Best Cheyenne Taylor Podcasts (2026)

1
Episode 104: Ronda Reynolds | A Death Rushed to Judgment 1:16:44

Play Pause

4d ago1:16:44

1:16:44

A decorated state trooper, a marriage unraveling behind closed doors, and a death that authorities rushed to label as suicide. But years later, a civil inquest would hear the evidence that was ignored—and reach a very different conclusion. This is the case of Ronda Reynolds, and the investigation that never really happened. Trigger Warnings: Domest…

1
True Crime: The Trial of Brian Walshe 33:29

18d ago33:29

33:29

Send us a text This week Katie covers the disappearance of Ana Walshe and the trial of her husband Brian Walshe. Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a haunted lighthouse)? Check out https://www.buymeacoffee.com/waitforread Have stories to tell? Email them to us at [email protected] Katie & Grace

1
Episode 103: Julian Buchwald & Carolynne Watson | Satanic Cults & Kidnappings 57:45

25d ago57:45

57:45

A quiet afternoon in the woods turns into something no one saw coming. What began as a simple plan spirals into a mystery filled with fear, faith, and unanswered questions. Nothing in this story is as simple as it first appears. Trigger Warnings: Mentions of Murder Satanic Cults Human Sacrifices Kidnappings Deadly Faith PATREON: https://patreon.com…

1
Episode 102: Michael Taylor | 54:16

28d ago54:16

54:16

Tonight, we’re exploring the disturbing case of Michael Taylor — an ordinary man whose life unraveled after a bizarre exorcism. What followed was a night of unthinkable violence that left even investigators shaken. Trigger Warnings: Mutilation/Torture Murder Animal abuse Attempted Suicide Deadly Faith PATREON: https://patreon.com/DeadlyFaithPodcast…

1
True Crime: The Lawson Family Murders and The Ashland Tragedy 32:44

1M ago32:44

32:44

Send us a text This week, Grace covers two horrific crimes that happened during christmas. - On December 25, 1929 Charles Lawson brutally murdered his wife and six of his seven children - leaving family and neighbors shocked. - On December 23, 1881 three teenagers are killed, leading to the arrest of three men, the case is used as an example of mob…

1
Paranormal: Canadian Urban Legends 44:47

1M ago44:47

44:47

Send us a text Happy (American) Thanksgiving! This week Katie tells Grace about two Canadian Urban Legend: The Disappearance of the Lake Angikuni Village and Coughlans Coffin. Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a lighthouse)? Check out https://ww…

1
Poddy Podcast | Our Thoughts on Witchcraft 34:33

1M ago34:33

34:33

Welcome to the Poddy Podcast — where Laci and Lola shoot the shit and wander through all of life’s weird little whims. This week, they’re diving into their thoughts on witchcraft. Want more unfiltered Poddy chaos? Join the Deadly Faith Patreon! Deadly Faith PATREON: https://patreon.com/DeadlyFaithPodcast?utm_medium=unknown&utm_source=join_link&utm_…

1
Paranormal: Charleston Ghost Stories 44:32

2M ago44:32

44:32

Send us a text During Grace's belated birthday episode, she tells us what she learned on her recent Charleston ghost tour. Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a lighthouse)? Check out https://www.buymeacoffee.com/waitforread Have stories to tell? …

1
The Devil Made Me Do It: The Case of Arne Cheyenne Johnson 28:35

2M ago28:35

28:35

Send us a text This week Katie covers the case being The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It based on a true case in which Arne Johnson accused (and eventually convicted) tried to plead not guilt by reason of Demonic Possession, it was the first but not the last case of its kind. Happy Birthday Grace!! Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://yout…

1
Episode 101: Jonestown Part 2 | When Faith Turns Fatal 1:42:38

2M ago1:42:38

1:42:38

When a U.S. congressman boards a plane to investigate a remote religious settlement, he expects a diplomatic visit — not a reckoning. What begins as a routine inquiry quickly unravels into something far darker, fueled by secrecy, devotion, and fear. In this episode, the line between faith and control begins to blur… and the world starts to take not…

1
Episode 100: Jonestown Part 1 | The Making of a Messiah 1:13:35

2M ago1:13:35

1:13:35

Before the world knew his name, Jim Jones was just a small-town preacher with a big vision. He spoke about justice, equality, and love when few others dared to — drawing in crowds who saw him as a voice for the forgotten. But behind the sermons and the smiles was a man driven by something more than faith. In Part One, we explore the rise of Jim Jon…

