y ago37:41

37:41

Between February and May 1946, three people were brutally attacked and five were murdered in Texarkana by a man dubbed the Phantom Killer. Texarkana straddles Texas and Arkansas and had a population of about 27,000 at the time of the murders. The murders have never been solved, though many believe to know who’s responsible for the crimes. James “Ji…

1
Am I The A**hole - Holiday Edition! | WTF Wednesday #16 43:21

1+ y ago43:21

43:21

Thanksgiving is over, but the holidays are far from over. Get ready for an episode full of a-holes, entitlement, and ridiculousness in our Holiday Edition of Am I The A**hole? Website: www.weirdtruecrime.com Patreon: www.patreon.com/weirdtruecrime Instagram: www.instagram.com/weirdtruecrime TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@weirdtruecrime YouTube: https://ww…

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Gina Nichols And Amber Paul Podcasts

Podcasts Worth a Listen