Best Fic List Podcasts (2025)

1
Ep 118: Wayward 59:11

Play Pause

7d ago59:11

59:11

The girls felt like Wayward youths themselves as they went down a very windy path to recap this limited series show in Netflix. They talk about Amanda's house ghost interfering with the viewing, Maggie's love of the Paris Hilton autobiography, and their shared appreciation of the MTV hit series: Undressed. One of them really liked this show and the…

1
Ep 117: Black Rabbit-Part 2 50:32

15d ago50:32

50:32

Recapping Part 2 of Black Rabbit The girls are back for another intense episode and it's a good thing they had started off the day with a good breakfast and some grinding their coffee beans. They take you through the back half of the limited series, Black Rabbit, and they have HOT THOUGHTS. They also chat about their favorite thing for breakfast, w…

1
Ep 116: Black Rabbit-Part 1 44:33

22d ago44:33

44:33

THEY ARE BACK! And kicking off their new glow up with part one of Black Rabbit. And OMG the only word they can use to describe this show: INTENSE. From start to finish, this limited series starring Jason Bateman and Jude Law had the on pins and needles. The plot-wild. The acting-no notes. The nostaliga for Amanda & Maggie-maybe a little too close t…

1
Ep 115: October Watch List! 10:35

1M ago10:35

10:35

It's almost time, y'all! OSF is about to have a real, live glow up and the girls are ready for it! This week, they reveal their October watch list so you can start binge watching alongside them. That's right...comfy couch season is just around the corner and they are about to dive in and binge watch some of the top shows on streaming this month. It…

1
Ep 114: New Theme Song, Who Dis? 12:56

1M ago12:56

12:56

Well it's almost time for OSF to become, well OSF. With a glow up! And more shows up (on deck) to watch. In fact, Maggie and Amanda have decided they will NEVER STOP WATCHING SHOWS because if any, they are Only Show Fans! In this quickie, the girls try out some AI-generated theme songs for their upcoming launch. Thanks, robots! They're hovering ove…

1
Ep 113: With More Love, Maggie and Amanda (Recapping Season 2 of With Love, Meghan 44:27

1M ago44:27

44:27

Meghan Markle Rachel Sussex says that you don't need to be nervous if you're prepared. It's crazy how Amanda and Maggie show up to this podcast and neither one of them are nervous and also Amanda is totally unprepared and has her microphone turned around backwards for 3/4 of the show? Meghan would never do that and that's why they have so much love…

1
Ep 112: We Love Meghan Markle Rachel Sussex (With Love, Meghan Season 1) 46:31

2M ago46:31

46:31

You thought they might be finished with OSF just because they wrapped up Suits? Hardly. They're just getting started. As they bridge the gap to their new launch coming soon, they had to stay true to their Suits Roots™ and review Meghan Markle Rachel Sussex (who knew?)'s new show. To say they have been influenced by the Dutchess is an understatmenet…

1
Ep 111: Season 9: Boxers! Briefies! Bloopers! and FAN FIC! 20:03

2M ago20:03

20:03

BONUS SUITS EPISODE-The girls run it back one last time for the weirdest episode of every season. And this time, they took a detour from prediction town and made a stop at Fan Fic Village and boy oh boy is it full of surprises. Also suprising, there were no boxers this season. Only bangers. And speaking of banging, the girls have some banging news …

1
Ep 110: SUITS SERIES FINALE: The End of an Era! 56:36

2M ago56:36

56:36

Recapping SUITS Season 9: Episode 9 & 10-The Series Finale! It feels like yesterday (21 months ago) that the girls kicked off this recap podcast of the beloved law procedural. What a wild ride it's been and these last episode were just as wild! The sing, the dance (go watch on YouTube), they via for lots of sponsorships. They even take not one but …

1
Ep 109: OSF S9E4: Will the Real Harvey Specter Please Stand Up? 1:01:38

3M ago1:01:38

1:01:38

Recapping Season 9 Epsiodes 7 & 8 These epsiodes really are all about Harvey! (and who can blame Carl the Writer...Harvey's pretty easy to write for and look at!) The girls are back at it again with a good ol' "how do you pronounce this" when route/route comes into play. They discuss the episode that Amanda's mom/Maggie's mother-in-law loves so muc…