1
True Crime: Randy Greenwalt and the Tison Gang 32:26

2M ago32:26

32:26

Send us a text Send us a text After his escape from prison, Randy Greenwalt went on a killing spree with the Tison Gang. Grace covers Randy's crimes resulting in his first conviction and the crimes after his escape. Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee…

1
Halloween Spooky Special: Ghost Stories & Grace's Jump Scare 56:52

2M ago56:52

56:52

Send us a text Happy Halloween to all our amazing listeners! We wanted to give you an extra bonus episode for this Halloween and we decided to keep it spooky with some ghost stories. Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a lighthouse)? Check out htt…

1
October Special: Murder of Chelsea Bruck 47:12

2M ago47:12

47:12

Send us a text What should have been a fun Halloween party with friends quickly turned deadly for Chelsea Bruck. Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a lighthouse)? Check out https://www.buymeacoffee.com/waitforread Have stories to tell? Email them…

1
Episode 99: Arne Cheyenne Johnson | The Devil Made Me Do It Trial 1:31:27

2M ago1:31:27

1:31:27

In 1981, a small Connecticut town became the epicenter of one of the most chilling legal battles in American history. When Arne Cheyenne Johnson brutally murdered his landlord, he claimed something no U.S. courtroom had ever heard before—the Devil made him do it. Trigger Warnings: Murder Demon Possession Exorcism Religious Trauma Alcohol Abuse Dead…

1
October Special: The Murder of Taylor Van Diest & The Louvre 52:14

3M ago52:14

52:14

Send us a text Grace covers a tragic murder of Taylor Van Diest on Halloween night in 2011. Katie gives us the lowdown on the ongoing Louvre museum heist. Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a lighthouse)? Check out https://www.buymeacoffee.com/wa…

1
Episode 98: Charity Miranda-Martin | Mother, Sister & the Exorcism Gone Wrong 1:00:05

3M ago1:00:05

1:00:05

Charity Miranda Martin’s family claimed they were fighting a demon — but by the time the struggle ended, someone was dead. What was meant to save her soul turned into a night of terror that even seasoned investigators struggled to understand. Was it faith, fear, or something far darker that took Charity’s life? dg Trigger Warnings: Murder Exorcism …

1
October Special: Triple Feature Murders 33:12

3M ago33:12

33:12

Send us a text Katie ends up covering three different murders that took place on or around Halloween. Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a lighthouse)? Check out https://www.buymeacoffee.com/waitforread Have stories to tell? Email them to us at w…

1
Episode 97: Vilma Trujillo | Fire, Faith, and Femicide 57:56

3M ago57:56

57:56

Deep in the isolated jungles of Nicaragua, a young mother’s desperate plea for help turned into a nightmare of fire and fanaticism. What began as a search for healing ended with Vilma Trujillo bound to a tree as flames devoured the night. This is a story of blind faith, fear, and a community pushed past the edge of reason. Trigger Warnings: Violent…

1
October Special: When the Haunted House Screams are Real 37:13

3M ago37:13

37:13

Send us a text Grace covers our first October episode for this season and talks about horror stories from haunted attractions. Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a lighthouse)? Check out https://www.buymeacoffee.com/waitforread Have stories to te…

1
Episode 96: Joan & Ralph Vollmer | Bound by Faith, Lost to Madness 1:29:38

3M ago1:29:38

1:29:38

By Lola Robbins, Laci Bean

1
Unsolved Mysteries: The Springfield Three 38:41

4M ago38:41

38:41

Send us a text The Springfield Three refers to an unsolved missing persons case that began on June 7, 1992, when friends Suzie Streeter and Stacy McCall, and Streeter's mother, Sherrill Levitt, went missing. Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a l…

1
Episode 95: The Lamb Funeral Home | A Mortician or A Monster 1:43:08

4M ago1:43:08

1:43:08

Today we’re heading to California to talk about a case that shook a quiet community. It started with grieving families and a trusted funeral home — but ended with headlines no one saw coming. Grab your coffee, because this story will leave you questioning who you can trust when saying goodbye. Trigger Warnings Desecration of a Body Possible Murder …

1
True Crime: Capital Punishment in Japan 39:33

4M ago39:33

39:33

Send us a text Grace covers a few death row cases that took place in Japan and breaks down the history behind the practice of capital punishment. Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a lighthouse)? Check out https://www.buymeacoffee.com/waitforread…

1
Unsolved Mysteries: The Keddie Murders 36:18

4M ago36:18

36:18

Send us a text What should have been a quiet night at home with the kids quickly turned deadly. This is the story of the Keddie Cabin Murders. Skip the banter? Go to ~6:00. Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a lighthouse)? Check out https://www.b…

1
Episode 94: Rodney Alcala | “The Dating Game Killer” 1:34:08

4M ago1:34:08

1:34:08

He was charming, intelligent, and even won a spot on a popular TV dating show. But behind the smile, Rodney Alcala was hiding a dark secret. Join us as we delve into the chilling story of the man who became known as "The Dating Game Killer." Trigger Warnings: Murder Torture Rape Deadly Faith PATREON: https://patreon.com/DeadlyFaithPodcast?utm_medi…

1
Unsolved Mysteries: Dorothy Jane Scott 38:13

4M ago38:13

38:13

Send us a text Dorothy Jane Scott was last seen on May 28th, 1980 in Anaheim, CA. While this case remains unsolved, many believe the killer was the man who stalked her and her family for years. Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a lighthouse)? Ch…

1
Paranormal: Scary Stories Round 100ish 41:23

5M ago41:23

41:23

Send us a text This week is another round of scary stories with a theme! These stories come from security guards who easily have the scariest night jobs. Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a lighthouse)? Check out https://www.buymeacoffee.com/wai…

1
Episode 93: Tony Jones & The New Evangelicals | Abuse, Denial, and Accountability in Progressive Faith Spaces 2:32:03

5M ago2:32:03

2:32:03

In this episode, we dive into the controversy surrounding Tony Jones, the Emergent Church, and The New Evangelicals. From past allegations of abuse and manipulation to the recent GRACE investigation into Tim Whitaker and TNE, we examine how power, silence, and image protection can cause deep harm—even in progressive faith spaces. This is a story of…

1
Paranormal: The Bunny Man, The Wood Booger & Haunted Hospitals 39:06

5M ago39:06

39:06

Send us a text Grace traveled to Washington, D.C. last week and came back with quite a few paranormal stories to tell us. Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a lighthouse)? Check out https://www.buymeacoffee.com/waitforread Have stories to tell? E…

1
True Crime: The Mona Lisa 29:25

5M ago29:25

29:25

Send us a text Katie is an avid lover of art and takes this week to detail the history behind the Mona Lisa. Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a lighthouse)? Check out https://www.buymeacoffee.com/waitforread Have stories to tell? Email them to …

1
Episode 92: Jon & Shamika Hayes | When Parenting Crosses the Line 49:03

5M ago49:03

49:03

When Jon and Shamika Hayes claimed they were “teaching” their teenage daughter about sex, the reality was far more disturbing. What unfolded was a horrifying case of parental betrayal, abuse, and manipulation disguised as education. ** Trigger Warning ** Sexual Assault Rape Deadly Faith PATREON: https://patreon.com/DeadlyFaithPodcast?utm_medium=unk…

1
Paranormal: The Whistling 37:15

5M ago37:15

37:15

Send us a text Taking a break from true crime this week to cover one of Grace's favorite /nosleep stories, Something walks whistling past my house every night at 3:03 Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a lighthouse)? Check out https://www.buymeac…

1
Unsolved Mysteries: Natalie Wood 45:31

5M ago45:31

45:31

Send us a text Known for her roles in Miracle on 34th Street, Rebel Without a Cause, and West Side Story, Natalie Wood was an American actress that was loved by many. Her death may be ruled as accidental, but some theories suggest otherwise. Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want…

1
Episode 91: The Holy Rollers Cult | When Faith Turns Fatal 1:22:28

6M ago1:22:28

1:22:28

They claimed to be led by divine visions, but their version of holiness was anything but sacred. What started as a spiritual revival quickly spiraled into something much darker. In this episode, we uncover the twisted truth behind the group known as the Holy Rollers. Trigger Warnings: Cults Spiritual Abuse Sexual Abuse Animal Abuse Murder (Not Grap…

1
Unsolved Mysteries: Terrance Williams and Felipe Santos 45:12

6M ago45:12

45:12

Send us a text This is the story of Terrance Williams and Felipe Santos, two men who vanished in Naples, Florida, after separate encounters with the same sheriff’s deputy. If you have any information about the disappearances of Terrance Williams or Felipe Santos, you can call the Collier County Sheriff’s Office at (239) 252-9300 or Crime Stoppers a…

1
Paranormal: Dorm Room Ghost Stories 49:44

6M ago49:44

49:44

Send us a text Taking a break from unsolved mysteries this week to have a good laugh and scare telling ghost stories that took place in dorm rooms. Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a lighthouse)? Check out https://www.buymeacoffee.com/waitforre…

1
Episode 90: Elizabeth Thomas | The Teacher She Thought She Could Trust 1:15:37

6M ago1:15:37

1:15:37

15 year old Elizabeth was looking for a friend, someone to trust during a difficult part of high school. When she found that trust and friendship in a school teacher, she felt seen and heard. However, Elizabeth was unprepared for the horrifying, secret plans her teacher had for her. In the midst of her teacher’s plotting, an unlikely hero would hel…