1
Ep 109: OSF S9E3: Larger than Life 45:14

3M ago45:14

45:14

Recapping SUITS Season 9 Epsiodes 5 & 6 The girls are back together again in the same studio and they're finally able to get that clap lined up! They discuss, debate, and measure each other's heads to see who in fact has a head that is larger than life. They talk about the appropriate number of people who should have a key to your house, what meats…

1
Ep 108: OSF S9E2: Face Sneeze 59:17

3M ago59:17

59:17

Recapping SUITS Season 9 Episodes 3 & 4 The girls have to cram a lot into this episode because Carl the Writer is cramming so much into these last few episodes. As the end draws near, they discuss how much they're enjoying the softer side of Harvey and how Oprah had such a great idea to tell people not to talk about work during dinner. Thanks, Opra…

1
Ep 107: OSF S9E1: Bone Zone Songs 1:09:30

3M ago1:09:30

1:09:30

Recapping SUITS Season 9 Episodes 1 & 2 It's the beginning of the end. The first few minutes of a bittersweet symphony. It's senior year. It's all the feels as the girls venture into Season 9 of their beloved law procedural and the wild cast of characters who find their way in and out of this wonderful world. In this episode, they talk about how Ky…

1
Ep 106: OSF S8:Predictions! Briefies! Boxers! Bloopers! 18:45

4M ago18:45

18:45

SUITS BONUS EPISODE-The best episode of the season! It's time for the girls to reflect back on Season 8 as the end draws near. Maggie missed the mark on her Season 8 predictions but she's feeling great about the final season and lays it all out on the table in prediction town. The girls nominate their favorite briefs for the Briefy Award and recogn…

1
Ep 105: S8E8: The Round Table (Season Finale!) 54:24

4M ago54:24

54:24

Recapping SUITS Season 8 Episodes 15 & 16 In their next to last season finale, they talk about how this could have been an actual series finale. In fact, there was speculation from some listeners there were only 8 seasons and, after watching these last two episodes in season 8 for the first (and fifth) time, they agree that episode 16 really tied a…

1
Ep 104: S8E7: Bring Em Out 1:03:00

4M ago1:03:00

1:03:00

Recapping SUITS Season 8 Episodes 13 & 14 It's Maggie and Amanda's first official recording from different states. :( They're still working on their sound (have been since day one) but they sound like they're having the most fun. Maggie and Amanda talk about how only one of the loves talking on the phone and the other avoids it all costs. They both…

1
Author's Notes: It's None of Our Business with D'Manda Martini 1:18:49

4M ago1:18:49

1:18:49

Welcome back to the Fic List Presents: Author’s Notes, an interview series where I chat with creative-type people about their experiences in and relationships to fandom and fan culture.Pride month may officially be over, but it’s Pride in our lives every day! As such, please welcome to the Author’s Notes podcast-stage, the Chanteuse of Southern Mar…

1
Chapter 41 - What A F*cking Segue [Omegaverse] 1:40:34

4M ago1:40:34

1:40:34

IT’S PRIDE Y’ALLWell, technically, it’s just after Pride month, but it’s never *not* Pride here at The Fic List Headquarters. And what else could we possibly choose for our grand return to the podcast but Omegaverse fic??? After all the panels we’ve done on the topic, it’s a shock even to us that we’ve never discussed it here before! So, here we ar…

1
Ep 103: S8E6: A Very Erie Episode 57:34

4M ago57:34

57:34

Recapping Season 8 Epsiodes 11 & 12 If three's a crowd, then you're going to love this crowded episode- jam packed with sidebars, dumb jokes, elbows rubbing on the table causing weird ASMR, and a general sense of echo b/c they recorded in a huge house with zero furniture. Since the girls made it to Erie in record time, Kyle (Maggie's husband/Amanda…

1
Ep 102: OSF S8E5: Steam Heat 55:04

4M ago55:04

55:04

Recappng Suits Seasom 8 Episodes 9 & 10 Well this episode is hot with everything but a Suits recap. Not really, but kind, really. The girls find themselves recording at the latest start time in OSF historyl..12:01a to be exact! And it's also the last time they'll record together in the OSF podcast studio together. Maggie and Kye (her husband/Amanda…

1
Ep 101: OSF S8E2: Cart of Blanches 38:36

5M ago38:36

38:36

Recapping Suits Season 8 Epsiodes 3 & 4 Amanda and Maggie are two silly ladies who have made plenty of silly mistakes. Amanda wins the mistake trophy for this season because she just completely skipped over an epsiodes and didn't edit or release it in time! HUGE shout out to listener (maybe their BFF?) Georgia for writing in to let them know she co…

1
Ep 100: S8E4: Good News Bruise 50:16

5M ago50:16

50:16

Recapping SUITS Season 8 Episodes 7 & 8 Paging Dr. Hips and Dr. Lips! Amanda and Maggie have decided on their new doctor names as they analyze two more episodes of this beloved law procedural! They talk about how fun it was a kid to sneak downstairs and watch TV or just sit a the bottom of the stairs and spy on your parents. They decide who would b…

1
S8E3: Secrets, Secrets Are No Fun!? 57:31

5M ago57:31

57:31

Recaping Season 8 Epsiodes 5 & 6 Lots of catching up to do in this episode. First and foremost, after a deep dive on the arcade game BURGERTIME, Amanda has offered to fly to any city in North America for the first person to leave a review about their delicious burger options in their city! The girls debate on whether or not Secrets! Secrets! are/ar…

1
SUITS LA S1E13: Sunset on Suits LA 44:22

5M ago44:22

44:22

It's true that all good things must come to an end. And Suits LA ended up being better than good, it was great. If you're going to one and done a series, this was the way to do it. Bring back all the brunettes and confuse us one last time. Show us what really happened with Ted's dad and his brother Eddy. Leave us hanging with a hot hook up from the…

1
Author's Notes: The Fangirl to Media Employee Pipeline with Cailyn Hoertz 1:10:32

6M ago1:10:32

1:10:32

Welcome back to the Fic List Presents: Author’s Notes, an interview series where I chat with creative-type people about their experiences in and relationships to fandom and fan culture.In today’s episode, I am beyond thrilled to welcome Social Media Department Lead at Try Guys (2nd Try LLC), social strategist, content creator, professional fangirl,…

1
S8E1: Heavy is the Crown 49:27

6M ago49:27

49:27

Recapping Season 8 Episodes 1 & 2 The girls kick off Season 8 and it's hard to believe there's only two more seasons left of this life-changing show. They talk about the good, bad, and ugly of firing people at work. Amanda reveals her celebrity doppelganger, according to the internet of course. They discuss the etiquette of snooping in medicine cab…

1
SUITS LA S1E12: We Miss Amanda 42:29

6M ago42:29

42:29

While Amanda is away, Kyle will also be away, but the show must go on! Coming off this week's announcement that Suits LA has NOT been renewed for next year makes this a bittersweet brief to write. Perhaps if Louis had shown up earlier in the series, we wouldn't be facing such sorrow. Or maybe if the show spent more time thinking about the future an…

1
SUITS LA S1E11: NSync With This Episode 37:34

6M ago37:34

37:34

Recapping Suits LA Season 1 Episode 11: Tearin' Up My Heart Just like the karaoke sung in this episode, it can be hard to tell what's singing, what's talking, and what's a podcast. Luckily, Maggie is joined by Amanda's brother/Maggie's husband this week to make sense of a doozy of a filler episode. There's Patton Oswald! There's Brian Baumgartner! …

1
S7: Predictions! Briefies! Boxers! Bloopers! 21:47

6M ago21:47

21:47

Once again, it's the girls' favorit episode of the season. Maggie reviews her predictions from season 7 to see how they matched up what what REALLY happened and she makes another round of ground-breaking predictions for Season 8. They each have a nomination for the Briefy Award and they consolidate their nomination for the boxer because who really …

1
Suits LA: S1E10: NOT a Season Finale! 45:02

6M ago45:02

45:02

Recapping Suits LA S1E10 This episode is a cautionary tale about what happens when two sisters-in-law believe everything they read on the internet. What they thought was going to be the Season Finale of Suits LA Season 1 was, in fact, just episode 10. Still a great episode, just not the final episode of the season. And that means they get THREE MOR…