1
Unsolved Mysteries: The Triangles 44:27

6M ago44:27

44:27

Send us a text You have probably heard of the Bermuda Triangle, right? But did you know there are several other 'triangles' out there? Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a lighthouse)? Check out https://www.buymeacoffee.com/waitforread Have stori…

1
Unsolved Mysteries: The Gardner Museum Theft 37:00

6M ago37:00

37:00

Send us a text Katie tells us about an infamous museum heist that still remains unsolved to this day. Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a lighthouse)? Check out https://www.buymeacoffee.com/waitforread Have stories to tell? Email them to us at w…

1
Episode 89: Matthew Lee Richards | A Father’s Faith, A Family Betrayed 1:21:34

6M ago1:21:34

1:21:34

He was a youth pastor, a devoted father, and a trusted member of his church. From the outside, Matthew Lee Richards seemed like the kind of man any family would be lucky to have. But behind the Bible verses and Sunday smiles… something much darker was festering. One quiet evening, that darkness erupted — and his family paid the price. This is the s…

1
Unsolved Mystery: What Happened to DB Cooper 38:17

7M ago38:17

38:17

Send us a text While you may have heard of the infamous DB Cooper, you haven't heard our take on it yet! Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a lighthouse)? Check out https://www.buymeacoffee.com/waitforread Have stories to tell? Email them to us a…

1
True Crime: Paula Jean Welden 37:46

7M ago37:46

37:46

Send us a text For this week's unsolved mystery, Katie tells us about the odd disappearance of Paula Jean Welden. Watch this episode on YouTube! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a lighthouse)? Check out https://www.buymeacoffee.com/waitforread Have stories to tell? Email them to…

1
Episode 88: Tim Ballard and O.U.R. | Unmasking the Man Behind the Mission 1:07:40

7M ago1:07:40

1:07:40

A man on a mission for something greater- saving people from human trafficking. A noble mission turned perverse when allegations of abuse and coercion begin to surface. Tim’s true colors and hidden secrets couldn’t hide behind religion forever. Listen in as we decipher the truth behind O.U.R. Trigger Warnings: Alleged Sexual Assault Sound of Freedo…

1
True Crime: Cindy James 43:10

7M ago43:10

43:10

Send us a text Grace takes over this week and covers a tragic case out of Canada back in the 1980s. This is the story of Cindy James. Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a lighthouse)? Check out https://www.buymeacoffee.com/waitforread Have storie…

1
True Crime: Sigrid Stevenson 30:54

7M ago30:54

30:54

Send us a text Katie kicks off the next theme for our podcast, Unsolved Mysteries. This week's episode is quite gruesome and leaves you wanting to do some research of your own. Who murdered Sigrid Stevenson? If you have information about this case, contact the Mercer County Homicide task force at (609) 989-6406. Watch this episode on YouTube too! h…

1
Episode 87: Jonelle Matthews | A Christmas Disappearance 1:30:02

7M ago1:30:02

1:30:02

It was a cold December night in 1984 when 12-year-old Jonelle Matthews disappeared from her home after a Christmas concert—leaving behind a house with no signs of struggle and a community full of questions. For decades, her case remained a haunting mystery. But recent revelations have finally started to uncover the truth... and it’s more twisted th…

1
Conspiracy: What is Really Happening at Mattress Firm? 38:26

8M ago38:26

38:26

Send us a text Grace decided to take a break from true crime this week and delve into a conspiracy theory that has always been amusing to her. The theory? Mattress Firm is a money-laundering front. Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a lighthouse)…

1
Paranormal: Haunted Paintings 33:24

8M ago33:24

33:24

Send us a text Katie loves to scare Grace and this episode does the trick! Katie tells us about some haunted paintings and even video footage of the hauntings. Watch this episode on YouTube too! https://youtube.com/@waitforrealtruecrimepodcast?si=UfOh-oBfyEoICiQA Want to buy us a cup of coffee (Or a lighthouse)? Check out https://www.buymeacoffee.c…

1
Episode 86: Tom Green | Polygamy, Prophets & A Disturbing Abuse of Faith 1:07:30

8M ago1:07:30

1:07:30

In this episode we venture to Utah and meet a man of little character and how he created a plural family in the most disgusting way possible. We will find out the disturbing real life of sister wives in the 1990s, something TLC could never. Trigger Warnings: Child brides Child Rape Incestual Themes Hannah’s Story on Growing up in Polygamy https://y…