1
SUITS LA S1E9: Sweatpants ARE for Winners 38:18

6M ago38:18

38:18

Recapping SUITS LA S1E9 If there's one thing everyone can all agree on it's that Harvey Specter is a real sight for sore eyes and their eyes are a little less sore now that Harvey keeps making an appearance. The one thing they can disagree on is that, despite Harvey being truly perfect, he's wrong about one thing: winners DO, IN FACT, greet the day…

1
The Pearson Bait and Switch 46:54

7M ago46:54

46:54

It's the season finale and they have some HOT TAKES! Maggie is so kind to offer to make Amanda some homemade ricotta cheese so she can truly enoy it and Amanda declines. Maggie talks about the time she and her bff Sarah were agressively greeted in Chicago and told their leisurely pace wasn't good enough. Maggie reflects on how flawless Real Housewi…

1
Author's Notes: Yappin' About Art with Jon Jon Johnson 1:35:37

7M ago1:35:37

1:35:37

Welcome back to the Fic List Presents: Author’s Notes, an interview series where I chat with creative-type people about their experiences in and relationships to fandom and fan culture. In today’s episode, I am delighted to welcome Anti-Racism and Anti-Oppression Specialist, Talent Acquisition Manager, Director, Dramaturg, Playwright, and occasiona…

1
SUITS LA S1E8: Paging Dr. Whit! 50:55

7M ago50:55

50:55

Recapping Suits LA S1E8 Well well well. We finally have Dr. Whit in the house. The girls' friend Whitney, of previous OSF podcast fame, is finally joining today while Maggie is out of town with Kyle (Maggie's husband/Amanda's brother). Not ony does Dr. Whit make her podcast debut, but she crushes with with hot takes all while keeping it cool. Of co…

1
S7E7: A Pitch Perfect Episode 46:28

7M ago46:28

46:28

Recapping Season 7 Episodes 13 & 14 Well they are almost to the end of Season 7 and they have A LOT to dish about. BUT FIRST, WTF is up with Amanda's sneeze? Is that real life? Or is that just a horse hanging out in the podcast studio. You decide! The girls disuss what celebrity couples were meant to be together and ones whose break ups still live …

1
Suits LA S1E7: A Simile-Minded Man 48:25

7M ago48:25

48:25

Catgate 2025 has taken over the podcat studio but the girls and Whisky the Producer Dog™ somehow managed to make it through episode 7 and the live recording! They finally feel like Suits LA is the true franchise it was meant to be. They discuss whether or not they would name a pastry, or any food for that matter. They try to get to the bottom of Ro…

1
S7E6: Highway to the Danger Zone 46:21

7M ago46:21

46:21

Recapping Season 7 Episodes 11 & 12 They're getting closer and closer to the end of another season. Time sure does fly when you're having fun! Amanda has to improvise a brief on her lunch break because such is life. They both talk about their worst spoiled and spilled milk stories. The ACA Center for Performing Arts and the MRA Art Museum are absol…

1
SUITS LA S1E6: Hot to Trot 40:00

7M ago40:00

40:00

Well if it isn't ol' Bugs and Nana, recapping epsiode 6 of Suits LA! The girls are back and new nicknames for their present law firm. The make a pact that they will alwasy tell each other if they know someone murdered someone they are representing at their pretend law firm. They have real hot takes on the Oxford comma. Don't get Amanda worked about…

1
S7E5: Oh, Donna! 55:25

7M ago55:25

55:25

Recapping Season 7 Epsiodes 9 & 10 They debate the best kind of cereal but they agree that cereal guestimation is the only way to go. Amanda is having a hard time with general words in this epiosde but she is not shy about singing. Maggie gets to talk about the impact she made at Model UN as a teenager while Amanda just did dance and theater as a k…

1
SUITS LA S1E5: Cheeky Little Episode 53:52

7M ago53:52

53:52

Recapping SUITS LA: Season 1 Epsiode 5 Well the girls are finally understanding what the heck is going on in LaLa Land. There's been so many things happening in each episode and now they finally feel like they're settling in and really understanding the people, and more importantly, the LAW! They talked about the best kind of deli meat and how hot …

1
S7E4: Squatty Long Dick 54:42

8M ago54:42

54:42

Recapping Season 7 Episodes 7 & 8 If this show title doesn't want to make you listen HARD to this epsiode, then it might be a lost cause. Amanda and Maggie break down what weird skill sets they have where they could slide rigth in as consultants b/c they're so dang clever. They both agree Gretchen is crushing it right now and they are here for it! …

1
SUITS LA S1E3: Penis Bush 55:28

8M ago55:28

55:28

Amanda and Maggie are so thrilled that Harvey is back! And he's looking better than ever, even though it's been 15 years. They talk about some new game that seems to be gaining traction called Dungeons and Dungeons. And who cares if Suits LA doesn't have a high rating on rotten tomatoes? We all know what kind of things you can make from some rotten…

1
The Fic List Presents: Author's Notes: A Conversation with Daniel Thrasher 1:08:40

8M ago1:08:40

1:08:40

Welcome to the first ever episode of The Fic List Presents: Author’s Notes, an interview series where I chat with creative-type people about their experiences in and relationships to fandom and fan culture.My name is Erin, and you might know me as one cohost of The Fic List podcast (or as that girl you see on Tiktok sometimes when your FYP sends yo…

1
S7E3: Steak 'n' Shake 'n' Bake 53:19

8M ago53:19

53:19

Recapping Season 7 Episodes 5 & 6 The girls talk about how the will eat carmelized onions and mushrooms straight out of a pan while also discussisng their surprise breakfasts. They debate which version of The Parent Trap is better and we all know which one it is. Maggie did a deep dive on the lyrics to Greenback Boogie and now she's obsessed with b…

1
SUITS LA: S1E3: Too Much Context 49:24

8M ago49:24

49:24

Recapping Suits LA Season 1, Episode 3 Amanda and Maggie are really starting to love SUITS LA. Amanda talks about how confident she is in what she can accomplish in the minutes leading up to a virtual meeting or podcast. Maggie talks about how she gets typecast with all things teeth. Amanda talks about how she talks on the phone every night. And th…

1
S7E2: Bench Seats and Early Eats 55:39

8M ago55:39

55:39

Recapping Season 7 Epsiodes 3 & 4 Well the the beaver was right and has predicted some crazy weather for Amanda and Maggie in the month of February but they're finally on the other side of it. Both of them reminisce about their grandparents' cars and how they totally chilled on those bench seats. Speaking of grandparents, the both LOVE an early din…

1
SUITS LA: S1E2: Suits LA is our Oscars's Red Carpet 1:11:25

8M ago1:11:25

1:11:25

Recapping SUITS LA Season 1, Episode 2 Week 2 and it's already feeling like a real Suits Franchise! The girls are thrilled to hear their favorite song, Greenback Boogie, as the official theme song. They talk about how Dylan, Elizabeth, and Samantha could all be the same person-and maybe she is. Amanda wondered for a split second if Erica's characte…

1
S7 E1: The Return of the Can Opener 53:31

8M ago53:31

53:31

Recapping Season 7 Epsiodes 1 & 2... What a way to kick off Season 7 with so many plot twists! In this epsiode, we learn Maggie isn't a fan of having skin in the game. Amanda was super excited to hear the name Axelrod in this episode and had no idea Maggie had her OWN Axelrod story! They both decide what foods would be impossible to compete against…

1
SUITS LA: S1E1: Characters Welcome! 56:28

8M ago56:28

56:28

Characters Welcome here at Suits LA because there are SO.MANY.CHARACTERS. and Amanda and Maggie are here for it! Amanda calls BS on Fantasy Football being completed in 15 minutes and she is concerned the show is being blasphamous to the name (and character) Stu. They hear some great advise for difficult conversations. Amanda thinks Ted Black is alm…

1
S6 Bonus Episode: Predictions, Briefies, Boxers, and Bloopers! 21:39

9M ago21:39

21:39

It's Amanda and Maggie's favorite episode! Oh, who are we kidding? EVERY EPISODE IS THEIR FAVORITE EPSIODE! But this one holds a special place in their hearts because they get to relive the last season, take a big ol' ride down to prediction town for the next season, and let the listeners have a peak behind the scenes to the chaos that doesn't make…